Ali Benarbia said:
Sir Knives said:
I don't know what game some of you were watching but Manchester City FC were anything but superb today. The team just basically did what it has been doing all season; doing enough to get by against less than average opposition and holding on for the win. Alot of the players need to be shown the door asap and replaced with players that can play with a bit of sense (and urgency). I also get the feeling Mr. Pellegrini doesn't get it at this level either, it just seems like the only things he cares about are formation and attacking, he has even sacrificed the once formidable defense this team was known for.
To become a European elite you have to change the way the team plays, everytime I watch City these days it feels like something is off, almost like you have all the ingredients of a top team but for some reason aren't making it happen, I never could quite put my finger on it but now I think it has dawned on me. I came to the conclusion that City lacks two things: 1) the ability to retain possession and 2) the ability to press correctly. To rule Europe you have to know how to keep the ball and move it well, have quick interplay, penetrating runs, etc but everytime I see a City player with the ball he either holds the ball far too long and takes unnecessary touches or he tries a sexy hollywood pass to a teammate that's 25 yards away, but watch a Barcelona, Chelsea, or Bayern and see how quickly they move the ball around with short passes and not giving the opposing team time to regroup, when they do lose possession it doesn't take long for them to get it back because they press, which brings me to my next point.
The players you have leak the ball like a sieve and I don't understand why so many expensively priced players can't win a ball back from the opposition, there were times today I would see some of your players practically give up balls that were easily chase-able and would scream and ask myself "Why did he let that go?" "Why not press?" I don't know whether pressing is not emphasized with Pellegrini or whether the players are just lazy but without it you can never be a top tier team. I can now understand why the people at the top want to go for Pep (if the stories are true), he's not just a manager but a coach that will bring this style of play into the team at the same time stamping his authority.
The Chelsea remark apart, he makes a good point. In fact he makes several. It's drilled into Pep's teams that if they lose the ball they are expected to get it back within 15 seconds or so.
It's not absolutely necessary to win the ball back with such haste though. It works for some teams, but there's plenty of other teams who don't and still manage to win games.
We don't have the skill level across the team to play like Barca. The likes of Silva and Aguero (and even Nasri in this specific regard) are great with rapid rapid and close control, but there's plenty in our team who just aren't that sort of player... they have different attributes.
Personally I think to become a European force it takes:
1) Time
We've really not been at for very long as a club, or even as a consistent team.
2) Better Players
We've had some wonderful players in recent years, but we've still been shopping in tier 2, and probably still will be for some time. Don't get me wrong, we've been buying some serious talent, but it's still not at the level of Bayern / Barca / Real. We still can't go out and buy Bale, or Suarez 'just because we can'.
3) Team Ethic
This is probably one of our biggest issues. We've got some players with a clear desire to do well for City, and some where it's questionable.
We aren't going to be a club that every young Spaniard or South American dreams of playing for. We are a club they are willing to play for at a price (and if we're lucky, they'll fall in love with us). One day we MIGHT become such a club, but right now, we're like 90% of other 'top' clubs... a step down from the European greats.
It's easy to say we should be like Barca, or Real, or Bayern etc, but the fact is, we need all three of the above before we can be serious about competing with them. We're a bloody good team, but not a European great one.