The Album Review Club - Week #144 - (page 1893) - XO - Elliot Smith

First of all, what a great nomination by @threespires ! Whether you liked it or not, it provoked a lot of great debate and discussion. And after all, that's what makes this thread so good!

I don't think my nomination will provoke the same reaction though. After the feistiness of the last week and the plethora of 1's I'm hoping this relaxing album will calm everyone down ha ha!

Here we go...

I once heard an idea/theory says that after a mad decade that started with the "Second Summer Of Love" around 1988, the next decade or so is just one stop party. House, RnB, Rap, Grunge and Britpop soundtracked the decade. If you were a youngster in that era, life felt like a long party (it did to me anyway!).

When inevitably happens next is that after that decade of hedonism, people get married, settle down and have kids. They move to the suburbs and can't think of anything worse than going out to a club till 4am then waking up with a baby to deal with. Instead of a wild night at an Indie club going mental to Oasis, you prefer to have a few friends (also with kids) around for house-parties instead. Nothing wild, just a nice meal with a few glasses of wine and good company.

But what music do you put on at your dinner party? House music might be a bit too uptempo and maybe the bass will wake the kids! Oasis has been done and grunge is a bit too loud. You don't want music that intrudes on the conversation. You want 'background music' and maybe something that hints at quiet sophistication. By the mid-2000s there were quite a few bands doing this laid-back, 'relaxing' sound such as Dido, Zero7, Norah Jones, Moby, Goldfrapp and maybe even Coldplay to some extent. I do think there's something in this and I know this band are one of my 'go tos' when I want some background music.

So what does this anecdote/theory have to do with my nomination? Well, my nomination is given as an example of the type of music you might've played at these dinner parties. It's soft, relaxing, background music which hints at that 'quiet sophistication'. I've also heard them described as a band who make soundtracks for films that don't exist. It's "Pocket Symphony" by Air and I think it's a brilliant album, but absolutely no way would I describe it as background music.

I discovered Air by hearing "Sexy Boy" back in the mid-90s and for a while, I assumed they were a bit of a joke band who got lucky with a one-hit-wonder, but I absolutely LOVE that song. It just sounded so completely different to anything else at the time and eventually after hearing "Kelly Watch The Stars" I bought album and fell in love with it. It's one of my all time favourite albums. Their next album wasn't much cop really and I kind of left them behind for about 15 years or so. When Spotify came out, I found "Sexy Boy" and eventually discovered these other albums they made and that's how I found "Pocket Symphony". That album and also "Talkie Walkie" saw them get back to their brilliant best and also develop their sound.

What I love about this album is the low-key cleverness to it. On the one hand it's modern easy listening and perfect dinner-party music. However, making something this easy to listen to yet with lots of little hooks to make it interesting is difficult to do. I'm also unsure at times whether this is an electronic album, or is it natural instruments with synths? As you'll know, I am a bit fan of synthesizer music and especially when it sounds earthly and organic. Air are the absolute masters of making synth-based music sound natural and organic and that's not easy. When they sing, their French accents only add to this other-worldly yet innocent sound.

When the direction of the album changes on Mer du Japon, Left Bank and One Hell Of A Party (with Jarvis Cocker) it breaks it up a bit, but the tracks just fit together so well. The album seems to have lots of different tracks but they all work well together.

As I've said before, I find that my music choices change as the seasons change. My music choice in winter is pretty music completely different to that in summer. However, when Spring and Autumn come around, I tend to find that it's a bit unsettled. I find in Winter that as the nights draw in, the years about to end I sometimes reflect on the last year and what's coming in the next year. It's perfect music to reflect to - Space Maker, Mayfair Song, Redhead Girl, Lost Message, Night Sight and Crickets in particular. They are incredibly atmospheric. You can put them on and just think about something else, but you can also listen to the tracks and just find so much beauty in there.

I never thought I'd be the type of person who could 'get' background/ambient music. When I was younger, I wanted it plain and in your face but as I've got older (more tolerant?) I really enjoy music that enables you to think about things and Air are perfect for that.

I've listened to this album hundreds of times since I found it. I do think terms like 'background music', 'easy listening' are negative terms to describe this style of music. I think it's a bit like my first nomination (Planetary Unfolding) in that when the music doesn't focus on lyrics so much, you have to 'dive into it' a bit more. Personally, as I'm getting older, I sometimes feel that words get in the way. A synth can say a 1000 words in a couple of seconds!

I love the understatedness of this album. I really hope you do too!
Brilliant review. But you were selling it to me so well until Jarvis Cocker turned up! I'll try not to let him spoil the rest of the album for me.

There was a free CD from Q Magazine 20-odd years ago that included Air's "La Femme d'argent", which is a brilliant instrumental. I guarantee that at least half of you will have heard that track on the TV at some point.

I didn't think much of the rest of Moon Safari when I listened, so it will be interesting to see how I feel about this album. I do remember enjoying your Michael Stearns pick though.
 
I wanted to take the top and bottom slots ;) Only joking of course, the thread isn't about the scores it's about listening to something out of your comfort zone!

I chose Revolver as basically, I couldn't. It's my all-time favourite album and as close to perfect as I can get. Musically it means so much to me and I pretty much judge all other albums from it.

It was the only album I opted out of after one spin (although heard it before). Partly because how overly sensitive a few here got. I preferred your, until recently, bottom of the list nomination to it which I thought was somewhat misunderstood.

But then your Jerry Lee album was my only ever 10, which is well reserved for something special. No idea what this one will bring.
 
Brilliant review. But you were selling it to me so well until Jarvis Cocker turned up! I'll try not to let him spoil the rest of the album for me.

There was a free CD from Q Magazine 20-odd years ago that included Air's "La Femme d'argent", which is a brilliant instrumental. I guarantee that at least half of you will have heard that track on the TV at some point.

I didn't think much of the rest of Moon Safari when I listened, so it will be interesting to see how I feel about this album. I do remember enjoying your Michael Stearns pick though.
Pocket Symphony and Talkie Walkie sound different to Moon Safari in my view, I would say they've found a style which I personally like.

Funnily rnough I love Pulp and they were amazing at the Castlefeld Bowl a few months ago...but his track is the worst one on the album :)
 
First of all, what a great nomination by @threespires ! Whether you liked it or not, it provoked a lot of great debate and discussion. And after all, that's what makes this thread so good!

I don't think my nomination will provoke the same reaction though. After the feistiness of the last week and the plethora of 1's I'm hoping this relaxing album will calm everyone down ha ha!

Here we go...

I once heard an idea/theory says that after a mad decade that started with the "Second Summer Of Love" around 1988, the next decade or so is just one stop party. House, RnB, Rap, Grunge and Britpop soundtracked the decade. If you were a youngster in that era, life felt like a long party (it did to me anyway!).

When inevitably happens next is that after that decade of hedonism, people get married, settle down and have kids. They move to the suburbs and can't think of anything worse than going out to a club till 4am then waking up with a baby to deal with. Instead of a wild night at an Indie club going mental to Oasis, you prefer to have a few friends (also with kids) around for house-parties instead. Nothing wild, just a nice meal with a few glasses of wine and good company.

But what music do you put on at your dinner party? House music might be a bit too uptempo and maybe the bass will wake the kids! Oasis has been done and grunge is a bit too loud. You don't want music that intrudes on the conversation. You want 'background music' and maybe something that hints at quiet sophistication. By the mid-2000s there were quite a few bands doing this laid-back, 'relaxing' sound such as Dido, Zero7, Norah Jones, Moby, Goldfrapp and maybe even Coldplay to some extent. I do think there's something in this and I know this band are one of my 'go tos' when I want some background music.

So what does this anecdote/theory have to do with my nomination? Well, my nomination is given as an example of the type of music you might've played at these dinner parties. It's soft, relaxing, background music which hints at that 'quiet sophistication'. I've also heard them described as a band who make soundtracks for films that don't exist. It's "Pocket Symphony" by Air and I think it's a brilliant album, but absolutely no way would I describe it as background music.

I discovered Air by hearing "Sexy Boy" back in the mid-90s and for a while, I assumed they were a bit of a joke band who got lucky with a one-hit-wonder, but I absolutely LOVE that song. It just sounded so completely different to anything else at the time and eventually after hearing "Kelly Watch The Stars" I bought album and fell in love with it. It's one of my all time favourite albums. Their next album wasn't much cop really and I kind of left them behind for about 15 years or so. When Spotify came out, I found "Sexy Boy" and eventually discovered these other albums they made and that's how I found "Pocket Symphony". That album and also "Talkie Walkie" saw them get back to their brilliant best and also develop their sound.

What I love about this album is the low-key cleverness to it. On the one hand it's modern easy listening and perfect dinner-party music. However, making something this easy to listen to yet with lots of little hooks to make it interesting is difficult to do. I'm also unsure at times whether this is an electronic album, or is it natural instruments with synths? As you'll know, I am a bit fan of synthesizer music and especially when it sounds earthly and organic. Air are the absolute masters of making synth-based music sound natural and organic and that's not easy. When they sing, their French accents only add to this other-worldly yet innocent sound.

When the direction of the album changes on Mer du Japon, Left Bank and One Hell Of A Party (with Jarvis Cocker) it breaks it up a bit, but the tracks just fit together so well. The album seems to have lots of different tracks but they all work well together.

As I've said before, I find that my music choices change as the seasons change. My music choice in winter is pretty music completely different to that in summer. However, when Spring and Autumn come around, I tend to find that it's a bit unsettled. I find in Winter that as the nights draw in, the years about to end I sometimes reflect on the last year and what's coming in the next year. It's perfect music to reflect to - Space Maker, Mayfair Song, Redhead Girl, Lost Message, Night Sight and Crickets in particular. They are incredibly atmospheric. You can put them on and just think about something else, but you can also listen to the tracks and just find so much beauty in there.

I never thought I'd be the type of person who could 'get' background/ambient music. When I was younger, I wanted it plain and in your face but as I've got older (more tolerant?) I really enjoy music that enables you to think about things and Air are perfect for that.

I've listened to this album hundreds of times since I found it. I do think terms like 'background music', 'easy listening' are negative terms to describe this style of music. I think it's a bit like my first nomination (Planetary Unfolding) in that when the music doesn't focus on lyrics so much, you have to 'dive into it' a bit more. Personally, as I'm getting older, I sometimes feel that words get in the way. A synth can say a 1000 words in a couple of seconds!

I love the understatedness of this album. I really hope you do too!

A cracking write up with loads to ponder.

I've never really thought about the seasonality of my listening other than maybe at Christmas and on holidays but I'm sure subliminally it must affect us all. I have a feeling the only time I listen to any R&B (modern usage of the term) is in summer.

As for dinner party music, the older I get the more I adopt the 'if you're up for eating my food, then you can jolly well listen to my choice in music too" approach to feeding people :-) selfish but works for me. For better or worse I've seen a few of the laid back dinner party acts you name check, including Norah Jones before she took off with her first album. I remember it because as talented as she was I think she had the least stage presence of anyone I'd ever seen and a slightly apologetic air of I'd much rather be doing this for myself at home.

I'm not really familiar with Air as, despite a great liking for an old school analog synth, Sexy Boy didn't do it for me so I missed out when Moon Safari was getting a lot of praise. However I'd be surprised if there wasn't something for me to like here. In the spirit of the nomination I will try this nomination in a number of settings: as the background music to a meal, with my full concentration and maybe as the background to another tasks.
 
As for dinner party music, the older I get the more I adopt the 'if you're up for eating my food, then you can jolly well listen to my choice in music too" approach to feeding people :-) selfish but works for me.
You've got that right! The good thing about having a varied background, one can usually find something in between styles that the other party might really appreciate, that's what I find most rewarding.
I'm not really familiar with Air as, despite a great liking for an old school analog synth, Sexy Boy didn't do it for me so I missed out when Moon Safari was getting a lot of praise. However I'd be surprised if there wasn't something for me to like here. In the spirit of the nomination I will try this nomination in a number of settings: as the background music to a meal, with my full concentration and maybe as the background to another tasks.
That's a great idea, I'm planning to do the same.
 
Thanks to this thread and some of my other leanings, Spotify has me down with 30 genres and "only one place (in the world) listened like you", which was....

Stockport, UK

My top song was "Death Dream" by Frightened Rabbit (19x). 423 artists, some definitely aided by this thread. "Old Engine Oil" by the Budos Band also made my Top 10. @Coatigan my top influencer! ;-)

Thanking this thread for the variety and some new favorites!

I agree that album scores don't matter, and experiencing (new) music and adding to life's memories can't be beat.
 
Thanks to this thread and some of my other leanings, Spotify has me down with 30 genres and "only one place (in the world) listened like you", which was....

Stockport, UK

My top song was "Death Dream" by Frightened Rabbit (19x). 423 artists, some definitely aided by this thread. "Old Engine Oil" by the Budos Band also made my Top 10. @Coatigan my top influencer! ;-)

Thanking this thread for the variety and some new favorites!

I agree that album scores don't matter, and experiencing (new) music and adding to life's memories can't be beat.
I am much more narrow minded than you, 18 genre, and the only place to have good taste like mine is Bozeman, USA. I think I might take a visit :)
 
Thanks to this thread and some of my other leanings, Spotify has me down with 30 genres and "only one place (in the world) listened like you", which was....

Stockport, UK

My top song was "Death Dream" by Frightened Rabbit (19x). 423 artists, some definitely aided by this thread. "Old Engine Oil" by the Budos Band also made my Top 10. @Coatigan my top influencer! ;-)

Thanking this thread for the variety and some new favorites!

I agree that album scores don't matter, and experiencing (new) music and adding to life's memories can't be beat.

I'm on 1,328 artists, supposedly 54 genres (Although I call shite on that one, there wil be many made-up genres there), 3,292 songs. So, much to learn you have my young padawan ;).

In fairness between this and the playlist threads, no doubt there is a big boost to that.

My top song was played 133 times, and 4 of my top 5 songs are from the one album. Maybe that says I should be putting that album forward. And likely challenging threespires for the bottom spot.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.