The bent referee - complain.

ForzaMancini said:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0YiuSbBdaQ[/youtube]

If any referee allows this goal to stand then they certainly should never be put in charge of Premier League games.
Click to expand...
That's him.

I doubt we will ever see a more incompetent ref ever again.
 
mancitygaz said:
ForzaMancini said:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0YiuSbBdaQ[/youtube]

If any referee allows this goal to stand then they certainly should never be put in charge of Premier League games.
Click to expand...
That's him.

I doubt we will ever see a more incompetent ref ever again.
Click to expand...
Posted it above, and some comments from another ref that I know.

He's now on the international panel, its a complete joke.
 
One of the worst reffing performances ive seen. He was a top flight ref (i think) in his early 20's. Good example of someone who has never played the game, but thinks he understands it.

Is not good enough for the prem.
 
ban-mcfc said:
Judge Roughneck said:
fucking absolute bollocks, yaya toure basically got bummed in the lead up to their penalty claim and Attwell did fuck all.

what about silva getting fucked over and shitwell doing nothing?

oh and balotelli, again..... nothing.

that is honestly the worst display of refereeing i've ever seen. even worse than walton with the scouse cunts.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

That Balotelli one made me go ballistic, how on Earth was it their free kick, when Mario got fucking jumped on and nearly over?!
 
Maybe some fans are bottlers and lose the plot too easily?

Ref had a poor game, but I've seen worse.

Crowd developing too much tension. It's only October. What will it be like in March?
 
Yeah, the ref wasn't bent. There were no orders from high above or from a big brown envelope with "FROM ALIX FURGASUN xxx" on it... The guy was just a fucking idiot who has somehow managed to find himself refereeing a premier league football match that involved making decisions.
 
cleavers said:
Marvin said:
Ref had a poor game, but I've seen worse.
Click to expand...
but not since Rob Styles, and Graham Poll.

It was worse than poor, it was incompetent, as bad for Wolves as he was for us, but he has history for it, dreadful referee.
Click to expand...
We should have been two up at half time,that's not the refs fault.

What is his fault is his complete lack of ability to ref a game.
 
I haven't seen a worse ref for years!

He is a 'Hollywood ref',that means it is all about him and he wants to be in the spotlight,when you never notice the best refs.

A few boos and he took it personal and went out of his way to give us even less.I was actually amazed he allowed our first goal.

Poor old Mick McCarthy thought we were booing City at half time the moron,when we were actually booing the ref,lol!
 
He was shit but we are good enough for it not to matter. Fuck complaining, it will acheive nothing, leave it to the assessors.

And as for suggesting he is corrupt, do me a favour love, it's just incompetence
 
paulchapo said:
I haven't seen a worse ref for years!

He is a 'Hollywood ref',that means it is all about him and he wants to be in the spotlight,when you never notice the best refs.

A few boos and he took it personal and went out of his way to give us even less.I was actually amazed he allowed our first goal.

Poor old Mick McCarthy thought we were booing City at half time the moron,when we were actually booing the ref,lol!
Click to expand...

What decisions riled you?
 
mancitygaz said:
What is his fault is his complete lack of ability to ref a game.
Click to expand...
Yes that's it in a nutshell, as I mentioned above I know someone who knows him through refereeing, and has been a ref a while, he thinks he's out of his depth at this level, he is.
 
[quote="johnmc
What decisions riled you?[/quote]

I would say nearly all of them,plus his overall handling of the game was shocking.He let Wolves kick seven bells out of City players,giving them no protection and timewaste until they went behind.

There was one occasion Silva was just whacked,the player nowhere near the ball,he allowed play on but never even spoke to the player when the game was stopped.

He was complete and utter shite!

Probably one of the very few decisions he got right was the penalty and sending off,even if it went against us.
 
FeedTheGoat10 said:
He was shit but we've had plenty worse over the years. Only reason this stands out is because this season we've been getting favourable decisions in the other matches.
Click to expand...

George Courtney at Maine Road, gave Liverpool 3? penalties. We have had some shockers down the years. Atwell today was as bad as I've seen for a long long while.<br /><br />-- Sun Oct 30, 2011 1:07 am --<br /><br />
johnmc said:
paulchapo said:
I haven't seen a worse ref for years!

He is a 'Hollywood ref',that means it is all about him and he wants to be in the spotlight,when you never notice the best refs.

A few boos and he took it personal and went out of his way to give us even less.I was actually amazed he allowed our first goal.

Poor old Mick McCarthy thought we were booing City at half time the moron,when we were actually booing the ref,lol!
Click to expand...

What decisions riled you?
Click to expand...

The problem that I found with him was he'd give a free kick for say minimal contact by one of our players, but when exactly the same happened in reverse we didn't get the free kick. Silva was floored from behind twice and we didn't even get a free kick. Micah was clearly tripped nothing given. Before they scored I'm sure yaya was fouled at least twice nothing given. Totally inept, and I hope we never see him again any time soon!! He makes Clattenburg look top class.
 
He is an all round poor referee and the FA should just get rid. He invents goals (watford v reading) he has been demoted so many times they just seem to keep hold of him because he was touted as the future, youngest referee, rubbish......... from my point of view there was no consistency. Hennesy able to take his time over goal kicks whereas Joe was told to hurry up..... slightest challenge from a city player drew a free kick yet on a number of occassions I could swear he was actually looking away from the action as if distracted...<br /><br />-- Sun Oct 30, 2011 1:40 am --<br /><br />He is an all round poor referee and the FA should just get rid. He invents goals (watford v reading) he has been demoted so many times they just seem to keep hold of him because he was touted as the future, youngest referee, rubbish......... from my point of view there was no consistency. Hennesy able to take his time over goal kicks whereas Joe was told to hurry up..... slightest challenge from a city player drew a free kick yet on a number of occassions I could swear he was actually looking away from the action as if distracted...
 
Pam said:
http://www.footballreferee.org/contact.php

Link to make a futile complaint about the cheating rag, Attwood.

"I have just returned home from the Manchester City V Wolves game - 29th October 2011. That was one of the most breathtakingly corrupt and unforgivable refereeing performances it has ever been my misfortune to witness. Stuart Atwell is a disgrace and an embarrassment. There is no earthly explanation for what took place at the Etihad today. It is time to kick out the cheat. He has brought your Association into disrepute and should never be permitted to officiate a a Manchester City game again. I strongly urge that this matter be scrutinised as a matter of urgency. Shocking.
"
Click to expand...
Give it a fucking a rest!
 
paulchapo said:
Poor old Mick McCarthy thought we were booing City at half time the moron,when we were actually booing the ref,lol!
Click to expand...

Surely you jest. What did he say?
 
paulchapo said:
[quote="johnmc
What decisions riled you?
Click to expand...

I would say nearly all of them,plus his overall handling of the game was shocking.He let Wolves kick seven bells out of City players,giving them no protection and timewaste until they went behind.

There was one occasion Silva was just whacked,the player nowhere near the ball,he allowed play on but never even spoke to the player when the game was stopped.

He was complete and utter shite!

Probably one of the very few decisions he got right was the penalty and sending off,even if it went against us.[/quote]

Which was about thirty seconds after he'd booked another one of our players for a far less serious foul.
 
MCFC BOB said:
Refs have good days and bad days like players do.

We won, we're top. Let's rejoice.

-- October 30th, 2011, 2:39 am --

Refs have good days and bad days like players do.

We won, we're top. Let's rejoice.
Click to expand...
Very true, but this wasn't a ref having a bad day.

Shocking performance Atwell
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top