The Bluemoon Song Cup 2023

Not sure U2 have fielded their best striker here Jeff, I'd have been tempted to start with Blige up front with the gobby fella playing behind her Jeff; and if that's not working then chuck on Timmins for the last 10 minutes Jeff.
It is interesting how some well known artists have been selected but with oddball choices.

I think it's good that out of 160 songs, which is a pretty short list in the grand scheme of things, there have been a lot of surprise choices.

And still we wait for Dylan, The Stones, The Who and The Beatles .......
 
For the first time I find myself abstaining. I don't get James, one or two songs apart and I don't get U2. Their track is marginally better but they're both a nah really.
 
I think its important to acknowledge that Bono is a bit of a nob. And U2 may have some good songs - but its all comes with a strong whiff of cheese.

James are a solid indie band, but putting predjudice aside, is this song better? Have to give this some thought.
 
I think its important to acknowledge that Bono is a bit of a nob. And U2 may have some good songs - but its all comes with a strong whiff of cheese.

James are a solid indie band, but putting predjudice aside, is this song better? Have to give this some thought.

It's not and U2 gets my vote.
 
It is interesting how some well known artists have been selected but with oddball choices.

I think it's good that out of 160 songs, which is a pretty short list in the grand scheme of things, there have been a lot of surprise choices.

And still we wait for Dylan, The Stones, The Who and The Beatles .......

I had a pick earlier in the competition where this was referenced.

There were songs from that particular artist that were more well known, but my choice was my favourite of theirs (although it did then lose as a result).

I wasn't in it to win the cup initially, I just picked songs I like. However, with some of the other picks I'm growing a bit more confident one of mine can go on and win the Southgate book!
 
I think its important to acknowledge that Bono is a bit of a nob. And U2 may have some good songs - but its all comes with a strong whiff of cheese.

James are a solid indie band, but putting predjudice aside, is this song better? Have to give this some thought.

For all I know if you peel the onion Paul Hewson might be a very nice fella but Bono comes across as a sanctimonious twat and it does make a difference I think. Take this song which I think is a decent enough one but would be much better sung with authentic vulnerability rather than the faux kind and the slightly hectoring tone I've always thought it had (don't mind being 'preached to' in music after all soul was born out of gospel, but that's different from being 'preached at' if that makes sense)

Then we have Tim Booth doing his version of Jim Kerr's slightly less badly dressed little brother on this particular James track.

Decisions.
 
I had a pick earlier in the competition where this was referenced.

There were songs from that particular artist that were more well known, but my choice was my favourite of theirs (although it did then lose as a result).

I wasn't in it to win the cup initially, I just picked songs I like. However, with some of the other picks I'm growing a bit more confident one of mine can go on and win the Southgate book!
Reading my comment back, I forgot to add my final sentence, which was that the competition has been better for the oddball and surprising choices. Nobody wants every pick to be songs that always appear in the "Top 100 songs ever" list. It's good to have a few of those, but the mix on here has been surprisingly good so far.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.