Weloveyoucitywedo
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jun 2012
- Messages
- 51
fair enough, people usually go off accent when they hear people speak though
Dirty Harry said:And that's a flaw because...? No United fans have moved out of the City?Vic said:Doesn't surprise me at all, this 'study' had basic flaws right from the off, at the time our kid was an ST holder living in Chester, I was living in either Chorley or Stockport, he was born at the MRI, I was born at Withington, both of us grew up in Fallowfield and Wythenshawe, yet we will have been shown as 'out of towners', as ever, a poor show and this will be no different, sad bastards
It's covered by the report (72% of United s.t. holders and 78% of City s.t. holders lived within the North West) - which means 28% of United's s.t. holders lived outside the region (so not all from London). Otherwise why are people so keen to diss a report which proved there were more City s.t. holders in the City of Manchester than United s.t. holders? And more in adjoining SK and most OL postcodes too.
Just ignore the snappy title then, and read the report. How can stats on s.t. holders addresses be an unreliable source of data?Point to where I said or even indicated that vic ?
Firstly the title :-
'DO YOU COME FROM MANCHESTER ?
That title indicates its (true) intentions to show an accurate representation of Mancunians (supporting either club), it's a simple question and a simple answer, so yes, we do come from Manchester (as per previous post).
Yet, it goes on to say 'a postcode analysis of the location of etc etc' and use that as its basis for its findings, so, straight away the figures will be flawed as it only takes into account the current (then) address of the ST holder, with this in mind because we lived at addresses outside of Manchester that now disqualifies us from fitting the original question/criteria as 'coming from Manchester' ?
In short, we fit the required criteria to answer the fundamental and most important question, but it then goes on to use a totally different and for many an unreliable source of data to establish this, so immediately the figures (for both sides) will be flawed you catch my drift ?
Vic said:Just ignore the snappy title then, and read the report. How can stats on s.t. holders addresses be an unreliable source of data?
Anyway, it's the "data" behind the rightmove "survey" that are suspect. Apparently 13% of City fans live in M11, but only 15% in the whole City!
black mamba said:13.2% of the 500 people polled were City fans from the local area , whereas only 8.6% of rags were ........
how does that make them better supported 'locally'?????