This weekends other Prem Games 13/14 Sept 2014

[supercrystal7]

Di Maria is class but take him instead of magic dave get to fuck. Silva and do maria are compl

If silva was playing for barca or Real Madrid he'd be nominated for a Balon d or. Seriously under rated.

It's just not true. The reason Silva does not play for Barca in particular who he would fit in better is because they have better players. He is not on the level of Iniesta, Xavi or Messi. It's very biased to suggest so. Even for Spain he has to take a backstage to the true stars of the Spanish team. He is not underrated. He is a great 10 and one of the best players in the Premiership, but he is not on the level of the Barca boys and either is Di Maria for that matter.

Respect your opinion, but your talking absolute nonsense here.

We will have to agree to disagree, but I don't think anyone except a City fan would ever suggest that Silva was as good as Xavi, Iniesta or Messi.

 

[stony]

I would take him over Silva. I would not take him over a Yaya 3 years younger though. When looking at prices you also have to take into account inflation and football inflation. Silva and Yaya would have probably gone for at around 35+ million now and Aguero probably would have been at least 50 million.

Di Maria is class but take him instead of magic dave get to fuck. Silva and do maria are compl

If silva was playing for barca or Real Madrid he'd be nominated for a Balon d or. Seriously under rated.

It's just not true. The reason Silva does not play for Barca in particular who he would fit in better is because they have better players. He is not on the level of Iniesta, Xavi or Messi. It's very biased to suggest so. Even for Spain he has to take a backstage to the true stars of the Spanish team. He is not underrated. He is a great 10 and one of the best players in the Premiership, but he is not on the level of the Barca boys and either is Di Maria for that matter.

I don't agree. I don't think there's much between Silva and the players you name. He's the best player in the Prem by some distance.

 

[Le Havre Oswald]

I would take him over Silva. I would not take him over a Yaya 3 years younger though. When looking at prices you also have to take into account inflation and football inflation. Silva and Yaya would have probably gone for at around 35+ million now and Aguero probably would have been at least 50 million.

Di Maria is class but take him instead of magic dave get to fuck. Silva and do maria are compl

If silva was playing for barca or Real Madrid he'd be nominated for a Balon d or. Seriously under rated.

It's just not true. The reason Silva does not play for Barca in particular who he would fit in better is because they have better players. He is not on the level of Iniesta, Xavi or Messi. It's very biased to suggest so. Even for Spain he has to take a backstage to the true stars of the Spanish team. He is not underrated. He is a great 10 and one of the best players in the Premiership, but he is not on the level of the Barca boys and either is Di Maria for that matter.

the reason he's not at barca or any other team is is because he plays for city. xavi and iniesta are getting on a bit now anyway. Right now you won't find 5 players better at slowing and speeding up play than silva. He's not at Ronaldo and messi's level because no one is, but he sure is In that very small bracket behind them.

 

[City_Sean]

It's just not true. The reason Silva does not play for Barca in particular who he would fit in better is because they have better players. He is not on the level of Iniesta, Xavi or Messi. It's very biased to suggest so. Even for Spain he has to take a backstage to the true stars of the Spanish team. He is not underrated. He is a great 10 and one of the best players in the Premiership, but he is not on the level of the Barca boys and either is Di Maria for that matter.

Respect your opinion, but your talking absolute nonsense here.

We will have to agree to disagree, but I don't think anyone except a City fan would ever suggest that Silva was as good as Xavi, Iniesta or Messi.

That's because most non City fans don't watch David Silva play every game, those who do realise he's world class and arguably the best playmaker on the planet.

 

[supercrystal7]

Di Maria is class but take him instead of magic dave get to fuck. Silva and do maria are compl

If silva was playing for barca or Real Madrid he'd be nominated for a Balon d or. Seriously under rated.

It's just not true. The reason Silva does not play for Barca in particular who he would fit in better is because they have better players. He is not on the level of Iniesta, Xavi or Messi. It's very biased to suggest so. Even for Spain he has to take a backstage to the true stars of the Spanish team. He is not underrated. He is a great 10 and one of the best players in the Premiership, but he is not on the level of the Barca boys and either is Di Maria for that matter.

I don't agree. I don't think there's much between Silva and the players you name. He's the best player in the Prem by some distance.

I would say that depends on Yaya. I would say over the last few years Toure has been better than Silva, but it is close. I have a feeling that with Yaya's age he may be on the decline now, but Di Maria, Falcao, Aguero are all possibly better than Silva and Hazard has the potential too.

 

[Sky Blue]

No, I'd want him with Silva. Like Tyler said a couple of times, that's what £60m gets.

So roughly twice the price of kun and 2 1/2 times the price of Siva and toure ?

I would take him over Silva. I would not take him over a Yaya 3 years younger though. When looking at prices you also have to take into account inflation and football inflation. Silva and Yaya would have probably gone for at around 35+ million now and Aguero probably would have been at least 50 million.

A good laugh from me will suffice......

 

[supercrystal7]

Respect your opinion, but your talking absolute nonsense here.

We will have to agree to disagree, but I don't think anyone except a City fan would ever suggest that Silva was as good as Xavi, Iniesta or Messi.

That's because most non City fans don't watch David Silva play every game, those who do realise he's world class and arguably the best playmaker on the planet.

Sorry that's just a poor excuse. Lots of people watch City every week. City are the champions and probably have been the best team to watch in the country over the last 4 or so years. Virtually every City and Spain game is on T.V. That sort of argument really only works at the lower level where the casual fan cannot constantly watch them.

For example I have seen 4/5 games this season (including the Charity Shield) and I watched extended highlights of the Stoke game.

 

[uwe rosler 28]

So you would take him over Silva for example then ? Seriously what did he do today ?

No, I'd want him with Silva. Like Tyler said a couple of times, that's what £60m gets.

This, a player like Di Maria would work wonderfully with David. And again, he scored, assisted and ran the QPR back line ragged.

clint hill wio and caulker I'm not surprised he did! He's a very good player but lets see how he plays against very good athletic defenders! And there's only 4 players in world football I'd take over spanish dave iniesta messi ronaldo bale.

 

[Armaan]

If David Silva could finish he'd be as close to Messi and ronaldo as you could get. If he played for Barca or Real people would be wanking themselves silly over him.

 

[City_Sean]

We will have to agree to disagree, but I don't think anyone except a City fan would ever suggest that Silva was as good as Xavi, Iniesta or Messi.

That's because most non City fans don't watch David Silva play every game, those who do realise he's world class and arguably the best playmaker on the planet.

Sorry that's just a poor excuse. Lots of people watch City every week. City are the champions and probably have been the best team to watch in the country over the last 4 or so years. Virtually every City and Spain game is on T.V. That sort of argument really only works at the lower level where the casual fan cannot constantly watch them.

For example I have seen 4/5 games this season (including the Charity Shield) and I watched extended highlights of the Stoke game.

Then there's no reason for him not be highly rated by yourself and others, He'd be a regular starter at Barca, Real and even Bayern. He's that good.