Thought we'd signed a dud but turned out a diamond

[Edin’s header]

Garcia is looking more and more like another Steve Daley, only not as quick. For the love of god, i hope this fella improves.

 

[andy_aston]

Samaras

 

[mancjess]

AJ, even though he wasn't good enough to play for City
anyway, the goals were fantastic and he's better than SS until now

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

We are so missing Nigel de Jong it's unbelievable we got rid of him to bring in Garcia they are worlds apart

This!!

 

[BoyBlue_1985]

We are so missing Nigel de Jong it's unbelievable we got rid of him to bring in Garcia they are worlds apart

This!!

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo not this shit again

 

[Le Havre Oswald]

Robinho.

Oops that's the other way round

 

[bilko05]

garcia isnt strong enough end of.i gave him the benefit of the doubt v wigan after he bottled that tackle but last night he was pushed away from tackles....plus he moves like he has a piano on his back...a true dud!!!

 

[Mad Eyed Screamer]

Danny Tiatto - couldnt get a game (deservedly so) in the 3rd division, we move up a league and he's a star! Then in the Prem League too.

Maybe he just didn't fancy York away......

Richard Jobson too - what the fuck was that signing about...... but what a great signing it turned out to be

 

[Dethred]

I want to see how he played at Benfica and RM. Does anyone know specific matches he played in with either so I can see if this is form or lack of talent and determination... would be interested to see what Marwood saw in him.

 

[ifiwasarichfan]

A good idea this thread. Shame it got hijacked.

Exactly this. It could have been one of thoe really good trip down memory lane threads and has been ruined, about 6 posts in 9 pages answering the question.