TheRemainsOfTheDave
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 16 Mar 2017
- Messages
- 6,491
It is a show for TV not a documentary. They cannot cast 100os of people, each with complex story-lines
I think it's well filmed and gives different, if not basic, perspectives
They didn't need to have interaction between the two characters on Dunkirk beach, it was unnecessary and there were plenty of other people available. I'm still to be convinced how the man got from Warsaw (avoiding German and Russian forces) and got to Dunkirk by foot and bumping into British forces.
The injured brother didn't need to interact with the doctor in Paris (not sure he would have been taken there anyway from Dunkirk) as it served no purpose to the eventual path the brother would take.
The chance of bumping into someone in the middle of war-stricken Poland countryside is quite frankly ridiculous, this could have been handled by elevating the Polish girl's story into being rescued by Polish resistance forces and somehow her getting a message back to her husband via the war office whereby he then decides to rescue her via this secret mission (of which we don't know much).
The injured brother didn't need to interact with the doctor in Paris (not sure he would have been taken there anyway from Dunkirk) as it served no purpose to the eventual path the brother would take.
The chance of bumping into someone in the middle of war-stricken Poland countryside is quite frankly ridiculous, this could have been handled by elevating the Polish girl's story into being rescued by Polish resistance forces and somehow her getting a message back to her husband via the war office whereby he then decides to rescue her via this secret mission (of which we don't know much).
It's a poorly written story in my opinion.