VAR - 2020/21

[edinburgh123]

What I do find very strange is that there are 2 real worlds, yours and the one that the rest of us live in. Despite your alleged belief that the majority of the people reside in yours, they don't.
VAR as a piece of equipment is not technically good enough to calculate when a player kicks the ball AND where abouts another player, further forward is. It is then left to clowns to make a decision.

So easy to fix though. Take 2 freeze frames. The one where contact with the ball has NOT been made and the very next one where contact has for the first time. The logic being the 'actual' point of contact must be somewhere between the two or actually literally at the second frame. You have to be offside on BOTH of the frames for offside to be given. Therefore going back (albeit slightly) to the forward getting the benefit of the doubt.

 

[aguero93:20]

Shrek wants VAR scrapped and the referee allowed to officiate the game. Funny that, he never seemed keen on letting them do that when he was playing.

 

[deegee33]

I'm not saying people are fine with it and I'm not saying I've any faith in it changing (unless it's IFAB mandated). I'm saying VAR isn't the issue, the implementation is.

Smart phone................Stupid user.

 

[tommy116]

Still looking for something on the Stones disallowed goal, was it ever looked at?

 

[stonerblue]

I think i have a right to say that, i like that poster want VAR but want it to be improved. i don't think for having that view makes me supportive of killing the game and being a c*nt.

I didn't see the game, but without VAR the penalty would have been given to Man U right ? regardless of it being offside.


How are the officials who operate it getting everything so wrong week after week?

firstly, there's no mention here of how many they get right - there has been hundreds of decisions which the refs would have normally got wrong, but checking VAR they realise player was offside or there was actually a foul.
this all goes very quiet.

however, there are still to many times where officials have checked and still got it wrong - Dean/Mason last week, they have been absolutely slaughtered, and they don't have a excuse of not seeing it again. I think there would have been less uproar without VAR because we got so accustomed to bad decisions.

No system is going to be 100% perfect, i really have to repeat that, otherwise we can all point at decisions and say 'explain that then ?!' and it will go on forever, but just because a system isn't 100% perfect, it can still be a better alternative to before.

I am just as angry as anyone when refs fuck up and more so with the benefit of VAR. refs need better training and more transparency, a lot of good suggestions, ie: refs being miked up. could be a solution.

Whilst i disagree completely with your views on var theres no need for posters to get personal with you. Bang out of order.

 

[Eds]

Still looking for something on the Stones disallowed goal, was it ever looked at?

It's in the same file as the Salah goal against us from last season. Find one you will find the other...

 

[Blue Mist]

Whilst i disagree completely with your views on var theres no need for posters to get personal with you. Bang out of order.

@stonerblue if he had not started the childish posts most others would not have replied with the same. Also, had he not peddled lies about the vast majority of people wanting it, most would have left it as a personal opinion by him. The team he supports does not matter, his opinion is as good as anyone's, it is the way he puts it over the annoys posters.

 

[stonerblue]

@stonerblue if he had not started the childish posts most others would not have replied with the same. Also, had he not peddled lies about the vast majority of people wanting it, most would have left it as a personal opinion by him. The team he supports does not matter, his opinion is as good as anyone's, it is the way he puts it over the annoys posters.

His posts annoy the fuck out of me but i don't get personal with him.
Also not sure he's been 'childish' or at least i haven't seen it.

 

[Bluearmy]

But Leicester would of had a penalty as Taylor pointed to the spot

It was outside (just) the box! The decision was correct, which surely is the point of VAR!!

 

[Bluearmy]

So 2 out of 3 pundits thought this challenge was inside the box? Am I missing something?

No you are not, but the idiot pundits are. No idea how u can look at that and then say it was inside. Defies belief.....