VAR Discussion Thread - 2023/24 | PL clubs to vote on whether to scrap VAR (pg413)

Would you want VAR scrapped?


  • Total voters
    293
  • Poll closed .
They should show the ground replays of decisions that validate the refs on-field decision. Not just things the ref has missed and has had to award after viewing replays himself on the monitor.

Can you imagine them chanting "Cheats.. Cheats.. Cheats.." then a replay runs of the ball hitting Alvarez on the chin and shuts them down mid chant.
Cant show replays in the ground. And we all know why
 
So, I was right then they dont

IFAB categorically state that no outside influence is permitted in the VAR room. This obviously includes TV commentary.

Obviously some people will refuse to believe that but you can only really debate the procedure as laid out, unless there is evidence to the contrary.
 
IFAB categorically state that no outside influence is permitted in the VAR room. This obviously includes TV commentary.

Obviously some people will refuse to believe that but you can only really debate the procedure as laid out, unless there is evidence to the contrary.
Darren Fletcher confirmed this after the palace pen. He said all they are permitted to hear are the word "VAR Check"/"Check complete Offside" etc.

It was nice to hear someone have that candour.

That's why we need cunts like Ratboy and Spitty removed because their opinion when they sound like they appealing to the VAR room makes fans think they maybe influencing Stockley Park.
 
Cant show replays in the ground. And we all know why
but they do show replays, right now it's only after the ref has been sent to the monitor to give a pen or a send a player off.

I think they should expand it showing video replay that backs up on-field decisions that were correct ie was the ball out of play? was it handball? etc. They could show a replay just before the game is restarted by kick-off.
 
but they do show replays, right now it's only after the ref has been sent to the monitor to give a pen or a send a player off.

I think they should expand it showing video replay that backs up on-field decisions that were correct ie was the ball out of play? was it handball? etc. They could show a replay just before the game is restarted by kick-off.
On the big screen?
 
but they do show replays, right now it's only after the ref has been sent to the monitor to give a pen or a send a player off.

I think they should expand it showing video replay that backs up on-field decisions that were correct ie was the ball out of play? was it handball? etc. They could show a replay just before the game is restarted by kick-off.

It’s a long standing rule that pre dates VAR, that they can’t show anything on the big screens that may be deemed ‘controversial’

A couple of teams have been fined for it. Tottenham I seem to remember showed something that went against them, that turned the crowd.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.