VAR Discussion Thread - 2023/24 | PL clubs to vote on whether to scrap VAR (pg413)

Would you want VAR scrapped?

  • Total voters
    293
  • Poll closed .
BlueHammer85 said:
West Brom casually tipping it over the bar to deny a certain goal. Corner kick given.

LView attachment 109447
Click to expand...

Are you really going to post on here every time VAR gets something "right" or a game without VAR makes a mistake? You want me to post every time a goal is disallowed for an offside that no one could judge by sight, or that is disallowed for an appendage being offside whilst gaining absolutely no advantage, or every offside decision given within the possible tolerance of the technology, or every decision that shows an offence that isn't given by VAR because it wasn't given on-field, or , I don't know, any game changing incident that isn't looked at because "protocol".

Wouldn't that be annoying? Well, you can imagine how the rest of us feel. We get it, you think VAR is good and, somehow, mistakes shouldn't be made. Some of us think the whole thing isn't worth it. Anything to actually discuss further on the merits?

Btw, I see you have modified your stance on diving to "non-contact dives" now. That's convenient.
 
halfcenturyup said:
Are you really going to post on here every time VAR gets something "right" or a game without VAR makes a mistake? You want me to post every time a goal is disallowed for an offside that no one could judge by sight, or that is disallowed for an appendage being offside whilst gaining absolutely no advantage, or every offside decision given within the possible tolerance of the technology, or every decision that shows an offence that isn't given by VAR because it wasn't given on-field, or , I don't know, any game changing incident that isn't looked at because "protocol".

Wouldn't that be annoying? Well, you can imagine how the rest of us feel. We get it, you think VAR is good and, somehow, mistakes shouldn't be made. Some of us think the whole thing isn't worth it. Anything to actually discuss further on the merits?

Btw, I see you have modified your stance on diving to "non-contact dives" now. That's convenient.
Click to expand...
He is fucking annoying
 
halfcenturyup said:
Are you really going to post on here every time VAR gets something "right" or a game without VAR makes a mistake? You want me to post every time a goal is disallowed for an offside that no one could judge by sight, or that is disallowed for an appendage being offside whilst gaining absolutely no advantage, or every offside decision given within the possible tolerance of the technology, or every decision that shows an offence that isn't given by VAR because it wasn't given on-field, or , I don't know, any game changing incident that isn't looked at because "protocol".

Wouldn't that be annoying? Well, you can imagine how the rest of us feel. We get it, you think VAR is good and, somehow, mistakes shouldn't be made. Some of us think the whole thing isn't worth it. Anything to actually discuss further on the merits?

Btw, I see you have modified your stance on diving to "non-contact dives" now. That's convenient.
Click to expand...

So only allowed to post when VAR makes a mistake/some fans disagree with ?
 
halfcenturyup said:
Are you really going to post on here every time VAR gets something "right" or a game without VAR makes a mistake? You want me to post every time a goal is disallowed for an offside that no one could judge by sight, or that is disallowed for an appendage being offside whilst gaining absolutely no advantage, or every offside decision given within the possible tolerance of the technology, or every decision that shows an offence that isn't given by VAR because it wasn't given on-field, or , I don't know, any game changing incident that isn't looked at because "protocol".

Wouldn't that be annoying? Well, you can imagine how the rest of us feel. We get it, you think VAR is good and, somehow, mistakes shouldn't be made. Some of us think the whole thing isn't worth it. Anything to actually discuss further on the merits?

Btw, I see you have modified your stance on diving to "non-contact dives" now. That's convenient.
Click to expand...
100%
 
I've waited ages for a ref to check the monitor and have the balls to stick by his original decision.. finally it happend... and it had to be against us Hammers FFS!! still watched many times and unsure myself so will suck that one up.
 
BlueHammer85 said:
West Brom casually tipping it over the bar to deny a certain goal. Corner kick given.

View attachment 109447
Click to expand...
It's just another example of how badly games are arbitrated. He appears to have more contact with the ball than Jack did in the final. Penalties seem to be awarded on the basis first of all whether there's been a penal offence, and then matched to the shirt colour and the current score.
 
stonerblue said:
No Yellow card for Salah's dive @BlueHammer85 ?

Would this be classed as a 'right' or 'wrong' decision when telling us what percentage var 'get right'?
Click to expand...

Not seen this one, have you got a clip ?

All players should get punished for diving and if it's really clear and obvious they should get retrospective bans imo.

that aside, i notice Liverpool fans in meltdown and crying corruption because they didn't get the penalty on the late challenge Doku made.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.