VAR (PL introduction 2019)

And of course when some dimwitted linesman fails to spot a player standing a foot or more offside right in front of his nose.
There's nothing dimwitted about Simon Beck, he knows exactly what he's doing. Looks after the old sky 4 and his beloved spurs.
 
I can already see next seasons controversies, they will include, why did they check X decision but not Y decision. I don't want this VAR crap, look at the way we got done over by it in the CL.
 
It doesn’t though, does it? The tech is nowhere near enough developed to get offsides right. The obvious ones maybe, but not all the ones it will be used for

It’s getting far more offside decisions correct than if we didn’t have VAR.
Liverpool wouldn’t have had those offside goals last season.
 
and if that goal denied you a win in a cup final ? or the title ? or a defeat to Liverpool ?

you may be able to brush it off, but majority of fans will be going mental in the stands,booing the ref off, bombarding forums saying the ref is corrupt and then the pundits make it the main talking point - if everyone had your blase attitude and could accept a ref gets it wrong on the odd occasion then we wouldn't be in a situation where VAR was required.
Correct.
I'll never forget (or forgive) Alf Grey!
 
Its literally turning competitions into a lottery of who will get awarded the most penalties.

Its an abomination.
 
What i dont understand about VAR is why has it regressed into the total shambles we have today from the relative success of the previous world cup.... ?

IMO its because they (Governing bodies/Refs) want it to fail.

Virtually everyone is in agreement as to how to implement it with total transparency, screens in grounds, all angles seen by VAR/ref seen by crowd and an open mic so everyone can hear what it is being discussed and said.

Not only will they not do that but they are literally allowing different rules for different leagues/competitions and making it up as they go along it seems with rule changes half way through competitions to suit.

Its an absolute farce.
 
Just be honest when you watch VAR in action has it enhanced your enjoyment of the greatest game in the world or not. The use of it for England ladies was farcical was it not? I’d rather keep the rules of football rather than create a new sport to suit VAR which if it was working would not be controversial ala the goal line tech.

The use of it in England ladies was not farcical..!! It resulted it a much fairer outcome. The England goal would have been ruled out incorrectly and the Cameroon goal would have stood incorrectly. A game that was at that point 2 nil, would have been changed to 1 all, totally unfairly...

The Cameroon behaviour, along with the refereeing performance was farcical...!!
 
IMO its because they (Governing bodies/Refs) want it to fail.

Virtually everyone is in agreement as to how to implement it with total transparency, screens in grounds, all angles seen by VAR/ref seen by crowd and an open mic so everyone can hear what it is being discussed and said.

Not only will they not do that but they are literally allowing different rules for different leagues/competitions and making it up as they go along it seems with rule changes half way through competitions to suit.

Its an absolute farce.

Bingo, the Cartel don't want it (All voted against it) so are trying to discredit it as best they can!!
 
VAR is certainly getting bad press with the women's world cup and I'm not sure it's fully warranted.

To me the refereeing authority has caused the problems.

For a start, the recent decision by some bright spark, possibly the great Collina himself, to change the handball rule is now looking quite ridiculous.

Previously, it was deemed a handball for doing it deliberately and gaining an advantage, which was fair enough and that deserves a booking.

But now, because if the ball accidentally hits any part of your arm (in the box only by the way), we have defenders trying to run around after forwards with their arms tied behind their backs.
It's laughable, I'd like to see that bright spark of a ref try it.

The instruction for the refs to award a penalty and yellow card if the ball hits any part of a defender's arm in the box, intentionally or not is preposterous and unfair.

It ruined the European Cup final in the first minute and many other games which have suffered severe injustices, because of it (PSG v United for example).

Another cracker from that bright spark ref, if a goalies foot is not on the line, not behind it, on it, the goalie has to be booked and a re-take.

Fair enough you say, but this is only applied if the penalty is missed, even if the shot misses the target completely and has little to do with the keeper.

But if a penalty is missed and the keeper is on the line, you know what's coming next, encroachment.
Players in box, yellow cards and re-take.

In most if not all of the above cases, these 'handballs' or ' foot on the line' issues, are only picked up by VAR, after super slow-mo checks, because previously refs would never have awarded stupid penalties like we're now witnessing.

It's why we had ex-pro footballer pundits arguing with the TV ref, Peter Walton, that these decisions weren't right.
Walton, the knob, instead of agreeing and saying the rule needs reverting back, argued that the rule was fine.

So, it isn't VAR that is ruining the game, it just shows what happened.

It was that bright spark ref, changing the rules, possibly not knowing he was destroying instead of enhancing the game.

I'd love it, if it was Collina.
 
Last edited:
VAR has increased the accuracy of decision from 92.5% to 98.1%. in womans world cup which is similar to Mens world cup.
This means a major decision will is missed in two more games a season without VAR than with it. Not every major decision mistake made ends up being match changing.
The question for every one is ... is that improvement worth the shit that comes with VAR?
 
Because it wasnt a success at the world cup. Keep swallowing the cartlel media shite.
I watched every game, I don't swallow or follow, it's my opinion based on what I saw, not what I read or someone told me .....!

Furthermore, read my post properly, I said relative success did I not..?
I fuckin hate VAR with a passion, it will kill the game..
 
Last edited:
VAR has increased the accuracy of decision from 92.5% to 98.1%. in womans world cup which is similar to Mens world cup.
This means a major decision will is missed in two more games a season without VAR than with it. Not every major decision mistake made ends up being match changing.
The question for every one is ... is that improvement worth the shit that comes with VAR?
In a word no.
 
VAR has increased the accuracy of decision from 92.5% to 98.1%. in womans world cup which is similar to Mens world cup.
This means a major decision will is missed in two more games a season without VAR than with it. Not every major decision mistake made ends up being match changing.
The question for every one is ... is that improvement worth the shit that comes with VAR?

giphy.gif
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top