Vincent Kompany

I think sacking him now would be pointless, they're not getting out of that mess, so why not just wait until the summer, and see what that brings, I think Vinny is a good coach, and he would be able to stabilise them again next year.

Laudable as it was to try and play football, you need the players to do it, especially up front where they've scored less than a goal game. The goals they concede, many of them are caused by errors, often from passing out from the back.
 
To be fair they were good at this style of play in the Championship and absolutely stormed the division for that reason. The problem they've had this season is flogging or dropping the players that made them tick and persisting with lads who don't have a clue how to carry out what's being asked of them. I think they just panicked and tried to put a "Premier League quality" side together but, as we've seen in the past, sometimes the team that wins the Championship is good enough to stay up in the top division.

But they lost Nathan Tella to Bayer Leverkusen. Manuel Benson and Jay Rodriguez barely play. They loaned Zaroury out to Hull. That's all four of their top goalscorers from last season either playing elsewhere or barely playing at all. Josh Cullen barely plays, Connor Roberts was loaned out to Leeds, Ian Maatsen was only on loan, and Ari Muric barely plays. That's four of their most-played players from last season either gone or benched. They made a big mistake by disrupting the chemistry of the team that won the Championship together.

Think Kompany deserves the chance to bring them back up. He's definitely shown that he's a more than capable manager for a Championship side and vastly out-performed expectations - lots of people were predicting another relegation for them because they had no money. Plus, Burnley allowed Dyche that luxury a couple of times and it paid off for them, I think. But whether Kompany even makes it to the end of the season is another matter really - if Burnley don't want to hold firm and take the hit of finishing with 20 points (roughly) he'll be out.
Good post. You've summed up their problems well there.
 
To be fair they were good at this style of play in the Championship and absolutely stormed the division for that reason. The problem they've had this season is flogging or dropping the players that made them tick and persisting with lads who don't have a clue how to carry out what's being asked of them. I think they just panicked and tried to put a "Premier League quality" side together but, as we've seen in the past, sometimes the team that wins the Championship is good enough to stay up in the top division.

But they lost Nathan Tella to Bayer Leverkusen. Manuel Benson and Jay Rodriguez barely play. They loaned Zaroury out to Hull. That's all four of their top goalscorers from last season either playing elsewhere or barely playing at all. Josh Cullen barely plays, Connor Roberts was loaned out to Leeds, Ian Maatsen was only on loan, and Ari Muric barely plays. That's four of their most-played players from last season either gone or benched. They made a big mistake by disrupting the chemistry of the team that won the Championship together.

Think Kompany deserves the chance to bring them back up. He's definitely shown that he's a more than capable manager for a Championship side and vastly out-performed expectations - lots of people were predicting another relegation for them because they had no money. Plus, Burnley allowed Dyche that luxury a couple of times and it paid off for them, I think. But whether Kompany even makes it to the end of the season is another matter really - if Burnley don't want to hold firm and take the hit of finishing with 20 points (roughly) he'll be out.

Excellent summary. That's the same mistake Fulham made a few seasons ago, came up, completely revamped the squad, never looked like a team, then went down. They also lost Harwood-Bellis as well, it's a shame he couldn't have had a season in the Premier League. Sacking Kompany makes no sense. They're 11 points from safety, its too much an ask for a new manager to keep them up at this stage, and Kompany has shown he can lead the team to promotion.
 
They had no right to come up last season, having lost the bulk of their experienced players, not exactly spent obscene amounts and all whilst attempting to implement a style of play completely at odds with that played for the last decade.

Set against that, they had no chance of staying up in the Premier league.

I think Vinny will get the boot by Christmas but as far as I'm concerned he couldn't have done any more in the last 18 months and is at the maximjm limit of what could have been achieved in that time.
 
Let’s get him back home where he belongs, learn as much from Pep whilst he can.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.