What happened with Rio? (merged)

[johnny crossan]

Re: Ferdinand

 

[Txiki Txiki Bang Bang]

Re: Ferdinand

he's a true rag , cut him and he bleeds red :)

 

[maccadon]

Re: Ferdinand

I think enoughs been said about the incident so what i want ask is this.It looked like he was away to take off his shirt n he was already on a booking.if he had of done do you think he would have been sent off? also with remaining time n added for said sending off, could we of grabbed an equaliser?

Ifs and buts. If we'd scored 6 and they'd scored 1 do you think it would have finished 6-1?

yes

 

[Churchill123]

Re: Ferdinand

Was just thinking about this exact incident only a moment ago! - All over the papers and in the press about cammel gob getting coined, yet no one has mentioned bellamy getting coined at their shit hole a few years ago!

 

[cheddar404]

Re: Ferdinand

I think enoughs been said about the incident so what i want ask is this.It looked like he was away to take off his shirt n he was already on a booking.if he had of done do you think he would have been sent off? also with remaining time n added for said sending off, could we of grabbed an equaliser?

Ifs and buts. If we'd scored 6 and they'd scored 1 do you think it would have finished 6-1?

yes

I thought so. Many thanks for confirming my suspicions.

 

[maccadon]

Re: Ferdinand

He was lifting his shirt above his head - thats not a booking.

what about incitement then? if no coin was thrown n he pulled shirt above his head.is that not a action of incitement?

 

[Damanino]

Re: Ferdinand

Bellamy was thrown with beer bottles. Also coins.

But City as a club apologised to Ferdinand and the fans that did the throws should be and will be punished end of story.

Did United apologise to Bellamy that time? Well if not that tell a lot about them an about City now.

End of story really.

(But players who provocate rival fans with celebrating ahead of them would deserve something from FA/PL. Many times this leads to reactions like this. This is true for everyone like Adebayor vs. Arsenal few years ago. Also when Rooney runs to City fans or Everton fans to kiss the badge...)

 

[johnmc]

Re: Ferdinand

He was lifting his shirt above his head - thats not a booking.

what about incitement then? if no coin was thrown n he pulled shirt above his head.is that not a action of incitement?

Infront of his own fans?

Im not a fan of the incitement argument either. Players from both sides get a load from the stand. If they score and give a bit back then fans should be able to take that if they have been giving it out. Verbals yes, but to reach in your pocket, select a coin and lob it is not a knee jerk reaction, just a cowards thing to do.

If we had scored a last minute winner at the swamp Id expect our players to celebrate in a similar manner.

 

[Sky Blue]

Re: What happened with Rio?

Hahaha

 

[maccadon]

Re: Ferdinand

Ifs and buts. If we'd scored 6 and they'd scored 1 do you think it would have finished 6-1?

yes

I thought so. Many thanks for confirming my suspicions.

your very welcome