kenzie115 said:Yes. You'd have to change the system a bit as there's no like-for-like replacement but I think we could be a better team without him, we'd certainly be more able to implement a high pressing game.chris85mcfc said:Anyone think we could be a better side without Yaya in it, but replacing him with the right player(s)?
Ultimately we'll have to learn to live without Yaya whether it's next season or in three years' time. If Txiki and Pellers think we're ready to do it now, they'll sell, if not, he'll stay.
Nasri, Fernandinho and Fernando in the middle, with Silva and Jovetic just off Aguero up front sounds pretty tasty, and that's without actually buying another midfielder as we're expecting to get Fernando anyway. Add Fabregas for example, and we've got plenty of options in midfield, and up front Aguero could play a withdrawn role alongside Silva or Jovetic, with one of the big blokes up top.chris85mcfc said:kenzie115 said:Yes. You'd have to change the system a bit as there's no like-for-like replacement but I think we could be a better team without him, we'd certainly be more able to implement a high pressing game.chris85mcfc said:Anyone think we could be a better side without Yaya in it, but replacing him with the right player(s)?
Ultimately we'll have to learn to live without Yaya whether it's next season or in three years' time. If Txiki and Pellers think we're ready to do it now, they'll sell, if not, he'll stay.
He's a great player and has turned up in a lot of big games, but sometimes i question whether he is a liability in terms of the way that we are wanting to try and play.
Before anyone quotes me, im not saying Yaya is a liability, im saying in terms of the way were trying to play ie high pressing and being on the front foot
In a lot of games last season a decent midfield played around him because he doesn't have the pace to close them down quick enough, and before you know it their at our back four
We would have to move one or two things round but this could actually see us start implementing a 4-3-3 if we wanted to as we would have 3 midfielders that can get about the pitch for 90 minutes
Imo, and an unpopular one it is, but YES I DO.chris85mcfc said:Anyone think we could be a better side without Yaya in it, but replacing him with the right player(s)?
Cobwebcat said:Haha Benatia has been "disrespested" by Roma now too and it would be a dream move to us.
Do we like Benatia or is it a one way street? Just wondering ;-)
Also if City have received an offer from PSG we must be thinking how can they be ignoring FFP and we aren't!
Something fishy about all of this.
Cobwebcat said:Haha Benatia has been "disrespested" by Roma now too and it would be a dream move to us.
Do we like Benatia or is it a one way street? Just wondering ;-)
Also if City have received an offer from PSG we must be thinking how can they be ignoring FFP and we aren't!
Something fishy about all of this.
BillyShears said:Cobwebcat said:Haha Benatia has been "disrespested" by Roma now too and it would be a dream move to us.
Do we like Benatia or is it a one way street? Just wondering ;-)
Also if City have received an offer from PSG we must be thinking how can they be ignoring FFP and we aren't!
Something fishy about all of this.
Not at all ... rumour has it that UEFA have told City/PSG the transfer limit is based on book cost of players rather than overall transfer value ... ergo ... any fee is booked over the length of the contract. In essence we could spend 200 million on four players giving them all five year contracts and not fall foul of the FFP rules.
UEFA themselves won't confirm this because much like the 21 man squad restriction, the details of the settlements fall in favour of the clubs who are being punished thus making them look weak.
St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:Love Yaya...
but ultimately love the club more.
As Rammy says,let Monaco and PSG have an auction.
Happy Feet said:Hope he stays, but if we get 40 to 50 million for a 31 year old then it would be a very good deal for the club.
He can go and play in a less demanding league for more money, so from that point of view you cant blame him.
No player is bigger than any club, we were here before him and will be here after him.
wayne71 said:Ray78 said:I trust the club to do the right thing.
Me too, no need for the flapping.
BillyShears said:Cobwebcat said:Haha Benatia has been "disrespested" by Roma now too and it would be a dream move to us.
Do we like Benatia or is it a one way street? Just wondering ;-)
Also if City have received an offer from PSG we must be thinking how can they be ignoring FFP and we aren't!
Something fishy about all of this.
Not at all ... rumour has it that UEFA have told City/PSG the transfer limit is based on book cost of players rather than overall transfer value ... ergo ... any fee is booked over the length of the contract. In essence we could spend 200 million on four players giving them all five year contracts and not fall foul of the FFP rules.
UEFA themselves won't confirm this because much like the 21 man squad restriction, the details of the settlements fall in favour of the clubs who are being punished thus making them look weak.
Cobwebcat said:BillyShears said:Cobwebcat said:Haha Benatia has been "disrespested" by Roma now too and it would be a dream move to us.
Do we like Benatia or is it a one way street? Just wondering ;-)
Also if City have received an offer from PSG we must be thinking how can they be ignoring FFP and we aren't!
Something fishy about all of this.
Not at all ... rumour has it that UEFA have told City/PSG the transfer limit is based on book cost of players rather than overall transfer value ... ergo ... any fee is booked over the length of the contract. In essence we could spend 200 million on four players giving them all five year contracts and not fall foul of the FFP rules.
UEFA themselves won't confirm this because much like the 21 man squad restriction, the details of the settlements fall in favour of the clubs who are being punished thus making them look weak.
Has the ten day period not passed now?
and do we want Benatia (as he seems to be copying Yaya) so if we are upset at Yaya, and accept Benatia are we hypocrites or just biased? :-)