ono
Well-Known Member
I totally agree with you, but closing down quickly and pressing quickly is something i would like to see all of the other attacking players do as well. It's not just a fault of Yaya's. Silva doesn't do it, De Bruyne doesn't Nasri doesn't, Aguero doesn't. On top of that, our defensive players over do it, rushing out of position to close space without thinking of the space they are leaving behind themselves. Otamendi does this a lot, as does Mangala, as does Zabaleta and as do both Ferns.Personally I think you're wrong in your perception that a midfielders defensive job is done as long as he "doesn't allow the opposing centre back or defensive midfielder to amble past him", that's only part of the defensive responsibility. There's positioning to block passes into strikers feet, there's closing down quickly at the right angle to shut off passing options, there's coming back to take the ball off a striker who is being held up/contained by a defender, there's doubling up to stop a winger coming inside your full back.
All dirty jobs our midfield doesn't like and that's why we're 4th and not walking away with another league title.
The thing with Yaya is at his age you can't expect him to contribute to every single phase of play. With Fernandinho and Fernando behind him (aswell as a back four) he shouldn't be worrying too much defensively, especially since teams only break on us with a small handful of players. I would like him to press more but only if it is a team effort and we have worked on a specific approach in relation to a specific opponent (like teams do with us, ironically with Yaya).
I think the way to view him is as an attacking player who drops deep to get on the ball. Asking him to contribute enormously to the defensive side of things is the same as asking David Silva to do it or De Bruyne. Or actually it's like expecting Fernando to arrive into the 6 yard box for tap ins....
Oh wait he can't do that because of Yaya :p