BillyShears said:
I understand that he's not 'ideal' captain material, but he has so many qualities on the field which make him a fantastic captain, that I don't mind a little of the craziness.
Anyway, I said the other day I believe City will be Carlos' last European club, and for that reason, he'll be here for another few years until he's won it all (hopefully!) once more - then he'll move back to Argentina...
Just out of curiosity in which way do you think he could become a liability?
I agree that he runs around a lot, but after 4 (?) years in the country, I would have expected him to have a greater level of communication in English than he already does. People put this down to 'tricking the media', etc, but it's rubbish really, even the other day on the Children's Hospital visit he could hardly converse. fully motivated individual shouldn't have this type of problem after 4 years, even Mancini's English (which is a stick he's often beaten with) is better than Tevez's.
I tend to believe that running around a lot on the field is far less useful than being able to motivate your team mates through communication. Can anybody see Tevez putting an arm around Boyata after a mistake, with some words of confidence?
The liability comment was just a general trend amongst players with poor mental attitudes rather than something that I see in Tevez particularly.
In addition to this, he's gone public on his grievances with the manager before, which should automatically rule him out of the captains slot, as it's unprofessional and causes nothing but trouble. Then we have the constant retirement comments, and the fact that he was made captain purely for his own self interest rather than the interest of the team.
I don't know who should be captain. Toure wasn't a bad choice, Kompany seems to be the future, perhaps Barry but he seems a little quiet. Maybe Yaya in time once he has settled.
Thing is, Tevez is a top player, but he seems flaky mentally too and I would certainly not be surprised if he did go at the end of the season in some engineered move to Madrid or even back to Boca (despite him ruling it out).