Referees/Officials

  • Thread starter Thread starter blueinsa
  • Start date Start date
While we're on the subject of offside and video refereeing - To guarantee propriety every possible offside should be recorded and the TV refereeing decision for each records - again accessible by the club at least (but ideally by anyone).
 
Just wondering what will happen to the ref running the line who said the ball went out when it clearly didn't cross the goal line. Probably end up getting a huge bonus by the FA for making such a huge mistake. I would like someone from the FA organising committee to publish in the press how they are going to compensate MCFC for their failure in appointing this so called assistant in the 1st place. As this huge mistake in all probability has cost us a place in this years FA Cup Final.
 
I get where you are coming from but if that was the case that they are simply not good enough then surely they wouldn't be good enough for both teams? both teams committed 20 fouls Sunday, one team picked up 5 yellows the other picked up 2. Best case of us being refereed differently is Kun getting booked for lobbing the keeper when offside at Burnley whilst Son getting away with the same thing at home to us - it was the same ref!

Up until this season I didn't have the victim mentality however it is very clear to see we don't get treated the same as other teams. If the refs wasn't good enough then the old "they even themselves up" would actually happen or at least come close to happening.
Very well said.
I wasnt aware of the disparity in punishment for the sergio /Son incidents..well spotted.
 
Just wondering what will happen to the ref running the line who said the ball went out when it clearly didn't cross the goal line. Probably end up getting a huge bonus by the FA for making such a huge mistake. I would like someone from the FA organising committee to publish in the press how they are going to compensate MCFC for their failure in appointing this so called assistant in the 1st place. As this huge mistake in all probability has cost us a place in this years FA Cup Final.

33000 city fans may as well have stayed at home and saved a small fortune, its beyond the point of being honest mistakes, it's corrupt to the core, i dont believe in the integrity of the game anymore, scudamore bemoaning his lost viewers because of united struggling, Gill sat cosily in the FA, it all stinks to high heaven, last season was bad, this season has been fraud, it just isn't possible to be on the end of so many game changing decisions, if we get a shocker tomorrow, i feel i might just get up and go home
 
33000 city fans may as well have stayed at home and saved a small fortune, its beyond the point of being honest mistakes, it's corrupt to the core, i dont believe in the integrity of the game anymore, scudamore bemoaning his lost viewers because of united struggling, Gill sat cosily in the FA, it all stinks to high heaven, last season was bad, this season has been fraud, it just isn't possible to be on the end of so many game changing decisions, if we get a shocker tomorrow, i feel i might just get up and go home


It's more than the decisions, it's who the decisions were against. Luiz, Walker, Milner, Monreal - all game changing decisions against our direct rivals. Fair enough every team gets the shitty end of the stick a few times throughout the season but none as obviously as us, and not in as many crucial games.
 
It's more than the decisions, it's who the decisions were against. Luiz, Walker, Milner, Monreal - all game changing decisions against our direct rivals. Fair enough every team gets the shitty end of the stick a few times throughout the season but none as obviously as us, and not in as many crucial games.

We've been screwed out of nine points against rivals which would have put us right into the mix regarding the title. Also add the ridiculous decision by Clattenburg at Goodison Park when Robles should have been sent off for bringing down Sterling.
 
It's more than the decisions, it's who the decisions were against. Luiz, Walker, Milner, Monreal - all game changing decisions against our direct rivals. Fair enough every team gets the shitty end of the stick a few times throughout the season but none as obviously as us, and not in as many crucial games.

Refresh my memory, please. I have no memories of some clubs getting the shitty end of the stick from referees.
 
FIFA have confirmed that video refereeing will be used at the 2018 World Cup, which Is a positive development.
 
That's old news from about 4 years ago but only scratched the surface. There were a number of convictions but it was really only about one ring and a handful of people. I believe the FBI is now collecting evidence on a much wider scale about domestic match-fixing in the UK and they won't fuck about.
That could be amazing
 
That's old news from about 4 years ago but only scratched the surface. There were a number of convictions but it was really only about one ring and a handful of people. I believe the FBI is now collecting evidence on a much wider scale about domestic match-fixing in the UK and they won't fuck about.

Hmmm.... Interesting, I wonder how the FA and PGMOL will try to cover their stuff up. But I would like to see how their investigation turns out tho
 
FIFA have confirmed that video refereeing will be used at the 2018 World Cup, which Is a positive development.

That is good news.
I know I saw a couple of weeks ago a France v Spain International that was supposed to be a trial match with video refs in preparation for said even t so confirmation is excellent.

The game itself showed same areas of contention we see today except mistakes (eg offside goals etc) were rectified despite being initially given by match ref.
David Silva scored a video ref given penalty for Spain.
Players accepted decisions and a minimum of delay.

Our England team may give all in UK something they will want during Russian Tournament so hopefully will have to be implemented by PL.
 
Hmmm.... Interesting, I wonder how the FA and PGMOL will try to cover their stuff up. But I would like to see how their investigation turns out tho
A US Federal investigation sounds an interesting prospect, but then you have to consider the diplomatic angle. If said investigation turned up evidence of widespread corruption involving the FArce/PGMOL/PL (Gill/Reilly/Scudamore), and it transpired that League positions were being manipulated by underhand and devious means then it would pretty much be the end of football as we know it.

Considering the amount of revenue that the Tax Man gets from football related activity (sponsorship/transfers/advertising/ticket sales/betting), do you really think the government would want the lid blowing on this, or do you think that they would come to some sort of agreement with the US Government to suppress any evidence?
 
Last edited:
A US Federal investigation sounds an interesting prospect, but then you have to consider the diplomatic angle. If said investigation turned up evidence of widespread corruption involving the FArce/PGMOL/PL (Gill/Reilly/Scudamore), and it transpired that League positions were being manipulated by underhand and devious means then it would pretty much be the end of football as we know it.

Considering the amount of revenue that the Tax Man gets from football related activity (sponsorship/transfers/advertising/ticket sales/betting), do you really think the government would want the lid blowing on this, or do you think that they would come to some sort of agreement with the US Government to suppress any evidence?

Exactly the case, the cost of any wrong doings would be astronomical even to those being wronged, Sheikh Mansour's investment in City would be lost in an instant
 
Exactly the case, the cost of any wrong doings would be astronomical even to those being wronged, Sheikh Mansour's investment in City would be lost in an instant
I really don't know what the solution would be. I'm almost resigned to accepting it is bent, and in some ways I wish I didn't know. Unfortunately, that particular genie is out of the bottle, and for me football will be forever tainted.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top