Another new Brexit thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This Letwin amendment for tomorrow's vote looks tasty. Supported by opposition parties and Tory rebels.
Looks as though BoJo will have to dig that ditch baby.

So long as you build your bunker to hide from the real right wing conservative/ERG/Brexit party lot you are going to open the political landscape up to in the near future because your beloved party isn't going to be anywhere near power for a long time Len.

Be careful what you wish for is all i will say and Letwin and co might find their mates in Brussels are no longer so friendly.

Its a funny old game is politics.
 
This Letwin amendment for tomorrow's vote looks tasty. Supported by opposition parties and Tory rebels.
Looks as though BoJo will have to dig that ditch baby.
The important thing now is to find a way to protect remain MP's jobs in leave constituencies. The sensible way to do this is to find a way where those MPs can vote for the deal, but then also vote for ammendments which will kick the legislative can far enough down the road for Boris to have to ask for an extension. They can then honestly tell their constituency they voted for the deal but still make sure brexit doesn't happen. They then keep their jobs come the next GE.
 
Lot of chickens being counted by the supporters of the deal. I’d say it is too close to call with the bookies slightly favouring rejection with the odds slightly lengthening for acceptance. A lot could change over the next 22 hours. I suspect there will be more than a handful of MPs who won’t decide until the debate tomorrow.
 
I’m inclined to agree with this.
Whether that is the way they go or not, I think you’ll find out soon enough after a GE.
Trouble is if the Tories get their majority, which I still think was the original overall game plan, the deal is a happy bonus if they get it through parliament. Then it will be too late to stop them if indeed their intentions are somewhat less than honourable.

NI will have been removed as an obstacle, they would be left with a choice of The EU or The UK.

Same economic catastrophe would be faced by local businesses.

I think there is a battle ongoing with the one nation lot right now. We all just assume that they will be on board but this is all set up for a very hard line from here on. I suspect a good number are in a real bind - if this goes through they will not be able to live with the end result, vote against and BoJo will kick them out in the morning and they will be rethinking their whole career. Lets see how it goes.
 
Yes, she should, it would finally mean she gets what she wants, but she won't, and if the deal gets passed, zero
fucks will be given about her, or the SNP, and we, thankfully, will be hearing much less of her, and that raving fat jock who
completely lost it in the house the other day.
There are many positives about Brexit;)

Putting aside all (both of ours) political convictions, i genuinely can not understand how you beleive Brexit, in whatever form, will mean the SNP and the Independence drive will get any weaker, rather than continuing getting stronger? i honestly don't get that. And without referring to your version of the economic guesswork, which will be the least relevant thing at that point.
 
This is the reality of where we are heading. Pray this fails



Controversial opinion. Johnson is lying to them. Johnson is always lying to someone and my bet is that’s it the ERG mob. He needs their votes. But think about it. Why wait 14 months to trigger a no deal scenario? Tories may not even be in power in 14 months. Would make more sense to refuse to do a deal with the EU, get a three month extension forced on him, fight an election as the no deal champion, win it and then no deal in January.

Just a thought.
 
I am still in favour of leaving albeit slightly, but not if it means the takeover of the country by the hard right. That is what we might be seeing, the endgame of Thatcherism. A choice between that and remain, remain all day long. The damage a hard right government free of EU restraint could do to the country is unimaginable. It will be the biggest ever redistribution of wealth from poor to rich the world has ever seen.

How can it be, Rascal? The poor have had all their weath taken off them and given to the rich already remember? Now come on, stay on message for goodness sake.
 
Labour to back rebel Tory bid to postpone key vote on deal so Johnson is forced to demand extension
My colleague Heather Stewart says Labour is planning to back the Letwin amendment tomorrow. This sounds like a technicality, and it is not event unexpected, but it may be the most important news of the day, and it could make a Brexit extension followed by an election more likely.

Well this could certainly put the cat amongst the pigeons

In previous votes parliament has been given a week to scrutinise yet they are being bounced in less than 48 hours to vote into one of the most biggest decisions in political history.
 
I think you've perhaps overlooked a minor flaw in your argument.
As many hate Johnson as May and I can see him being even worse on the campaign trail, he's far too lazy and has far too many skeletons in the closet, could be more the British Hillary than Trump.
 
No death, I am a pacifist, no camps, I hate tents, a basic grounding on the basics of Socialism sounds good though. A redistribution of resources so nobody goes hungry and everybody has a home would be a start.
I know you are passionate @Rascal so genuine question... if you are advocating redistributing resources to help the hungry how will you get the bone idle off their arses to make sure you focus on those who really need the support?

That's the flaw for me... people take liberties and @Labour /socialists would simply keep dishing out free stuff... to anybody

That's a recipe for disaster
 
This is the reality of where we are heading. Pray this fails


It really is complete bollocks.

Think about it for 1 microsecond. Johnson pontificated for ages about whether to back Remain or Leave. So let's for the sake of argument accept for one moment the left-wing-driven propaganda that he is a self-serving liar who only ever does anything for personal gain, and that he only backed Leave because he thought it would get him his best shot at No. 10.

Well he's in No. 10, isn't he. So no need for further duplicity. And his actions have shown that he's actually not a hard liner at all. He's come up with a much softer Brexit than anyone anticipated.

Now you can continue to think it's some kind of master conspiracy to fool us all and he's hell bent on a hard Brexit. Or you can just accept the reality that he really isn't a hard liner at all.
 
It seems to me that this situation is actually very very simple. I've had my "road to Damascus" moment, but others seem to be struggling with it, so let me explain where I am coming from.

1. We had a referendum which I am sure everyone will agree, despite all our preferences, reservations, objections or what-have-you's, was positioned as a, once-in-life-time binary vote on whether we should stay in, or Leave. And also there was a universal commitment from all involved that the result would be respected.

2. Realising what a cluster-fuck this was, I chose to ignore this and argued passionately for a full reversal or a second referendum in order to get the result I'd have preferred. In hindsight, this was wrong. The result must be honoured. For two reasons, (a) because to not do so, would destroy all faith in democracy in this country and (b) because those who voted Leave will never let it drop anyway. We cannot move on, and start addressing all the problems in society - the very things that many people were driven to vote Leave over - until we move on and Leave.

3. There can no justification for rejecting a democratic referendum result. However, if there was to be one, then the only plausible objection might be that no-one voted to leave without a deal. That people were told there would be a deal. That the economy will be trashed without a deal. We now have a deal, so that objection is eiiminated and can no longer be valid.

Therefore the ONLY sensible option, the only morally acceptable option, is now for MPs to vote to accept the deal. I think enough of them will realise this and it will be passed.
And you end up with No Deal after the transition period.
 
As many hate Johnson as May and I can see him being even worse on the campaign trail, he's far too lazy and has far too many skeletons in the closet, could be more the British Hillary than Trump.
There is no-one and absolutely nothing which could be worse that May's GE campaign. It is the zero against whilst all other efforts can be calibrated. For some bizarre reason, many people find Johnson quite charismatic and appealing. No human thought that of Theresa May.
 
Controversial opinion. Johnson is lying to them. Johnson is always lying to someone and my bet is that’s it the ERG mob. He needs their votes. But think about it. Why wait 14 months to trigger a no deal scenario? Tories may not even be in power in 14 months. Would make more sense to refuse to do a deal with the EU, get a three month extension forced on him, fight an election as the no deal champion, win it and then no deal in January.

Just a thought.

I agree, even as a Remain voter who detests Johnson’s lies.

He’s keeping them on side, hoping this gets voted in, he’ll then likely win a huge majority, some of them will be in powerful positions or won’t be needed due to such majority and he’ll backtrack on no deal later by negotiating a FTA.

I mean, the EU won’t want no deal either. Why would he not try and secure a FTA once a WA passes? It makes zero sense for him to absolutely destroy the economy when he’s already won, just to appease a group of MP’s he likely won’t need by then.

I’m going to be completely honest here as I often try to be... this is just ardent remainer crap that’s not going to happen.
 
As many hate Johnson as May and I can see him being even worse on the campaign trail, he's far too lazy and has far too many skeletons in the closet, could be more the British Hillary than Trump.
I think he's a c#nt but he's more popular in ratings than May. she came across as cold and boring whereas Johnson doesn't. Sad that that seems to be what counts in choosing who will lead our country, though, but that's the modern world. Can't stand watching Johnson in interviews when he tries to come across all matey. The c#nt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top