Saxmundham Blue
Well-Known Member
Get in the bin
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Var debate 2019/20
- Thread starter Chi-town blues
- Start date
Like the Sheffield United one it should of been retaken (and maybe a Lloris sending off because of the challenge on Sterling). Whether we would scored it is another matter. As for Raz's booking its debatable and you could call it a very rare VAR decision in our favour.
Yes, Lloris was off his line. Penalty should definitely have been retaken. I’ve seen some say that VAR can’t intervene in that instance. But I’m pretty sure that it did during the Nations Cup?
I do have to ask you, though, why you suggest that Lloris might have been sent off. Yes, there was contact but, IMO, Sterling was already going down long before any contact. Even if Dean had decided to give a penalty, it would have been a yellow card at most. Why red?
Yes, Lloris was off his line. Penalty should definitely have been retaken. I’ve seen some say that VAR can’t intervene in that instance. But I’m pretty sure that it did during the Nations Cup?
I do have to ask you, though, why you suggest that Lloris might have been sent off. Yes, there was contact but, IMO, Sterling was already going down long before any contact. Even if Dean had decided to give a penalty, it would have been a yellow card at most. Why red?
The challenge on Sterling but looking it again it would of been generous.
Last edited:
Yellow would have been right as you say but in all honesty no-body knows with certainty what the rules are anymore , that was a farce today , over 140 yrs of the game & var has managed to ruin it in 6 monthsYes, Lloris was off his line. Penalty should definitely have been retaken. I’ve seen some say that VAR can’t intervene in that instance. But I’m pretty sure that it did during the Nations Cup?
I do have to ask you, though, why you suggest that Lloris might have been sent off. Yes, there was contact but, IMO, Sterling was already going down long before any contact. Even if Dean had decided to give a penalty, it would have been a yellow card at most. Why red?
Crouchinho
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 Feb 2011
- Messages
- 7,167
- Location
- Toronto, bye bye blighty
- Team supported
- Tottenham Hotspur
Yes, Lloris was off his line. Penalty should definitely have been retaken. I’ve seen some say that VAR can’t intervene in that instance. But I’m pretty sure that it did during the Nations Cup?
I do have to ask you, though, why you suggest that Lloris might have been sent off. Yes, there was contact but, IMO, Sterling was already going down long before any contact. Even if Dean had decided to give a penalty, it would have been a yellow card at most. Why red?
Never a penalty the second one he was going down before Lloris even gets near him. Besides, Sterling was a lucky boy to stay on the pitch, I'm shocked VAR let him off the hook.
deano ou812
Well-Known Member
It was one of those that on another day is red,when VAR looked at it I thought here we go red card,giving how we have been stitched up I’m surprised it wasn’t red,but I’ve already given my reasons on the match thread,as for the lloris pen save then sterling challenge that’s a stonewall pen for me lloris nowhere near the ball,the give city another pen was never gonna happen,anyhow you’s won but surely you must be concerned how poor your team is ( you got away with it today) but can’t keep riding your luck the remainder of the season.hopefully some good will come from your win as preventing the rags from getting top 4 ...Never a penalty the second one he was going down before Lloris even gets near him. Besides, Sterling was a lucky boy to stay on the pitch, I'm shocked VAR let him off the hook.
Last edited:
VAR has a mare.
Sterling should have been sent off.
The time to give the pen was ridiculous.
The pen should have been retaken.
That error was backed up by Sterling not getting a pen after being clearly fouled.
The first half was close to unwatchable.
Sterling should have been sent off.
The time to give the pen was ridiculous.
The pen should have been retaken.
That error was backed up by Sterling not getting a pen after being clearly fouled.
The first half was close to unwatchable.
jaiguruKun
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 3 Mar 2011
- Messages
- 5,242
Things have become so bad that Clattenburg is now the voice of reason!
jaiguruKun
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 3 Mar 2011
- Messages
- 5,242
VAR has a mare.
Sterling should have been sent off.
The time to give the pen was ridiculous.
The pen should have been retaken.
That error was backed up by Sterling not getting a pen after being clearly fouled.
The first half was close to unwatchable.
Correct - how any one can say that's not a pen ia beyond me!