Haaland or Mbappé

[Paul1970]

I just don’t understand that. What can any other club offer that we can’t?

He is looking at history which is very foolish of him .

 

[Deleted member 87819]

Voted Haaland but either one would improve us (and both would improve under Pep)

 

[Akira]

Honestly, I'd be overjoyed with either of them.

 

[jamesha]

I just don’t understand that. What can any other club offer that we can’t?

At Real any chumps league that he wins will be just the latest in a long line. Same at dippers and, to a lesser extent, rags.
If he won it at City then he would be one of the players that reached that pinnacle first for the club.
Pragmatically players should look at the state of the clubs before they join - Barce is a disaster area and Real looks more like a retirement home than an elite club.
So the answer is istoreeee and nice weather.

 

[HelloCity]

I just don’t understand that. What can any other club offer that we can’t?

Great weather. A lot of big players find it hard to choose Manchester over Barca or Real because of it. Even United at their peak often found themselves in a losing battle when temping the very top players.

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

I voted for the Milky Bar squid.

 

[Sir Joe Aguero]

I just hope Liverpool don't get either of them. Van Dijk back and a competent striker over Firmino and they're back in the mix. Haaland would make us serious CL contenders.

 

[dachoosen1]

I voted mbappe just believe is more suited to us but think haaland is more likely to come don't think we will get either to be honest Dortmund and PSG will want crazy money.

 

[Citizen in Pakistan]

Haaland for a few reasons:

1: Tall, gives us a new dimension in attack.
2: More potent in front of goal. Our build up play have no issues, it's the finishing where we lack and he'd be perfect for that.
3: Would most likely be cheaper

 

[The Stockport Iniesta]

I doubt PSG would sell to City even if we could afford the fee. With Dortmund we might have some leverage to get the fee down. It was reported they want Braaf and we could also terminate the Sancho sell on clause, making the actual fee paid affordable.

 

[schtipps]

Dortmund have some really exciting young players coming through their ranks alongside Haaland. The latest of which is a lad called Moukoko who could well be one of the next big things.

Youssoufa Moukoko, the latest member of Borussia Dortmund's boy band

Youssoufa Moukoko has just become the youngest player in Bundesliga history at 16, joining a hit parade of teen sensations past and present at Borussia Dortmund: Erling Haaland, Jadon Sancho, Gio Reyna and Jude Bellingham.

www.bundesliga.com

 

[Invisible_Goat]

It's a no brainer who has more to their game.

1. Mbappe goal scoring record is very similar to Halland
2. Mbappe gets more assists
3. Mbappe makes more key passes
4. Mbappe makes almost twice as many overall passes per game on average
5. Mbappe successful pass completion % is better
6. Mbappe makes more successful dribbles
7. Mbappe is fouled more often
8. Mbappe can play anywhere across the front three including the wings, and has been played in attacking midfield too, Halland is primarily a centre forward
9. Mbappe has already had experience playing in major games, such as WC, UCL final, and he's won the league every year of his professional career

 

[Tugay One Cup]

10. Mbappe is an utter bitch

Great player and I'll obviously pretend I never said this if we ever signed him, put he has one of the most slappable faces in football. Cut from the same cloth as Neymar, another amazingly talented player who I hope we never sign.

 

[domalino]

It's a no brainer who has more to their game.

1. Mbappe goal scoring record is very similar to Halland
2. Mbappe gets more assists
3. Mbappe makes more key passes
4. Mbappe makes almost twice as many overall passes per game on average
5. Mbappe successful pass completion % is better
6. Mbappe makes more successful dribbles
7. Mbappe is fouled more often
8. Mbappe can play anywhere across the front three including the wings, and has been played in attacking midfield too, Halland is primarily a centre forward
9. Mbappe has already had experience playing in major games, such as WC, UCL final, and he's won the league every year of his professional career

A lot of those are not really plus points.

Why am I supposed to care if Mbappe can play across the front 3? We already have more wingers than we can use and Jesus might end up there.

Why do I care if he's fouled more often or makes dribbles? No one is picking the next striker on his passing %.

The only thing that matters is if the striker is technically good enough to fit in the side (Obviously both are, or they wouldn't be real targets) and if they are going to put the ball in the back of the net 45 times a season.

We don't need more assists from our striker. We don't need better passing %. We just need someone to convert chances into goals.

 

[LangleyBlue1970]

Haaland. Can you just imagine the record he'd achieve with the service from our players? I think Mbappe would fly, too, but I think he is the type of player to sulk too much and also not stay at one club too long. Haaland looks like he could make his name here for the next 10 years. Destroy all records.
The kid is unbelievable.

 

[birchwoodgingerste]

Its a bun not m bapp!:))

 

[Boo or Boo-urns]

Mbappe is an utter bitch

Mbappe has been courting the Dippers, like Griezmann yanked the chain of the RAGS.

 

[blueparrot]

Mbappe has been courting the Dippers, like Griezmann yanked the chain of the RAGS.

Don't think so, pretty sure if he's courted anyone it's Real Madrid.

 

[yankblue]

Why not both?

 

[Semper aggressus]

Why not both?

Because he said he didn’t want to play for City, so if Manchester isn’t what he considers good enough then the fucking cesspit of Merseyside certainly won’t be. Unless he plans to live in Paris and fly over for training every day.