Haaland or Mbappé

Would you rather us sign Haaland or Mbappe in summer ?

  • Haaland

    Votes: 380 71.3%
  • Mbappe

    Votes: 153 28.7%

  • Total voters
    533
Haaland. Mbappe wouldn’t work in our team IMO. He’s more suited to the Rags/Dipperpool style of play in terms of relying on quick transitions and counter attacks. We have too much of the ball for Mbappe to be Mbappe
 
Mbappes return is good when you add in the assists but he's a flat track that rarely shows up in the big games

This season - 0 goal involvements vs Man Untied or Leipzig instead 2 goals 3 assists vs Basaksehir

Last season 0 goals in the knockout stages(psg made it to the final) Again stat padded vs Club Brugge and Galatasary - 4goals 4assists

Then there's Halaand who has scored vs every opponent he has faced.

Mustard
 
Haaland. Mbappe wouldn’t work in our team IMO. He’s more suited to the Rags/Dipperpool style of play in terms of relying on quick transitions and counter attacks. We have too much of the ball for Mbappe to be Mbappe

Mbappe is great on the ball. Did you watch him tonight? He can drop deep, pick a pass and most importantly beat a man to create space for others and drag defenders out of position. He would suit our style perfectly
 
People are reactionary. Tonight, ask around and everyone will say Mbappe obviously. It all depends on the team around them and the moment. Both are exceptional
 
Mbappes return is good when you add in the assists but he's a flat track that rarely shows up in the big games

This season - 0 goal involvements vs Man Untied or Leipzig instead 2 goals 3 assists vs Basaksehir

Last season 0 goals in the knockout stages(psg made it to the final) Again stat padded vs Club Brugge and Galatasary - 4goals 4assists

Then there's Halaand who has scored vs every opponent he has faced.
Hmmmm

Scored in a world cup final at 19 too
 
Idealy Mbappe, but I don't see him ever coming to the PL
He is a Hollywood player. Given he is already at the zenith of French football, that means Spain...where the sun shines and the money is good!

He wants Real Madrid. If they want him, I think they will get him.
 
It's a no brainer who has more to their game.

1. Mbappe goal scoring record is very similar to Halland
2. Mbappe gets more assists
3. Mbappe makes more key passes
4. Mbappe makes almost twice as many overall passes per game on average
5. Mbappe successful pass completion % is better
6. Mbappe makes more successful dribbles
7. Mbappe is fouled more often
8. Mbappe can play anywhere across the front three including the wings, and has been played in attacking midfield too, Halland is primarily a centre forward
9. Mbappe has already had experience playing in major games, such as WC, UCL final, and he's won the league every year of his professional career
It's not close. And today was another reminder why. Mbappe is head and shoulders better.
 
People coming out the woodwork now he had a good game vs a shite Barca.. Haaland still the choice.
In fairness he didn't play against the following todsy:

Juventus - Man City - Liverpool - Man United - Bayern - Dortmund - Real Madrid

So whatever you think ir don't think I'd today. The above list even excluding in today, suggest he is anything but a flat track bully.
 
This is how I see it, but if it becomes a choice to go for Haaland or Mbappé it has to be Mbappé IMO.
Mbappe is certainly the most dynamic inside left in modern football. However, it looks like Haaland might be both less trouble in, and more suited to, Manchester.

If Mbappe ever came to the PL, it would be for United or Arsenal, IMHO. He would prefer the Big Smoke, and it’s ridiculously easy access to Paris, but the lure (although it has long since lost it luster in my view) of Manchester United might possibly tempt him to “Up north!”

While we might think we are the best team, best coach, best facilities, etc., once you are a £100M footballer, it JS the niceties in life, WHILE playing for a top club that regularly wins things, that attracts you.

Monaco...Paris...Manchester???

Just don’t see it for Mbappe, even though we are one of only a handful of clubs that could afford him.
 
A fun armchair exercise, but I'd be delighted (and surprised) if we got either.
 
As we tend to sign personality and character, and not only quality and potential, Haaland seems to be more fitting for us and the one I would rather see us go for.
 
HAALAND, good with both feet, decent header of the ball, pacy, not just a goal poacher and he's still a youngster. Nice family connection to the club means we may not get fucked over my agents - gets my vote but I'd also have Mbappe
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top