The Super League | FA + PL: New Charter & Fines | UEFA: Settlement

Would you be happy if City joined this European Super League?

  • Yes

    Votes: 109 5.3%
  • No

    Votes: 1,954 94.7%

  • Total voters
    2,063
Those 2 twats on sky going on about how we need to set football rivalry aside but continue only to talk about the red scum. Even now their bias cannot be hidden. When did rat and spity become the voice of the people?
 
I would feel a whole lot better about our club if I had the answers to these basic questions regarding our part in this.

1. Were we involved in the set up of this Super League from its inception?
2. If not, at what point were we approached about it?
3. Why did we feel joining a competition run by our enemies would be beneficial?
4. Did we ask for a member to be on the board?
5. Why are the vice chairmen all members of American owned Premier League clubs?
6. Were we told this is a one time only offer to be part of it? take it or leave it?
7. When were the Players / management made aware of this?
8. How do the players and the management feel about this?
9. Were our board in full support behind this or are we divided?
10. How do we know the rules will not be altered if we do actually join?
11. Would we actually be prepared to walk away from the Premier League if it came to it.
12. Crucially do we feel that we have been railroaded into this?
Good set of questions that I'd also like to hear an answer to, before I can make an informed decision on it all.

As it stands with no detail, I don't like it, and I like it less that as a club we haven't (as supporters) been told anything officially from within.
 
How would we all feel if we did u turn with Chelsea? Can all be forgiven and forgotten?
For me 100% but it would have to be quick....god knows how the players prepare for Villa, PSG & the cup final not knowing if they’re coming or going in or out
 
The funny thing is that the CL is a closed shop as it is.

The fact is us or Liverpool could finish 7th with the new proposals and still get a CL spot due to our coefficient ranking points over the 5 seasons previous.

“Champions” league my arse.

Take Rangers, they have two rounds to negotiate to get into the Champions League for next season. They should be automatic entrants. It’s grossly unfair as it is. Makes me sick.

And to think these owners aren’t happy with the current setup even though it’s heavily skewed in their favour as it is.
The three red top clubs regularly fail to qualify for the champs league so surprise surprise they want to change that
 
Well done to those Leeds fans tonight. That needs to happen up and down the country and in Spain and Italy at every game involving these 12 from now on. The players won't be taking it personal, they know that we know its not them, it's not aimed at them but it's simply the best way of letting our feelings be known.
 
If I understand correctly this awful Super League starts next season. So in which case Liverpool effectively have nothing to play for tonight?
It made me laugh and a little bit sad when Andy Hinchcliffe just said what a big game this is tonight for the league. Hmmmmmm really Andy, actually it means absolutely fuck all just like 95% of all games now. This is a meaningless game and unless you are winning the title or fighting relegation, all games are meaningless now.
 
Damage is done mate - just like the Liverpool furlough proposal, people remember..............
That does not matter. Bans matter. We are going to have to move fast. I am sure we will.

Man Utd, Arsenal and Liverpool will be totally committed to this. This is their baby. Our name is down because we are scared they are going to disappear over the horizon.
 
Too soon in PR terms . . . not in practical terms. Post-COVID, the Spanish clubs the and clubs in general are hurting. The J.P. Morgan loan(s) is (are) on offer at what I assume are attractive rates (with rates likely to go higher -- maybe much -- if economies recover post-COVID). I am curious as to the collateral (secured line of credit? I assume unsecured -- or do the stronger clubs guarantee the weaker clubs' debt?). Messi's on his last legs. RM needs a revamp. Spurs and Arsenal look to be miles behind regular way CL qualification. The American owners want the mostly closed shop idea because its the locked-in model here that creates unassailable product monopolies. So we start with this half-step -- semi-closed, five open slots -- that will inevitably morph into a fully-closed, full season league like in the US. Because that's what makes the owners the richest. Guaranteed revenue. No relegation. No competition. On the weekends. Brand name matches. There will I'm sure be a harsher salary cap eventually too.

Yes everything we hate this side of the pond. Fine for you guys where you are mainly talking about one country. You are taking on 52 here.
 
I mean there are countless leagues in Europe. All of the winners there can't qualify for the CL, can they? I think the coefficient system works well in most points, the fact is Celtic/Rangers or any other Scottish team havn't done much of note compared to the other leagues and hence have to go through qualifying rounds unlike the Champions of Ukraine.

On the other point of 8th getting into the CL from 2024, agreed that is messed up. Hopefully somehow that idea gets shot down as well.
Of course they can’t.

But it should still be made up of a majority of Champions. Top 16 nations should see their Champions automatically qualify. Then other 16 should be filled with 12 runners up from top 12 countries. And 4 spots from smaller leagues through a qualifying route.

5 teams from the one country in a competition that was designed for champions is an insult to all of these other clubs missing out.
 
Not going to happen but neither is the ESL so be the first to pull the plug. We owe Man Utd and Liverpool nothing.

Actually incorrect , but unfortunately what we do owe them we can only deliver on the pitch.

They are two of the biggest problems affecting the integrity of the PL
 
So are we getting kicked out of the Prem? If so.. what's the point in playing on Wed?
No, there’s not a snowballs chance in hell we’re kicked out of the Premier League. Think about what happens to the Premier League if they did that.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top