SWP's back
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 90,597
Honestly the most bent sporting event of this millennia.Higher ups giving him an order no doubt
Honestly the most bent sporting event of this millennia.Higher ups giving him an order no doubt
Higher ups giving him an order no doubt
Nail on head.What Masi did was make a decision to NOT move the lapped cars, but then realized that even if he could get ONE LAP IN (which Horner implored him to do on the radio for the world to hear!), with the traffic ahead (even blue flagged traffic), Lewis would be off and away after the Safety Car!
Then, he realized if I do allow the lapped cars through, we are not going to be able to get one lap done. Quandary!
So, in his complete lack of sporting wisdom, he came up with a completely new, NETFLIX-ready, solution…just allow the cars BETWEEN then through before we get around to the finish line and then pull the safety car!
In effect, he said, “Max either can’t catch Lewis if we race, or has no chance if we don’t race, so let me remove the barrier to a race lap and remove the cars involved. Not only will this distill the entire year of hundreds of millions of dollars of hard fought racing down to a 1 lap sprint, it’ll effectively put a slower car but with faster tires a fraction of a second behind a faster car with slower tires! That sounds like ‘car racing’ to me!”
The result?
The driver who not only nullified poll position before the first turn, was ahead for the entire race, but also managed his tires for a 1 stop (versus 3 stop!!!) strategy was PENALIZED by allowing the time and track positions lost during those tire changes to be removed from consideration….and thus the driver who was tied for the Championship before the race, led the entire way in the “Winner Takes All” Grand Finale had the WORLD CHAMPION TITLE taken from him by the Race Director, who made up a solution to his “problem” for the last lap.
If it doesn’t get overturned (unlikely), this title will always have an asterisk besides it for me. And, after giving Max a win earlier in the season, it is simply compounding the fix.
And, as if on cue, Horner suddenly becomes magnanimous and Verstappen turns philosophical!
What an absolute joke Masi has made of this entire season with some of his decisions, especially his final decisive one!
If I were Mercedes, I would go as far as I could with the appeals process…and then drop out of F1 next year and leave a big gaping hole in their so-called competition!
Formula E is the future.
With respect that is absolute rubbish, The way the race director "manufactured" the situation so it came down to a last lap shoot out when one driver (who had lead the race from start to finish) was handicapped by worn tyres & had no real chance of winning the shoot out is just simply not fair, it does not matter who was in the cars,If only Verstappen was English maybe the corruption wouldn't seem so corrupt. Or Hamilton North Korean.
Seemingly all the media know this too and don’t seem to care, as the circumstances should be the headline not the result of Verstappen winning (sadly for him). Personally I haven’t been much of a follower since way back, but last week thought I might start again with this head-to-head scenario between the two going on. Think I’ll pass on it now and seems like many more think the same. F1 has enough muppets to follow it to survive, like WWE, so everyone in the sport will just accept it is my guess. Not for me.Not really a follower: ie watch the races lap by lap, but IMHO it was 'fixed' last week so it would come down to the final race. Then they had to make sure Verstappen wins overall.
It was marketed as a shootout and got the media giving air time to a sport that has slipped down the pecking order.
Hamilton has cruised to the title, Bayern style, the last few years and the sport has lost it's appeal. That isn't good for the sponsors, TV companies or advertisers.
Agreed. Think they've shot themselves in the foot with this one.As someone who doesnt really follow F1 I found myself waking up at 5am with my head still trying to understand what happened yesterday.
I still dont understand how a sport can remove the 4 cars Hamilton had just passed so his rival could have a clear run on new tyres.
I am still angry, I watch sport hoping to see a fair competition. I struggle with football and think that bent towards the American owned clubs.
But what I saw last night left me speechless, I witnessed clear and utter cheating. RB told the RC to remove the lapped cars and he did. It seems so many F1 rules were ignored by RC the SC should have done another lap, all lapped cars should have been unlapped.
You cant take F1 seriously from now on I dont think it will help F1 with new fans etc. Might have been what the sponsors wanted but long term it might have done more harm
cant argue with a single word. Haven't felt as cheated at a sporting event since CL quarters against Spuds. In fact in terms of being bent, yesterday was 100 times worse. If I hadn't seen it, I wouldn't have believed it.What Masi did was make a decision to NOT move the lapped cars, but then realized that even if he could get ONE LAP IN (which Horner implored him to do on the radio for the world to hear!), with the traffic ahead (even blue flagged traffic), Lewis would be off and away after the Safety Car!
Then, he realized if he did allow the lapped cars through, we were not going to be able to get one lap done. Quandary!
So, in his complete lack of sporting wisdom, he came up with a completely new, NETFLIX-ready, solution…just allow the cars BETWEEN them through before they get around to the finish line and pull the safety car!
In effect, he said, “Max either can’t catch Lewis if we race, or has no chance if we don’t race, so let me remove ‘the barrier’ to a race lap by removing the cars involved. Not only will this distill the entire year of hundreds of millions of dollars of hard fought racing down to a 1 lap sprint, it’ll effectively put a slower car with faster tires a fraction of a second behind a faster car with slower tires! That sounds like ‘car racing’ to me!”
The result?
The driver who not only nullified poll position before the first turn, was ahead for the entire race, but also managed his tires for a 1 stop (versus 3 stop!!!) strategy was PENALIZED by allowing the time and track positions lost by his arch rival during those tire changes to be removed from consideration. Thus, the driver who was tied for the Championship before the race, led the entire way in the “Winner Takes All” Grand Finale had the WORLD CHAMPION TITLE taken from him by the Race Director, who made up a solution to his “problem” for the last lap.
If it doesn’t get overturned (unlikely), this title will always have an asterisk besides it for me. And, after giving Max a win earlier in the season, it is simply compounding the fix.
And, as if on cue, Horner suddenly becomes magnanimous and Verstappen turns philosophical!
What an absolute joke Masi has made of this entire season with some of his decisions, especially his final decisive one!
If I were Mercedes, I would go as far as I could with the appeals process…and then drop out of F1 next year, leaving a big gaping hole in the so-called competition!
Formula E is the future.
The ‘sport’, as you call it, was basically erased from history due to the FIA choosing to make rules up on the fly which ensured a different outcome.It seems people here think this was all by design to allow Max to win. Of course Max being on the fresher tyres in a one lap shoot out was always going to get a fair shot of passing him. Im not saying I think the decision to let them race / allow some backmarkers to pass was right.
However, I can’t help but look at one moment in the race, and it’s a gamble we see teams take week in week out down the field to get a ‘cheap stop’. Mercedes made the call to maintain track position instead of pitting Lewis under the virtual safety car. (Toto on the radio to Masi begging him not to deploy the full safety car). Obviously Red Bull then react, they have to, they are then racing the variables. Both teams gambled and unfortunately for Lewis that initial team decision has put him on the back foot with tyre choice for what happens later. That initial decision keeps him on those worn tyres for the duration. He himself was on the radio multiple times questioning it, even calling it a risk and a gamble.
The sport comes down to split decisions and on a high speed street circuit there was always the possibility of a full safety car.
It’s a farce how the end of the race unfolded, but I do think Lewis is going to come back stronger than ever next season. The man is a warrior.
The ‘sport’, as you call it, was basically erased from history due to the FIA choosing to make rules up on the fly which ensured a different outcome.
As many have said, it is a manufactured result that not only leaves a bad taste, the credibility of the entire sport has been tarnished.
I think he would too as it meant the race just didn't finish behind a safety car. He wanted drama and he got it.i think the variable I was trying to ask was, and extremely hypothetical of course; If Mercedes had taken the first pit stop opportunity, the scenario would have been reversed, so do people think Masi would have still released the lapped cars for a single lap race? I think he would.
It seems people here think this was all by design to allow Max to win. Of course Max being on the fresher tyres in a one lap shoot out was always going to get a fair shot of passing him. Im not saying I think the decision to let them race / allow some backmarkers to pass was right.
However, I can’t help but look at one moment in the race, and it’s a gamble we see teams take week in week out down the field to get a ‘cheap stop’. Mercedes made the call to maintain track position instead of pitting Lewis under the virtual safety car. (Toto on the radio to Masi begging him not to deploy the full safety car). Obviously Red Bull then react, they have to, they are then racing the variables. Both teams gambled and unfortunately for Lewis that initial team decision has put him on the back foot with tyre choice for what happens later. That initial decision keeps him on those worn tyres for the duration. He himself was on the radio multiple times questioning it, even calling it a risk and a gamble.
The sport comes down to split decisions and on a high speed street circuit there was always the possibility of a full safety car.
It’s a farce how the end of the race unfolded, but I do think Lewis is going to come back stronger than ever next season. The man is a warrior.
and maybe that's what they want,people like you who haven't got a clue, as for hamilton having it in his own hands, your a wumBut people will watch it, the same way everyone deems football is corrupt and still watch it religiously.
If anything it could bring new fans in like me. Loved the drama today. I like how everyone is forgetting Hamilton still had a lead, in his own hands and lost it.