31 | Ederson - 2022/23 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
dickie davies said:
Myself and the people around me (all season card holders) had a discussion at HT yesterday and the opinion if all is that Eddie doesn't contribute anything
When he was pinging the ball wide, he was Hoddle esq, but we don't play that way anymore.
He is a bang average keeper that fails to command his penalty area and if we're not utilising his strength then it's pretty pointless playing him
Click to expand...

In your discussion did you agree on a goalkeeper you all agreed to replace him ?
 
asahartford1 said:
Just be thankful you don't sit there.
Click to expand...
Trouble is we are matchday ticket buyers and Etihad nomads, so I could easily end up there:). That said going off some fans we've sometimes ended up near maybe we already have.if i was putting bets on CB2 would be the short odds.:)
 
His form has dropped a little. His passing out from the back or the pinged long balls are not quite top level at the moment. Maybe he needs a rest? Let Ortega have a few games.
 
gordondaviesmoustache said:
We all have at some point or other, mate.
Click to expand...

I sit next to a couple who travel from Devon for every match. Very knowledgeable and fun to watch the game with.
2 rows in front and in E104 aisle seat there is a loud negative guy. Everything is wrong , He hankers after the long forward ball, hates recycling, kind of turns in his seat to let everyone know what he is shouting, scruffy jeans, high blood pressure, terrible tash, City shirt needs a hot wash. Could do with losing a few stones, but at least he will be there Wednesday-;)
 
asahartford1 said:
I sit next to a couple who travel from Devon for every match. Very knowledgeable and fun to watch the game with.
2 rows in front and in E104 aisle seat there is a loud negative guy. Everything is wrong , He hankers after the long forward ball, hates recycling, kind of turns in his seat to let everyone know what he is shouting, scruffy jeans, high blood pressure, terrible tash, City shirt needs a hot wash. Could do with losing a few stones, but at least he will be there Wednesday-;)
Click to expand...
I better give my City shirt a hot wash for Wednesday, but I’m going to struggle to lose the weight by then. And I’ll think about the tash.
 
dickie davies said:
Myself and the people around me (all season card holders) had a discussion at HT yesterday and the opinion if all is that Eddie doesn't contribute anything
When he was pinging the ball wide, he was Hoddle esq, but we don't play that way anymore.
He is a bang average keeper that fails to command his penalty area and if we're not utilising his strength then it's pretty pointless playing him
Click to expand...
That is hilarious, dickie, just hilarious

And what does a season card holder have to do with opinion being informed?
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
That is hilarious, dickie, just hilarious

And what does a season card holder have to do with opinion being informed?
Click to expand...

Don't deter him. I'm dying to know how this elite think-tank has decided we play now, given that they've collectively decided that our goalkeeper doesn't play passes out wide anymore.

They sound like the Borg but if they were running on Windows Vista.
 
Zin 'messiah' Zimmer said:
That is hilarious, dickie, just hilarious

And what does a season card holder have to do with opinion being informed?
Click to expand...
Because I knew by posting a non conformative view which criticises one of our players there would be a pile on
And by qualifying my comments with the fact that it was a discussion between season card holders means these are people who've been watching us for years and seen the club develop
They're not kids or JCL's and we don't sit there booing or screaming "you're fucking shit Ederson " But we know, one shot one goal
Ederson can't be that unlucky that every decent shot is unsaveable
 
dickie davies said:
Because I knew by posting a non conformative view which criticises one of our players there would be a pile on
And by qualifying my comments with the fact that it was a discussion between season card holders means these are people who've been watching us for years and seen the club develop
They're not kids or JCL's and we don't sit there booing or screaming "you're fucking shit Ederson " But we know, one shot one goal
Ederson can't be that unlucky that every decent shot is unsaveable
Click to expand...
No offence, but you didn't just post a non-conformative view. You posted an extreme view that Ederson does not contribute anything, which, no matter how civil you were when you wrote it, was so preposterous that yes people would jump on it.

It's equivalent to me going into the De Bruyne thread and politely suggesting he doesn't know how to cross.
 
mccity said:
No offence, but you didn't just post a non-conformative view. You posted an extreme view that Ederson does not contribute anything, which, no matter how civil you were when you wrote it, was so preposterous that yes people would jump on it.

It's equivalent to me going into the De Bruyne thread and politely suggesting he doesn't know how to cross.
Click to expand...
He didn’t at the weekend. ;-)
 
mccity said:
It's equivalent to me going into the De Bruyne thread and politely suggesting he doesn't know how to cross
Click to expand...
Now you are being silly and this is my last post in here
I said "we do not utilise his strengths" which is his passing. Without that he is a very average goalkeeper
We were fortunate that the ref blew when Ederson made the mistake for the disallowed goal. If that had gone to VAR it would have stood
Look at the first two Newcastle goals last weekend. Both were similar to Palace's goals
Ederson slow to react and doesn't make himself "big"
 
There was nothing ‘fortunate’ about the disallowed goal. It was a free kick. The Palace player stuck his foot out as Ederson was releasing the ball and made contact with it. It’s never not going to be a free kick so wherever you’re one of those who just want a stick to beat our keeper with or just genuinely don’t know the laws of the game, it doesn’t matter as you’re wrong either way.
 
dickie davies said:
Because I knew by posting a non conformative view which criticises one of our players there would be a pile on
And by qualifying my comments with the fact that it was a discussion between season card holders means these are people who've been watching us for years and seen the club develop
They're not kids or JCL's and we don't sit there booing or screaming "you're fucking shit Ederson " But we know, one shot one goal
Ederson can't be that unlucky that every decent shot is unsaveable
Click to expand...
Extremely blinkered and damn right presumptuous, pal

So a person who has retained a ‘season card’ is the authority? Give over mate, it’s highly offensive to a good portion of the fan base who have, for economic reasons, had to give up cards; I’m. not meaning to have a pop but it’s hard not to with assertions like this…..

Being a ‘non conformer’ is all well and good, however, you leave yourself wide open, along with your group, when you have concluded, after 4 games, that Eddie is now obsolete as we no longer play his style..
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top