Good work Dave ! I’ve been wondering who this character is and had suspicions that there was something iffy.Who in the UK calls the Premier League the EPL !
Nope, change is always good it just doesn't have to be the pant-wetting Ultra bollocks that you so desire.
And therein lies the Issue with Ultras. It's not so much the about the Club, is their narcisstic view that they know best and are somehow better than other fans who don't subscribe to their view. They also want to think they can speak for all fans and become some sort of leader.
We have City Matters already, we also have comms from the club to ST holders and I'd rather we listened to view of those who actually attend the games rather than from people on Social media who have never been to a game?
Can I ask, you've been on BM for only a few months and in that time you've never posted about a favourite player, a memory from past games, the bald fraud, price of beer in the ground, title race predictions, comments on a game, price of season tickets, etc etc etc . You've only ever posted in the Etihad redevelopment section and the atmosphere section...
.....and always Ultras, Ultras fucking Ultras !
Do you run your own Man City Social channel by any chance or any football channel or City fan group? What age demographic do you represent? How often do you come to games? It might help me understand why you seem to think that anyone who doesn't drink from the kult of ultra cup is stuck in the past.
Exactly mate. I like some of the ideas being floated about on here but a lot of it seems fanciful.Yep. Not to mention the obligatory corporate section they will throw right in the middle of it.
I just hope that someone who knows what they are talking about can communicate with the club. I don’t think the club understand crowd psychology and the way that each stand has evolved since Maine Road.
It might be just where im sat. Its quietI sat in CB3 for two seasons in a row before this one. Never had a problem with it. Plenty of fans shout and sing. It seems CB3 is the dog to whip regarding the stadium atmosphere which is wrong.
Well said. Our opinions and ideas may differ (part and parcel of a football forum) but we are all Blue and we all want the same outcome, which is a better atmosphere.Can I just say.
The Personal attacks on LEXSTARproject are very unfair and are uncalled for.
He has every right to post what he wants.
He also has a right to his views and opinions.
He has contributed a lot to this thread and the Etihad Campus thread in good faith.
We don't have to agree with each other, but let's keep it civil please.
Bang on mate, THE BIGGEST PROBLEM is getting people to sing, I'm in 119 and it's a decent atmosphere but the amount of people who don't sing or only sing occasionally is huge, I'm a f.o.c but no one outsings me, shouts more or even clapping loud as fuck...that's what the old Kippax did to you, you got behind the team in any which way you could, no you hear people discussing what they are having for tea while the boys are playing...fucking joke just get behind the ladsI have posted on BM many times that 1894 have been having regular meetings with the club for over 9 years now, we all speak to the club but a dare say im the one that speaks to them most. I know what a good atmosphere is and what it takes to make a crap one better, started my city supporting in 1979 and have seen lots of games at maine road, away from home, you name it. Intelligent ? Well some would disagree !! I stand at the back of 115, have done since we moved there, i have probably been involved in every display that has been done in the south stand. You wont see me on social media, i have never got involved in any of that shite. But 1894 are wide across most social media.
We get fantastic backing from the club, we get fantastic backing off a lot of fans, so grateful of the support we get. But a very large percentage of our support in the the stadium does not buy in to working to get a better atmosphere. The great vocal fans are out numbered by the silent ones, this is the number one issue that we have been up against for 9 years. Fans look for faults such as tourists / beer / transport / a "drum" that will go up somebodies arse / and it seems fans will only sing if tickets come down in price. ( i do agree that the north stand needs to offer the best price tickets to encourage singing fans to move there, BUT and it is a massive BUT, as jrb said we dont want fans to move there just for cheap tickets or again we will face the same problems )
We have probably put more effort into working on a better atmosphere than most other clubs supporters groups, our fans need to take a good look at themselves and realise they need to sing more. Fine example and could somebody on here answerer this ? Why VS everton did the whole of the south stand lower punch the air with "haaland haaland haaland" then stay quite for most of the first half ?
I have seen a few people post about the united singing section that has sprung up recently. I know one of the guys that helped organise it, they actually did less than what we do to put the word about but got far more fans wanting to move in, they did very little. There was no question of ticket prices or wanting to stay where they already where to be with their mates, it was purely "the fans wanted to sing for the team, they had wanted it for a while. Now like rangers they have fans waiting to go in.
No matter what we call the new end, no matter where the away fans are, regardless of the drum rumours which arent true, there is a massive last chance to get a singing section in a couple of years so MOVE IN and sing.
But when he replies that anyone who doesn't lurve the ultras is old fashioned or lives in the past and is against change..or notes that older fans must wear flat caps and work down t'pit in a disparaging manner, then that's ok?Can I just say.
The Personal attacks on LEXSTARproject are very unfair and are uncalled for.
He has every right to post what he wants.
He also has a right to his views and opinions.
He has contributed a lot to this thread and the Etihad Campus thread in good faith.
We don't have to agree with each other, but let's keep it civil please.
Club don't care if the atmosphere is good or not..they would be happy if every seat had a new tourist every game.Exactly mate. I like some of the ideas being floated about on here but a lot of it seems fanciful.
Whilst the club may like a better atmosphere at the ground time and again they've shown everything comes a distant second to matchday income for them.
More half and half scarves, tourists, cringy entertainment and crap around City Square to come I fear.
the club really do want a good atmosphere, our contacts at the club are up for it as much as fans.Club don't care if the atmosphere is good or not..they would be happy if every seat had a new tourist every game.
Sat taking wank videos for tik tok or what ever they do with them
But when he replies that anyone who doesn't lurve the ultras is old fashioned or lives in the past and is against change..or notes that older fans must wear flat caps and work down t'pit in a disparaging manner, then that's ok?
What personal attack has there been? An example would be nice
Bang on mate, THE BIGGEST PROBLEM is getting people to sing, I'm in 119 and it's a decent atmosphere but the amount of people who don't sing or only sing occasionally is huge, I'm a f.o.c but no one outsings me, shouts more or even clapping loud as fuck...that's what the old Kippax did to you, you got behind the team in any which way you could, no you hear people discussing what they are having for tea while the boys are playing...fucking joke just get behind the lads
I find somebody constantly threatening to stick a drum up my arse offensive. :-? Not to mention a megaphone. ;-)
There have a been a couple of unnecessary comments, that’s all.
This is an emotive and passionate subject. Even though we all think there are different ways of improving the atmosphere at the Etihad, we all want a similar outcome. True!?
The sooner the club put us out of our misery regarding their plans for the North stand expansion and improving the atmosphere, the better. Once they do that, and hopefully it will be what most of us want, we can go about improving the atomsphere in conjunction with the club in the future.
To be honest I have been to Palace dozens of times over the years and the atmosphere is very average, especially when losing. West Ham at Upton Park and even Spurs much better than Palace…Ultras or no ultrasNobody wants to live in the past fella. You’re just insulting people because they don’t like cheese on toast ‘Ultras’ guff that you get wet over.
I’ve watched 5 minutes of this Palace game and already thinking of turning it off because of the awful Palace fans in their shit drum and boring ‘CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC CPFC’ chant over and over and over.
It’s nearly as boring as you always talking about ‘Ultras’. We don’t need Ultras, we just need our fans in one area and consistency.
This for me is the most compelling argument for Ultras - they would take the pressure off the people who have gone into themselves, and maybe bring them out of themselves.Bang on mate, THE BIGGEST PROBLEM is getting people to sing, I'm in 119 and it's a decent atmosphere but the amount of people who don't sing or only sing occasionally is huge, I'm a f.o.c but no one outsings me, shouts more or even clapping loud as fuck...that's what the old Kippax did to you, you got behind the team in any which way you could, no you hear people discussing what they are having for tea while the boys are playing...fucking joke just get behind the lads
We’ll get that singing section in the expanded North stand.
RIP Siberiano.