The Stones Goal

Was it right to give a goal?

  • Total voters
    866
ysmsa said:
Has there ever been 2 incidents like these (yesterday and Arse goal against us) where the reporting is completely different.

Gary O'Neil should take a look at the scrutiny all our goals receive to try and rule out them out.

Apparently on the MNC, even though there was nothing wrong with the goal and Bernardo was not interfering with play from an off side position (Rory's words) we still managed to find a loophole that should be closed!

Sound familiar, Villa HOME (my error updated) a couple of years ago.
Click to expand...

Clearly nothing will change from the goal on Sunday, as the 'loophole' would affect half the corners we see every week. We regularly get these 'interfering' goals, and there are a handful each season that are much more worthy of debate that the Silva one.

Just a comment on the Villa 'loophole' though. It's not all one way. PGMOL's response to the Bruno/Rashford goal was the same. They said it was technically onside, but that in the future, due to the reaction across football, similar goals shouldn't be given.
 
Bern was jostling with the keeper most of the game, which they seemed to take in good part? Anyone notice the one when the keeper pinched Bern's ear? If we're having a talking stupid contest, should that have been penalised?
 
ysmsa said:
Has there ever been 2 incidents like these (yesterday and Arse goal against us) where the reporting is completely different.

Gary O'Neil should take a look at the scrutiny all our goals receive to try and rule out them out.

Apparently on the MNC, even though there was nothing wrong with the goal and Bernardo was not interfering with play from an off side position (Rory's words) we still managed to find a loophole that should be closed!

Sound familiar, Villa HOME (my error updated) a couple of years ago.
Click to expand...

Its Boiled Piss again,
But the truth is that the goal is NOT offside, OR Silva fouled the keeper, But Skysports will spend hours debating it,
No other club gets so much airtime on Skysports with the panel debating if we have cheated again, forget all the records and the winning titles and cups, 4 in a row, 5 in a year, It's always the negative and cheat claims.

Did anybody think, "Here we go, when it went to VAR?" City beat the Premier League in court, and it could be payback time. I said straight away GOAL, but knew anything could happen after the court case win
 
Not offside.
Not hindering the goalkeeper when the ball hit Stones on his head.
No Wolves player reacting esp their goalkeeper did nowt.

We totally deserved it. We have to do better though. And we will do so.
Wolves deserved very little. Defending like two doubledeck busses is not my kind of football.
 
eversince 76 said:
Not offside.
Not hindering the goalkeeper when the ball hit Stones on his head.
No Wolves player reacting esp their goalkeeper did nowt.

We totally deserved it. We have to do better though. And we will do so.
Wolves deserved very little. Defending like two doubledeck busses is not my kind of football.
Click to expand...
Agree. Don't like conceding the first goal (or any for that matter) like we keep doing either. I think it might take until after the Nov international break to get a proper rhythm.
 
Stonesy can add this to his Arsenal late theatrics, top man, i wonder how many injury time goals he can get this season!
 
andthesunshineband said:
Bern was jostling with the keeper most of the game, which they seemed to take in good part? Anyone notice the one when the keeper pinched Bern's ear? If we're having a talking stupid contest, should that have been penalised?
Click to expand...
They are international team mates hence the ear pinching.
 
prestonibbo_mcfc said:
Disagree. Eddie is travelling backwards to the back stick and Martinelli makes a back for him. Not a lot he can do really.
Click to expand...
Agree, what should've been done was one of our players runnning into Gabriel and blocking him like they did to Ederson.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top