Gundogan

Status
Not open for further replies.
He's had different injuries and he's not been a complete crock like Wilshere. He's an absolutely class act when fully fit so I'd have him in a heartbeat if this injury isn't going to cause long term issues.
 
As bluemedic says the risk of future knee discolations is high once you have done it. My best friend, a professional sportsman, did it once twisting, with a planted foot and without physical contact. Knee discolation reoccured half a dozen times over his career. He was able to play again but always had an underlying weakness that could sideline him for months.
 
supercity88 said:
He's had different injuries and he's not been a complete crock like Wilshere. He's an absolutely class act when fully fit so I'd have him in a heartbeat if this injury isn't going to cause long term issues.
Click to expand...
Maybe not complete. But some kinda crock :)

I'm not opposed to getting him, but his addition will mean considering given up on current crocks. Sergio we can't touch, but Silva, Nasri, kompany and Delph have to get serious cut considerations. Coz we really can't be carrying so many injury prone guys. Also we are gonna have to consider solid backup options. Coz he will miss time. Tough nosed guys who can come in and mash things up until our gems return.
 
Last edited:
Plain Speaking said:
As bluemedic says the risk of future knee discolations is high once you have done it. My best friend, a professional sportsman, did it once twisting, with a planted foot and without physical contact. Knee discolation reoccured half a dozen times over his career. He was able to play again but always had an underlying weakness that could sideline him for months.
Click to expand...
They might well have wired it given he is a footballer and it won't shift again
 
I just fail to see how you can spend £Millions on a player with such a serious injury.

Its not a twisted ankle or a slight muscle strain, its a dislocated knee cap and as good as he is, I will be amazed if this now goes through this summer at least.
 
blueinsa said:
I just fail to see how you can spend £Millions on a player with such a serious injury.

Its not a twisted ankle or a slight muscle strain, its a dislocated knee cap and as good as he is, I will be amazed if this now goes through this summer at least.
Click to expand...

Maybe if it was a one-off but our track record on rehabilitating injured players is appalling. No, just no, unless it is on a pay as you play deal. I remember thinking the same when we signed Crocky Santa Crock for £19m but was convinced by people who seemed to know better that, somehow, our expert medical team would miraculously put an end to his injuries. That didn't turn out well.
 
karen7 said:
They might well have wired it given he is a footballer and it won't shift again
Click to expand...
If he has surgery to stabilise the patellar then we can expect a significantly longer period of downtime (++months). If there's no obvious reason for the dislocation & no tear in the MPFL or sheared cartilage lying around then you'd expect them to just try to strengthen the surrounding muscles through a physio regime to prevent re-dislocation rather than operate.
 
Laporte, Gundogan top targets since months and they get serious injuries during negotiation. Unreal fucking unreal.

No idea how injury prone they are, but PL and the lack of winter break and more games and probably a more intense playing style under Pep is just gonna make injury prone players face even more misery. Huge money and thinking should go into the physio department as well. surely some top doctors can be signed as well.
The skinny (Italian?) guy in glasses looks to me like has no idea about injuries when he runs onto the pitch, and it shows given our players getting injured so much and then they come back in a mediocre shape and get injured again or we just blame former injuries too long for lack of form.

Instead of new signings hit the ground running with a good pre season they might start light training in September?

It could be the difference between a succesful season and a bad one.

I think playing stats should be important part of signing a players, based on his past seasons about how many games we can count on him usually.
 
Damanino said:
Laporte, Gundogan top targets since months and they get serious injuries during negotiation. Unreal fucking unreal.

No idea how injury prone they are, but PL and the lack of winter break and more games and probably a more intense playing style under Pep is just gonna make injury prone players face even more misery. Huge money and thinking should go into the physio department as well. surely some top doctors can be signed as well.
The skinny (Italian?) guy in glasses looks to me like has no idea about injuries when he runs onto the pitch, and it shows given our players getting injured so much and then they come back in a mediocre shape and get injured again or we just blame former injuries too long for lack of form.

Instead of new signings hit the ground running with a good pre season they might start light training in September?

It could be the difference between a succesful season and a bad one.

I think playing stats should be important part of signing a players, based on his past seasons about how many games we can count on him usually.
Click to expand...

A+D = Yellow.

What an absurd statement. You know nothing about him or his training and our injury record DOES NOT support you unsubstantiated claim about this person.
 
Just had a chat with someone who is the know never mind in the know.

Laporte
Gundongen
Pogpa - we hope
Zabba - gone
Mangala - gone
Kolarov wants to stay!
The blond kid from the eds. the left back to be given a chance.
Stones - no

Don't want any shit for this. Posted in absolute good faith.

Yaya - China
 
worsleyweb said:
Just had a chat with someone who is the know never mind in the know.

Laporte
Gundongen
Pogpa - we hope
Zabba - gone
Mangala - gone
Kolarov wants to stay!
The blond kid from the eds. the left back to be given a chance.
Stones - no

Don't want any shit for this. Posted in absolute good faith.

Yaya - China
Click to expand...

Are we getting 70mil for yaya then?
 
worsleyweb said:
Just had a chat with someone who is the know never mind in the know.

Laporte
Gundongen
Pogpa - we hope
Zabba - gone
Mangala - gone
Kolarov wants to stay!
The blond kid from the eds. the left back to be given a chance.
Stones - no

Don't want any shit for this. Posted in absolute good faith.

Yaya - China
Click to expand...

Pogba will surely depend on CL

Thank fuck Kolarov wants to stay ;)

Thanks for the info but tin hat on now
 
worsleyweb said:
Just had a chat with someone who is the know never mind in the know.

Laporte
Gundongen
Pogpa - we hope
Zabba - gone
Mangala - gone
Kolarov wants to stay!
The blond kid from the eds. the left back to be given a chance.
Stones - no

Don't want any shit for this. Posted in absolute good faith.

Yaya - China
Click to expand...
To be fair i could have told you that from reading on here
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top