Interesting that players remember the Kippax and talk about it almost as much as we fans. I heard an interview in French with Ali Benarbia in which he basically said that when it was rocking there was nothing else like it that he experienced in his career.
This whole discussion leads me directly to think how important it is to get the North Stand development right. Nothing will ever replace the Kippax, of course. But if handled correctly it could go some way to reconstituting that atmosphere we generated on good days (and I can remember plenty of flat ones when the Kippax, up to then as quiet a mouse, would start chanting “Celtic, Rangers, Celtic, Rangers, Celtic, Rangers” and on and on out of sheer boredom. I remember going to an end of season game against, I think, Sunderland. Utterly meaningless. We got beat, I think. And I got drenched, because I was nearer the front than I usually was and the prevailing wind was pushing the squalls of rain onto all of the front rows. I invaded the pitch at the end, though, so at least that was good (the one time I did).
It's taken me a long time to feel that the Etihad is some kind of home. But when it was really rocking the other night, against Arsenal, I looked round and felt it. I definitely did.