De Gea has been absolutely shite for the last three seasons , hence why the Rags have no intention of renewing his contract unless he is willing to take a massive drop on his current salary.
Not sure why you would compare him to a Rag , Why ? Pickford is the bench mark in the Premier league not DeGea , Pickford's all round game including his distribution is excellent , he makes the odd clanger but ALL keepers do.
But i dont have an issue with Ederson , he is in the top half a dozen in europe , a lot on here will shoot me down , but when has Ederson cost us one of the really big games ? He's fearless , brave and the best in the league with his feet , the downside he is hot headed at times and does get caught cold when he has been a spectator for 95% of most games.
Having been a keeper for a quite a few years , freezing you balls off whilst watching the game 60 yards away from you must be a challenge for your concentration , unluckily the team i played for wasnt a Pep team and i was never out of the action for more than a few minutes because we were shite most of the time :)
Style-wise De Gea's pretty much the polar opposite of Ederson. He's a dying breed almost now though, hence not getting in the Spain squad even anymore - plus his performances have dropped off for a few seasons. I'd say he has managed to get some form back this season, but it's an area that united will be looking to improve and by getting a more proactive keeper they may be able to start playing out from the back a little.
That might weaken them a bit though, because they're built as a counter-attacking team and they'll need to adapt.
Know what you mean about it being a difficult job though. When the one shot on goal you get against you is a pretty decent chance you can end up without much chance to show what you can do and through no fault of your own. Wish we could stick with a consistent defensive line up for a while so that we might stop giving away some of the chances that are coming. We need to find some consistency soon.