5 worst refereeing decisions against city

[oakiecokie]

Sorry I couldn't find the '5 worst goal line official decisions against City' thread.

So why mention it if its not a refs fault ? Thats exactly what the title thread says.Hardly his fault as I said.

 

[Sergio Picasso Aguero]

I didn't specifically say referee decisions, I was talking about decisions that have gone against us in general and as there was no other thread about goal line officials this seemed like the most appropriate place to mention it.

 

[solley attwell]

There was also the derby at the swamp when the Goat came on as a sub and scored after 11 secs and there was a disallowed goal later that had the rags scored would have been allowed. About 2003 , can't remember the ref but I'm sure it's one of the usual suspects

 

[es1]

There was also the derby at the swamp when the Goat came on as a sub and scored after 11 secs and there was a disallowed goal later that had the rags scored would have been allowed. About 2003 , can't remember the ref but I'm sure it's one of the usual suspects

it was alan wiley and was a clear handball by anekla to control the ball before squaring it

every decision against us must be part of a conspiracy...

 

[A Blue]

Not clear at all. Ball to hand. In fact Anelka's hand if anything is moving away from the ball. It's a conspiracy.....

 

[Bentheblue]

Not clear at all. Ball to hand. In fact Anelka's hand if anything is moving away from the ball. It's a conspiracy.....

That's how I remember it and I thought the ball just brushed Anelka's hand. Watched it in a pub full of rags, who were laughing their heads off because they had got away with one.

 

[Gundogan's Moustache]

Demichelis disallowed goal is in with a shout.

He was given the goal apparently , Rob Harris just tweeted about it

 

[portisheadblue]

That Rob Harris tweet and Facebook has to be a piss take surely or can UEFA be that crass?

 

[ROCKET80]

I was going to say this one, just an unbelievable decision and at a time when a League Cup Quarter Final was absolutely huge for us. Against Ipswich wasn't it?

Right you are, it was Ipswich. Shocking decision.

Regarding that Owen goal in the derby, I know that time was added on for 'excessive celebration' but were we not told by the media and FA at the time that every substitution adds 30sec to stoppage time too?

Though that was never the case before and never been the case since.

 

[Mancini Manus Domini]

The one that sticks in my mind is when Sylvan Distin, who I think was our captain at the time, was upset with a decision made in the first half at Stamford Bridge by David Ellary. They were walking off at half time, and because Distin wouldn't give him the ball back immediately he gave him a 2nd yellow and sent him off.

 

[Gingers Dad]

Right you are, it was Ipswich. Shocking decision.

Regarding that Owen goal in the derby, I know that time was added on for 'excessive celebration' but were we not told by the media and FA at the time that every substitution adds 30sec to stoppage time too?

Though that was never the case before and never been the case since.

Motd added the time up and came to the conclusion that the ref had added the correct time on to about the second. They failed to mention why we kicked off after and played a further 20 seconds. The ref had two opportunities to end the game prior to the goal but bottled it.

Horlock sent off because the ref didn't like the way he walked towards him and Morrison for blowing a kiss were classic injustice