Now you've finally grasped he isn't an attacking midfielder ala Mcatee, do you want to suggest any of these 6's we can get who are young enough and good enough to play a squad role for us at sub 50m?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Adam Wharton
- Thread starter It'sBlue93:20
- Start date
If Wharton was to be sold for 30/40m it would be worth it. He could work into the rotation to start and supplant some the senior players as that time comes.
With palace saying they wanted 100m for him or something, it's a complete non starter. He's nowhere near that level yet and paying any sort of future valuation makes no sense.
There's too much other talent in the world to pay a massive fee for this guy. It's just too much risk as it stands currently
With palace saying they wanted 100m for him or something, it's a complete non starter. He's nowhere near that level yet and paying any sort of future valuation makes no sense.
There's too much other talent in the world to pay a massive fee for this guy. It's just too much risk as it stands currently
Still a much better player than Wharton who only has potential.So, just as expensive, much older and on huge wages and would want to play every game.
Not the best option.
McAtee can be converted if required to play deeper if Pep wished. He still has plans for him. Rico Lewis is another who could play the 6 if Pep wants him in that role. Both are young players who still have time on their sides and are equally talented as Wharton.Now you've finally grasped he isn't an attacking midfielder ala Mcatee, do you want to suggest any of these 6's we can get who are young enough and good enough to play a squad role for us at sub 50m?
Alan Harper's Tash
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Dec 2010
- Messages
- 61,099
Kimmich would be the better option should Walker leave. He’d then have an avenue to more first team games.Still a much better player than Wharton who only has potential.
As it stands, we need an understudy to Rodri. That generally means an uo and coming youngster to learn or an older player not so fussed about minutes.
A lot of us in here think Wharton ls the best option of that type of player.
I disagree especially what Palace would ask for Wharton.Kimmich would be the better option should Walker leave. He’d then have an avenue to more first team games.
As it stands, we need an understudy to Rodri. That generally means an uo and coming youngster to learn or an older player not so fussed about minutes.
A lot of us in here think Wharton ls the best option of that type of player.
Alan Harper's Tash
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Dec 2010
- Messages
- 61,099
Similar price to Kimmich. 8 years younger. Wouldn’t demand to play every game. Learns from Rodri. Takes over from Rodri.I disagree especially what Palace would ask for Wharton.
No different to Rodri graduating into Fernandinho’s boots.
Then McAtee is another you've hardly watched. Pep is a genius but even he couldn't turn McAtee in to a 6. Why would he want to he's got the potential to be a great player for City in the role he's played his whole career - a role that hasn't remotely been as a 6.McAtee can be converted if required to play deeper if Pep wished. He still has plans for him.
I have seen him a lot and he is just as talented as Wharton and he has cost us nothing. If Wharton was highly talented he would already been snapped up by a higher profile club by now.Then McAtee is another you've hardly watched. Pep is a genius but even he couldn't turn McAtee in to a 6. Why would he want to he's got the potential to be a great player for City in the role he's played his whole career - a role that hasn't remotely been as a 6.
I rather keep the money for someone who is more talented.Similar price to Kimmich. 8 years younger. Wouldn’t demand to play every game. Learns from Rodri. Takes over from Rodri.
No different to Rodri graduating into Fernandinho’s boots.