Atmosphere 2024/25

  • Thread starter Thread starter jrb
  • Start date Start date
EastMidlandsBlue said:
If you think SS1 only make noise on a rare occasion, then it's very clear that the sound doesn't carry well to 105.

SS1 sing most of the game
Click to expand...
No they don't.

Being so tribaI (childish) I hear every away fans' chant and everything that comes out of SSL1.

SSL1's output is, for the most part, infrequent and underpowered.
 
GortonBlue62 said:
We need the fans in the stadium to take responsibility for that.

What do people want the club to do? Hold auditions so only fans with loud voices can go in the new NSL2?
Click to expand...
No but if there’s no organisation to actually make it a singing end with appropriate pricing and no support from 1894 (which there won’t be) it will be a disaster.
 
I’m an occasional visitor to 115 / 116 and every time I’ve been there people around me sing pretty much the whole time
 
GortonBlue62 said:
No they don't.

Being so tribaI (childish) I hear every away fans' chant and everything that comes out of SSL1.

SSL1's output is, for the most part, infrequent and underpowered.
Click to expand...

You obviously don't stand on SSL1.

If you think SSL1 output is for the most part, infrequent and underpowered, really?, I'd hate to think what you think about the rest of the stadiums output.
 
jrb said:
You obviously don't stand on SSL1.

If you think SSL1 output is for the most part, infrequent and underpowered, really?, I'd hate to think what you think about the rest of the stadiums output.
Click to expand...
If you're correct why are we discussing the atmosphere?

If SSL1 'performs' there is no issue with the atmosphere.

Time and again, game after game, my brother and I wonder where the fuck is our singing section?
 
GortonBlue62 said:
If you're correct why are we discussing the atmosphere?

If SSL1 'performs' there is no issue with the atmosphere.

Time and again, game after game, my brother and I wonder where the fuck is our singing section?
Click to expand...
There’s a big difference to all 115/116 singing and the reality where a small proportion of 115/116 are constantly singing. If 115/116 was full of singers it would make a huge difference, but there are plenty in there who hardly make a sound for 75% of games.
 
it’s a shame the away car park is where it is and there seems no alternative because the cheapest and best option is to shift the away fans. EL1 like a sing song but usually join in when there is a well constructed chant coming from the corner or SSL3. Very rarely does EL1 join in with chants from SSL1 due to poor acoustics and the away fan split. When atmosphere is up EL1 are usually singing different tunes to SSL1.
Shift the away fans and you have a full South stand all levels and East level 1 full length who would belt out the tunes in unison.
 
If we can't move the away fans move the cameras to the other side. This would make the away fans dissappear round the corner as at OT and Anfield. Nothing more annoying on telly than see the away fans erupt as we concede a goal in the south stand end. Realise I am speaking for the armchair fans here which regrettably is me these days.
 
Spurs quarter 69 said:
If we can't move the away fans move the cameras to the other side. This would make the away fans dissappear round the corner as at OT and Anfield. Nothing more annoying on telly than see the away fans erupt as we concede a goal in the south stand end. Realise I am speaking for the armchair fans here which regrettably is me these days.
Click to expand...
No chance of a camera move with the Manchester sun, ok it's only out a couple of games a season but it'd make armchair viewing difficult.
 
GortonBlue62 said:
The home fans currently in those blocks (109 and 110 I think) regularly put SSL1 to shame.
Click to expand...
Not difficult .....SS1/2/3 should be all City with ES1 relocating to SS2/3 & away fans being moved round the corner flag to ES1/SS1.

The best acoustics in the stadium come from height and a concentration of noise. Our fans are split up over 3/4 disconnected zones.

Sound/acoustic speakers in arenas,theatres stadiums are always stacked vertically NOT horizontally....ask yourself why !!
 
GortonBlue62 said:
If you're correct why are we discussing the atmosphere?

If SSL1 'performs' there is no issue with the atmosphere.

Time and again, game after game, my brother and I wonder where the fuck is our singing section?
Click to expand...
So you didn't hear SSL1 on Sunday at all?

Do me a favour! Lol!

I've sat on CBL1 and CBL2 and I've heard SSL1.

I heard 111, 110, 109, and ESL1 on Sunday.

I've heard the NS at times.

There's obviously something wrong with your hearing. Get it checked out.

The thread is about the atmosphere around the ground, not just about SSL1.
 
jrb said:
So you didn't hear SSL1 on Sunday at all?

Do me a favour! Lol!

I've sat on CBL1 and CBL2 and I've heard SSL1.

I heard 111, 110, 109, and ESL1 on Sunday.

I've heard the NS at times.

There's obviously something wrong with your hearing. Get it checked out.

The thread is about the atmosphere around the ground, not just about SSL1.
Click to expand...
SSL1 drives the atmosphere around the ground which is why we're discussing it.

SSL1 were OK on Sunday.

Nothing wrong with my hearing.

Nobody is saying the atmosphere is always bad.

The fact that it is sometimes very good surely invalidates, or at least weakens, your argument that the stadium configuration is the decisive factor.
 
Man_City_Loyal said:
If SSL1 is always singing (You can hear them from CB Level 3) but others can not.

What do you do to improve the acoustics?
Click to expand...

It's not really a mystery. The noise travels up and so people in CBL3 can hear it but generally if you're anywhere near the NS you hear SSL3 over SSL1. That's because the roof refracts the noise back into the ground. I've seen plenty of occasions where SSL1 people think it's been buzzing and they've made a racket, but that's not reached other parts of the ground.

You need the singers under the roof, it's as simple as that. The roof has materials to refract the noise, rather than it travelling upwards getting muffled by clothes and lost. The new NS is proposing materials to help retain noise and that will amplify around the ground and everyone will hear it. SSL1 could have thousands of fans making a racket, but stick that same number under the roof and they're getting amplified.
 
Man_City_Loyal said:
If SSL1 is always singing (You can hear them from CB Level 3) but others can not.

What do you do to improve the acoustics?
Click to expand...
You encourage our singers to move to a brand spanking new North Stand, get them all under the roof, and the sound they make will boom around the Etihad
 
supercity88 said:
It's not really a mystery. The noise travels up and so people in CBL3 can hear it but generally if you're anywhere near the NS you hear SSL3 over SSL1. That's because the roof refracts the noise back into the ground. I've seen plenty of occasions where SSL1 people think it's been buzzing and they've made a racket, but that's not reached other parts of the ground.

You need the singers under the roof, it's as simple as that. The roof has materials to refract the noise, rather than it travelling upwards getting muffled by clothes and lost. The new NS is proposing materials to help retain noise and that will amplify around the ground and everyone will hear it. SSL1 could have thousands of fans making a racket, but stick that same number under the roof and they're getting amplified.
Click to expand...
1000008386.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top