danburge82 said:
I am our biggest critic when it comes to atmosphere. It's not whinging for no reason; we are well average, often shite. The thing is we have changed so much in so many ways that atmosphere has become a major issue.
Firstly, since 1994 we haven't had a stand that is of a big enough size to be heard loud and clear or to be part of so you hear and learn songs. The move to the CoMS in 2003 made that worse as South Stand Level 1 was even smaller than the North Stand was at Maine Road. Even when i add the East/South corner Level 1 to the SSL1 it only comes to 3000 fans. That's just 6% of the capacity of our stadium. I can add to that mates of these people who sit around the ground, or people who go to pubs and are exposed to songs, or even away game travellers - but all these added together probably only comes to about 10000 fans. That's still only 21% of our total capacity. The whole of the other 79% of our fans will not know anymore songs than the 4 or 5 we always sing.
Around the ground we often can't hear the vocal areas as they aren't that loud unless you're in them so this other lot of fans will never learn or get to sing any new songs. Thus, atmosphere will never improve.
The only way this will improve is to provide a much bigger vocal area. 6% is fucking ludicrous! It's a bloody scandal, i tell yer! A bigger vocal area - obviously - house more people; more people will be exposed to all the variety of songs [that we do have by the way] and will learn and sing the songs; this will allow songs to be heard loud and clear by the rest of the crowd and thus they will then learn more songs and be able to join in.
This is the bigger picture i've been talkinig about endlessly when it comes to atmosphere. I must talk about this subject more than any other, and i do email City a lot about it. Maybe one day it will change, hopefully!
you and me both Dan, You and me both.
The problem is that the people who sit in the two singing areas don't agree, because they can't hear anything but themselves.
Proper atmosphere is when the whole ground join in. They will, if given a lead. Not always, but at the right moments. But at the right moments we either get the south stand drowned out by the way fans, and noone in the Colin Bell taking their lead. Or two different songs going at once, meaning noone else joins in.
If the ground has one voice, not two, things will improve.