Ntini77
Well-Known Member
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
I thought it was a red tbh but I've only seen it once.
Anyways, can he play on Wednesday ?
I thought it was a red tbh but I've only seen it once.
Anyways, can he play on Wednesday ?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Ballotelli appeal (Merged)
- Thread starter meldrew
- Start date
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
i was watching it on a poor internet stream and I assumed that he'd got a 2nd yellow. Not a straight red, but waiting for MOTD pictures to clarify. Their pundits verdict is important....not for the rights and wrongs, but for the success of any appeal.
i was watching it on a poor internet stream and I assumed that he'd got a 2nd yellow. Not a straight red, but waiting for MOTD pictures to clarify. Their pundits verdict is important....not for the rights and wrongs, but for the success of any appeal.
johnny crossan
Well-Known Member
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
If Andy Gray says he's innocent who are we to argue?
If Andy Gray says he's innocent who are we to argue?
cptaidan88
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 8 Dec 2008
- Messages
- 4,260
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
Went to the game so Ive only seen both incidents once and they both looked harsh at the time, particularly for the second to be a straight red. However I would like to know if this has been covered....
Assuming we appeal, I believe it would be a similar situation to the one Camelface found himself in before the 2nd leg of the cc semi-final last year. He wasnt sent off but was subsequently charged because of an elbow on a Wolves player and was able to appeal which meant he could play when he should have been banned.
There is obviously the potential that the ban could be extended to 4 games but if this situation arises would we prefer to have him available for the derby but miss Birmingham, Fulham, Stoke, and maybe Bolton; or not appeal and trust we have enough without him for just Utd, Birmingham, and Fulham?
Went to the game so Ive only seen both incidents once and they both looked harsh at the time, particularly for the second to be a straight red. However I would like to know if this has been covered....
Assuming we appeal, I believe it would be a similar situation to the one Camelface found himself in before the 2nd leg of the cc semi-final last year. He wasnt sent off but was subsequently charged because of an elbow on a Wolves player and was able to appeal which meant he could play when he should have been banned.
There is obviously the potential that the ban could be extended to 4 games but if this situation arises would we prefer to have him available for the derby but miss Birmingham, Fulham, Stoke, and maybe Bolton; or not appeal and trust we have enough without him for just Utd, Birmingham, and Fulham?
marco
Well-Known Member
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
thats what i thought a 2nd yellow, im sure he had that card out before the red,but it looks like i'm wrong because most say it was a straight red and what you say about the pundits verdict is 100% correct this will swing the decision, lets wait and see match of the day imo he should win the appeal
Marvin said:i was watching it on a poor internet stream and I assumed that he'd got a 2nd yellow. Not a straight red, but waiting for MOTD pictures to clarify. Their pundits verdict is important....not for the rights and wrongs, but for the success of any appeal.
thats what i thought a 2nd yellow, im sure he had that card out before the red,but it looks like i'm wrong because most say it was a straight red and what you say about the pundits verdict is 100% correct this will swing the decision, lets wait and see match of the day imo he should win the appeal
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
This may be naive but if ,as seems to be the general consensus on here , Ballotelli's red card is questionable then I think the club is right to appeal, not just for the ramifications of him playing the derby etc but because to me it shows unity. We would be saying, we are standing up for player who has been mistreated and we will not have that. Win or lose we would have voiced our protest and stood by our man. It may be a bit fanciful but I believe it would be good for the players morale to know the club is behind them and will back them.
This may be naive but if ,as seems to be the general consensus on here , Ballotelli's red card is questionable then I think the club is right to appeal, not just for the ramifications of him playing the derby etc but because to me it shows unity. We would be saying, we are standing up for player who has been mistreated and we will not have that. Win or lose we would have voiced our protest and stood by our man. It may be a bit fanciful but I believe it would be good for the players morale to know the club is behind them and will back them.
Shooter 83
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 26 Aug 2008
- Messages
- 4,234
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
Seen it at the game and thought it was a red, just seen ss highlights its never a red in a million years the guy fakes it he never touched his face. Ref had it for him, ****.
Seen it at the game and thought it was a red, just seen ss highlights its never a red in a million years the guy fakes it he never touched his face. Ref had it for him, ****.
marco
Well-Known Member
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
the ref was going to let it go untill the west brom players played up thats when he pulled the card out,he'l get it revoked
Shooter 83 said:Seen it at the game and thought it was a red, just seen ss highlights its never a red in a million years the guy fakes it he never touched his face. Ref had it for him, ****.
the ref was going to let it go untill the west brom players played up thats when he pulled the card out,he'l get it revoked
whosonthebench
Well-Known Member
Re: Ballotelli appeal?
I didn't think you could appeal if it was a second yellow?
anyway, ref was against us all game and Balos lash out was the tipping point.
I didn't think you could appeal if it was a second yellow?
anyway, ref was against us all game and Balos lash out was the tipping point.