You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Best and worst refereeing decisions in City matches
- Thread starter isab23502
- Start date
lust overlord
Well-Known Member
As been mentioned the Alan Wilkie phantom penalty v the rags
We never get any dodgy favourable descisions ever ;-)
We never get any dodgy favourable descisions ever ;-)
lancs blue said:fathellensbellend said:clive thomas at derby away late 70's disallowing a tueart goal claiming he had blown the full time whistle, like he did in the 78 world cup brazil v sweden, sure it was tueart i was only young so someone maybe able to clarify.
george courtney away at grimsby 1983/84, anyone who was there will never forget his bent display.
norwich away under royle i think, the black linesman who single handedly robbed city all night with woeful decisions, cannot remember how many goals he cost us.
roger milford disallowing a perfectly good goal from niall quinn at highbury, denying us a very very rare win there.
alan wilkie at old trafford, just corrupt.
Ha ha, I'd forgotten that plank, was it Mark Kennedy or Kev Horlock that he flagged offside with a defender practically stood on the goal-line?
Did we win that game?
bluebrother55
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Oct 2011
- Messages
- 1,137
The fa cup tie at the swamp when we were winning 1-0 through Rosler's goal and the Rags could barely muster an attack when all of a sudden the Ref awarded them a penalty for nothing and Cuntona equalised.
carlos tevez is a blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 16,121
Worst, FA cup last season, not Kompany's sending off but when Jones handballed it then looked right at the left pointing to his hand laughing.
lancs blue
Well-Known Member
isab23502 said:lancs blue said:fathellensbellend said:clive thomas at derby away late 70's disallowing a tueart goal claiming he had blown the full time whistle, like he did in the 78 world cup brazil v sweden, sure it was tueart i was only young so someone maybe able to clarify.
george courtney away at grimsby 1983/84, anyone who was there will never forget his bent display.
norwich away under royle i think, the black linesman who single handedly robbed city all night with woeful decisions, cannot remember how many goals he cost us.
roger milford disallowing a perfectly good goal from niall quinn at highbury, denying us a very very rare win there.
alan wilkie at old trafford, just corrupt.
Ha ha, I'd forgotten that plank, was it Mark Kennedy or Kev Horlock that he flagged offside with a defender practically stood on the goal-line?
Did we win that game?
No we lost, 1-0 I think.
danny123
Well-Known Member
Didn't Walton have an absolute stinker when we played Everton a few years back at home on a freezing cold night?
Burnage Burnsy
Well-Known Member
lancs blue said:isab23502 said:lancs blue said:Ha ha, I'd forgotten that plank, was it Mark Kennedy or Kev Horlock that he flagged offside with a defender practically stood on the goal-line?
Did we win that game?
No we lost, 1-0 I think.
Yeah we did. Had 2 disallowed for seemingly nothing. Thought it was Goat and Huckerby though but my memory is bolloxed.
lancs blue
Well-Known Member
Burnage Burnsy said:lancs blue said:isab23502 said:Did we win that game?
No we lost, 1-0 I think.
Yeah we did. Had 2 disallowed for seemingly nothing. Thought it was Goat and Huckerby though but my memory is bolloxed.
So is mine so you could be right!
can't remember if it was ball or thatcher who stamped on Ronaldo right under the refs nose but do remember the ref was Howard Webb even though he's totally biased for United and against City ;)<br /><br />-- Tue Jul 31, 2012 3:40 pm --<br /><br />can't remember if it was ball or thatcher who stamped on Ronaldo right under the refs nose but do remember the ref was Howard Webb even though he's totally biased for United and against City ;)