Biggest mistake City have ever made?

Peter Swales was one massive mistake.But he wasn`t the only one i can think of appointing Alan Ball as manager as well.There have been plenty of cock ups in Manchester City F.C land.
 
sacking joe mercer. if ever a club could have kicked on it was us then. we never recovered, yes we got lucky with the sheik but we actually never did recover under our own steam.
 
paulchapo said:
Appointing Peter Swales as chairman.His cack handed mismanagement almost put our club out of existance and without the latest takeover we would be a mid table/yo yo club at best.When he took over we were one of the top clubs in England.

I've just seen this thread and can't be arsed reading through all the posts.

I think P.J. appointed himself when he invested in the club. So, what happened over the next 18 years in no one's fault, but Swales himself.

I will never forgive him for the way he dragged this great club down, starting with his backing of Allison to take over as manager from Sir Joe.
 
I have read all the threads and they make intresting reading.The lad who said Brian Horton was a mistake.Wrong he was quite good manager for Manchester City.Biggest mistake Francis Lee did sacking Brian Horton.
 
Tony Coton - £500,000
Andy Hinchcliffe - fuck all
Colin Hendry - fuck all
Keith Curle - £650,000
Michael Hughes - £450,000
Paul Lake - scrimping on medical bills
Paul Walsh - Gerry Creaney
Garry Flitcroft - £3.5 million
Steve Lomas - £1.6 million
Georgio Kinkladze - £5 million
Clive Allen - fuck all
Nigel De Jong - £3.5 million
Felip Caicedo - £1 million
Martin Petrov - Free
Georgios Samaras - £1 million
Nicolas Anelka - £7 million
Matias Vuoso - free
Kevin Horlock - £300,000
Nicky Summerbee - £1 million
Michael Brown - £400,000
Niall Quinn - £1.3 million
Eyal Berkovic - free
Jo - fuck all
 
citykev28 said:
Tony Coton - £500,000
Andy Hinchcliffe - fuck all
Colin Hendry - fuck all
Keith Curle - £650,000
Michael Hughes - £450,000
Paul Lake - scrimping on medical bills
Paul Walsh - Gerry Creaney
Garry Flitcroft - £3.5 million
Steve Lomas - £1.6 million
Georgio Kinkladze - £5 million
Clive Allen - fuck all
Nigel De Jong - £3.5 million
Felip Caicedo - £1 million
Martin Petrov - Free
Georgios Samaras - £1 million
Nicolas Anelka - £7 million
Matias Vuoso - free
Kevin Horlock - £300,000
Nicky Summerbee - £1 million
Michael Brown - £400,000
Niall Quinn - £1.3 million
Eyal Berkovic - free
Jo - fuck all

Steve Daley £300,000!

Jesus that list is frightening.
 
Gary James said:
Allowing those who launched the takeover of City in November 1970 (when we were holders of 2 major trophies) - Joe Smith, Ian Niven, Simon Cussins, Michael Horwich and Chris Muir - to talk with existing board and progress their takeover of the club.

That led to most of that group joining the board; they split the Mercer-Allison highly successful partnership; brought Peter Swales in; they supported Swales for most of his City career; turned City into a club that was losing money year on year rather than one that was making a profitable; led to City being a failed club and fallen giant; and also some of those same people talked Peter Swales into bringing back Malcolm Allison.

Without them who knows what would have happened, but it couldn't have been much worse.

As for Thaksin - I strongly disagree that he was one of the biggest mistakes. City could have gone under without his arrival; he took the club into clear ownership (rather than thousands of shareholders - that may annoy me personally but it actually ensured the club could be sold to the Sheikh); he brought in Sven instead of Hughes (who the existing MD claimed he had wanted); he brought in Garry Cook who fought a few very important internal battles and - this I have on tape direct from the Sheikh's immediate advisors - Cook was the most impressive thing about MCFC when they started their negotiations.

Thaksin made money out of City and did make odd demands at the time of the sale (but I know he's not the only man to have made money out of City and made odd demands when selling!) but his period was vital in the transition between the failing club we had and the one we have today.

EDIT: I'd also like to add that Thaksin did have a longer term plan for City. Not 20 years maybe, but at least 5. Anyone who sat in meetings during that time (which I did) will have heard him talk of his ideas to turn City into a global club (some ideas were very crazy, but others could have worked).
It was only when his assets were frozen that he struggled financially and was unable to do what he had planned to do.
Really interesting post there. Thanks.
 
Appointing Steve Coppell as manager wasn't the wisest thing to do ..... never in a million years was that ever gonna work.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.