City to axe Mancini

[jay_mcfc]

What Mancini really needs is another one or two transfer windows so he can sell the players he doesn't want. I wonder if Hughes will be happy paying £18m for RSC, £12m for Barry, £24m for Lescott, £18m for Jo and £14m for Bellamy now he's at Fulham as that is clearly what he thinks they're worth.

 

[Glasgow Man City]

How anyone can compare the scottish devision to the italian league is beyond me, that comparison is apples and oranges mate. come up with a better one because that is bobins.

It's about comparing either to the EPL & that's the point neither are comparable so what has been achieved away from the EPL is irrelevant.

 

[bluejean1]

Personally I don't think this is the answer. Sacking Mancini at this stage wouldn't be a help at all. City have a history of sacking managers after a brief period of time, the most successful clubs tend to keep their managers for quite a time and give them a chance, Mancini hasn't had long enough. I don't care about Man U, Liverpool and any other club in the world, City is my club and has been foir over 50 years - I only care about them. There does appear to be some problems within the clun and they do need to get sorted out. The newspapers are full of details of the drinking culture with some of the players and there does seem to be a dicipline problem there, is that because there are so many prima donnas with the players, they are on so much money they think they can do what they want. I don't know what the answer is but I don;t think sacking Mancini is the answer.

 

[Freestyler]

He's going absolutely nowhere.

 

[Marvin]

How anyone can compare the scottish devision to the italian league is beyond me, that comparison is apples and oranges mate. come up with a better one because that is bobins.

It's about comparing either to the EPL & that's the point neither are comparable so what has been achieved away from the EPL is irrelevant.

Don't be ridiculous. It's not rugby. it's exactly the same skill set involved.

You going to tell me that Mourinho, Hiddink, Capello's foreign trophies were all meaningless as regards their fitness to manage in the Premier League?

The SPL doesn;t come into it, because there's only 2 teams in that, but Serie A is, or certainly was one of Europe's top Leagues. The Premier league is above all else an international League

 

[Blue_Rossy]

Didn't the rags say once when Taggert took over that he wasn't good enough???
How did that work out again??

We have to stick with Mancini for at least another season!!

 

[jay_mcfc]

It's about comparing either to the EPL & that's the point neither are comparable so what has been achieved away from the EPL is irrelevant.

Don't be ridiculous. It's not rugby. it's exactly the same skill set involved.

You going to tell me that Mourinho, Hiddink, Capello's foreign trophies were all meaningless as regards their fitness to manage in the Premier League?

The SPL doesn;t come into it, because there's only 2 teams in that, but Serie A is, or certainly was one of Europe's top Leagues. The Premier league is above all else an international League[/quote]

Don't waste your time mate. I've heard some shite on here before, but this is close to topping it.

 

[Glasgow Man City]

It's about comparing either to the EPL & that's the point neither are comparable so what has been achieved away from the EPL is irrelevant.

Don't be ridiculous. It's not rugby. it's exactly the same skill set involved.

You going to tell me that Mourinho, Hiddink, Capello's foreign trophies were all meaningless as regards their fitness to manage in the Premier League?

The SPL doesn;t come into it, because there's only 2 teams in that, but Serie A is, or certainly was one of Europe's top Leagues. The Premier league is above all else an international League

Mourinho is an exceptional manager and tbf so is Hiddink. How exactly did Capello cope with his first real test???

The British game is completely different to the Italian or Spanish game, and if you can't see that, then you are being deliberately obtuse.

Look at the Spurs game last season at home. Do you think any manager with a high knowledge of the British game would have played the tactics Mancini played?

As said above, it works both ways very few British managers could do it abroad, as I said Ferguson would never have been as successful if he'd left Aberdeen to go to Madrid/Milan etc.<br /><br />-- Tue Nov 02, 2010 7:23 pm --<br /><br />

Don't waste your time mate. I've heard some shite on here before, but this is close to topping it.

Sorry you see it as a waste of time.

 

[Marvin]

Don't be ridiculous. It's not rugby. it's exactly the same skill set involved.

You going to tell me that Mourinho, Hiddink, Capello's foreign trophies were all meaningless as regards their fitness to manage in the Premier League?

The SPL doesn;t come into it, because there's only 2 teams in that, but Serie A is, or certainly was one of Europe's top Leagues. The Premier league is above all else an international League

Mourinho is an exceptional manager and tbf so is Hiddink. How exactly did Capello cope with his first real test???

The British game is completely different to the Italian or Spanish game, and if you can't see that, then you are being deliberately obtuse.

Look at the Spurs game last season at home. Do you think any manager with a high knowledge of the British game would have played the tactics Mancini played?

As said above, it works both ways very few British managers could do it abroad, as I said Ferguson would never have been as successful if he'd left Aberdeen to go to Madrid/Milan etc.

There was nothing wrong with the tactics Mancini played against Spurs.

There are some differences between the English and European Leagues, but increasingly these are disappearing because of the number of foreign coaches and footballers. Of course there are some nuances, but to dismisss a manager's record abroad as irrelevant is not right.

capello is a different argument, but are you telling me that he's not a good club manager? Let's not go there.

If there's a manager in the British game who should be questioned it's Bruce at Sunderland who lost 5-1 to Newcastle and who paid £13 M for a striker and wont play him.

 

[Bunardinlian]

QUIT, Mancini is perfect for city. End of the fking story.


Mancini = Best manager of the world. We can win pl and el with Bobby.
Mancini = True City legend.
Mancini = Best manager City had in 50-60 years.

In king Roberto we trust.