Prestwich_Blue
Well-Known Member
Thought the referee was pretty decent tonight for a change. In fact I was thinking at the game "First time we get a decent ref and we manage to fuck it up ourselves."
schfc6 said:mad zab said:west didsblue said:Hart 5
Sagna 7 ( Zaba 7)
Clichy 8
Kompany 8
Mangala 6
Fernando 7
Navas 7
Lampard 7
Milner 6 (Jovetic 8)
Nasri 7
Aguero 11 (Demi ?)
Sagna was about a 5
Mangala 8 ( tell me a tackle he lost?)
Fernando 6
Milner 5
Nasri 5
Apart from that I agree with you
If you think Nasri was a 5 tonight, you're an idiot. I simply don't understand people like you. I agree on Milner & Mangala though.
onceabluealways said:schfc6 said:mad zab said:Sagna was about a 5
Mangala 8 ( tell me a tackle he lost?)
Fernando 6
Milner 5
Nasri 5
Apart from that I agree with you
If you think Nasri was a 5 tonight, you're an idiot. I simply don't understand people like you. I agree on Milner & Mangala though.
It depends on what you see nasri's roll as? When Silva isn't in the team lots of people expect him to step up what he actually does is bottle it. When we needed goals he was back on the half way line passing it with the CBs. He wasn't a 5 but he wasn't that much better.
My thoughts for what it's worth
Hart 4 didn't really do anything positive, arguably some fault for both goals
Sagna 6 Ok defensivly not nuch going forward
Komps 7 average game for him
Mangala 7 foul for their first but other than that thought he was very positive and calm when played some horrendous balls early on.
Clichy - 6 smilar to sagna
Navas 5.5 was put in some great positions but failed to deliver
fernando 5 as the ball winner - didn't really do it and made me nervous on occasion - doesn;t offer himself for the ball at all
Lampard 7.5 best of the midfield - always looking to be positive an nice to see a player who just doesn't want to pass 5 yards all the time
Nasri 6.5 nothing wrong nothing to great, expect more from a senior player
milner 6.5 usual effort but a game were his contribution was poor
Aguero 9 finishing brilliant, nearly a 10, was the difference between winning and losing
thought Jovetic was his sual self - very positive , not quite as many mistakes giving it away 7.5
others not enoughto score them.
Bayern are an excellent team, we have a lot of work to catch them - they looked organised , hard working and dangerous. We looked nervous , ponderous and looked to Aguero to much.