OB1
Well-Known Member
Q did give it a good review but spent years back tracking that opinion and are famous for asking the question: Are Tin Machine crap?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Classic Album Overrated/Underrated Discussion
- Thread starter SkyBlueTX
- Start date
Q did give it a good review but spent years back tracking that opinion and are famous for asking the question: Are Tin Machine crap?
Q did give it a good review but spent years back tracking that opinion and are famous for asking the question: Are Tin Machine crap?
Oh sure, absolutely. Opinions change over time. The Who's Quadrophenia got pretty mixed reviews at the time, but is now arguably thought of as their best album. My opinion of Tin Machine hasn't changed though ;-)
citizenyank76
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 16 Feb 2010
- Messages
- 2,336
Montrose is an awesome album.
I saw the Ronnie Montrose Band play a few months before he killed himself. It was one of the best shows I've seen in a small club. None of the original members of the Montrose where with him but everybody was on their feet chanting his name by the the end of the night. He was truly as good as an axeman as any of his contemporaries (Eddie Van Halen, Jimmy Page, Ritchie Blackmore) and he even pulled out some old nuggets from Gamma his project after Montrose. He was the sideman to Van Morrison, Herbie Hancock, Boz Scaggs and Edgar Winter.... the list goes on and on. I am glad that his old fans were able to make him feel good even if it was only for one more tour.
BobKowalski
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 May 2007
- Messages
- 20,062
As a concept album, DSOM is pretty much the benchmark.
Spot on.
OB1
Well-Known Member
Oh sure, absolutely. Opinions change over time. The Who's Quadrophenia got pretty mixed reviews at the time, but is now arguably thought of as their best album. My opinion of Tin Machine hasn't changed though ;-)
Opinions certainly can change over time as do tastes. Must admit I rate Quadrophenia more highly now than when I first bought it but I still rate Who's Next as their best and I reckon it would still get the majority vote. It's definitely the highest placed Who album on that list of 3000 although I think it should be higher than #35.
OB1
Well-Known Member
I saw the Ronnie Montrose Band play a few months before he killed himself. It was one of the best shows I've seen in a small club. None of the original members of the Montrose where with him but everybody was on their feet chanting his name by the the end of the night. He was truly as good as an axeman as any of his contemporaries (Eddie Van Halen, Jimmy Page, Ritchie Blackmore) and he even pulled out some old nuggets from Gamma his project after Montrose. He was the sideman to Van Morrison, Herbie Hancock, Boz Scaggs and Edgar Winter.... the list goes on and on. I am glad that his old fans were able to make him feel good even if it was only for one more tour.
I saw Gamma play the Free Trade Hall in Manchester.
SkyBlueTX
Well-Known Member
"Who's Next" is in my all time Top 10 for sure. An album full of strong songs from first to last. Like the cover, it pisses all over the competition.Opinions certainly can change over time as do tastes. Must admit I rate Quadrophenia more highly now than when I first bought it but I still rate Who's Next as their best and I reckon it would still get the majority vote. It's definitely the highest placed Who album on that list of 3000 although I think it should be higher than #35.
RACHACE
Well-Known Member
The new Noel Gallagher album isn't even in the list. WTF, that's criminal as it's easily better than any shit from say The Clash.
Opinions certainly can change over time as do tastes. Must admit I rate Quadrophenia more highly now than when I first bought it but I still rate Who's Next as their best and I reckon it would still get the majority vote. It's definitely the highest placed Who album on that list of 3000 although I think it should be higher than #35.
Yep, that's the obvious one. And of course the one that got away, partly because Lifehouse failed and partly because of the quality of the songs Glyn Johns inexplicably left off the final cut -the gorgeous Pure and Easy, Let's See Action, Join Together etc etc. Who's Next is a great album, but it could and should have been even better. And I think that slightly colours my view of an album I still love.
citizenyank76
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 16 Feb 2010
- Messages
- 2,336
I saw Gamma play the Free Trade Hall in Manchester.
I would have liked to have seen that show. That band had Davey Patterson who went on to sing with Robin Trower. I would have loved to have seen the Robin Trower Band when they had Reg Isadore and James Dewar. I still talk to old heshers who saw that act and say they were unbeatable live. Dewar was such an underrated lead singer.