Club Badge (merged)

[Fourinarow]

Actually, nobody voted on that shield shape as it wasn't in the questionnaire.

I'm sure when I did the questionnaire via the website there was a shield shape in there.

 

[Macker]

I am loathed to say it but I went over to the darkside of sad cafe to see if they are taking the piss and they are all praising it as stylish urrgh! anyway someone had mocked this up and I feel dirty even posting something fruom there but

Defo looks more balanced with football club but I still don't like it

 

[CitizenTID]

I'm sure when I did the questionnaire via the website there was a shield shape in there.

It was the old shield vs. the current Eagle one which has straighter sides. There was also the option of the CoA red shield

 

[IanBishopsHaircut]

I am loathed to say it but I went over to the darkside of sad cafe to see if they are taking the piss and they are all praising it as stylish urrgh! anyway someone had mocked this up and I feel dirty even posting something fruom there but

Was just about to post that

If our biggest critics are on the whole positive about the badge it can't be that shit..they would use any excuse

http://www.redcafe.net/threads/manchester-citys-new-badge-leaked.412868/

 

[CitizenTID]

Was just about to post that

If our biggest critics are on the whole positive about the badge it can't be that shit..they would use any excuse

http://www.redcafe.net/threads/manchester-citys-new-badge-leaked.412868/

The comment that it looks like a logo on a shit beer seems about right however I do like it for our badge.

 

[cleavers]

Seems like people wanted three rounds of voting or something which wouldve been ridiculous.

Some would have wanted 30 rounds of voting, and would still moan.

I'm not 100% happy with it, but its better than the current badge, and its not a Swales badge thank f*ck, its OK, it could have been better, it could have been worse, some of gavs were better.

I've no idea why the red rose gets so much opposition, the rivers and ship are great, nearly everyone wanted a round badge, and a shield, 1894 seemed popular. I wanted to keep "Football Club", and I think the shield should be within the circle. It looks far better on our kits background than a white one, and the mono coloured one looks great.

Perfect its not, but its better than what we have, and it relates to our past badges, and our Manchester heritage (which was part of Lancashire until the government intervened, and in cricket, Lancashire's home is still in Manchester (well Trafford)).

 

[Phil1]

Even though I'm not that arsed, it does look better with the football club added.

 

[CitizenTID]

Defo looks more balanced with football club but I still don't like it

Actually I'm not sure, they've just gone for City as everyone globally associates us as 'City' so it stands out more and is more identifiable.

 

[PragueBlue]

Even though I'm not that arsed, it does look better with the football club added.

I prefer it without to be honest. I must admit it's growing on me the more I see it.

 

[Keepingthefaithsince1976]

See it looks miles better and more even with football club

Nope. Too busy for me.