Criticism of Pep

[Coatigan]

Of course they can. It all depends on the weight you attach to the various comps.

FA and League Cups are great to win but both competitions have been degraded. They are where everyone plays their reserves.

PL and League titles are the biggies. And PL trumps the League in the outside world. We have barely registered in Europe. As for the League itself, Klopper will probably set a new all-time points record. Hell, they might even have an invincible season, although I doubt it.

Then you also need to take into account relative spends. Not a popular view on here but it’s a factor.

So yes, it is possible.

Have i stumbled into a liverpool forum?

literally impossible for klopp to surpass pep's achievement this season.

And liverpool have spent as much as city, some seasons less, some seasons more. overall there's a squad filler'a worth if a difference. See if you even mention bloody coutinho money im aff!

 

[Coatigan]

It’s not bullshit it’s my opinion.l get you don’t like my point of view but he did fuck up that day just as he did against Spurs last season. He is the best manager we’ve ever had but he is not above criticism. You have your view I have mine. I also have not parroted anybodies opinion, as that team came out that night I texted my mate to say that the team was weird and I felt we would get beat, he didn’t need to show how clever he was, we already knew what a great coach was.

He is not above criticism, absolutely.

He is however above being compared to klopp as an inferior manager, above being called a fraud, and above being wanted rid of. 100% above all three.

 

[eastmanc]

Go on then.

Actually explain how Pep playing Gubdogan made us lose that match.

Put some substance behind your opinion, as I did when I pointed out how it didnt effect the game at all.

How many times had Gundogan actually played in that position before that game, it was totally unnecessary as he had De Bruyne in the side who could have played out wide on the right. Pep obviously thought it was wrong because he has never played him there again. As for the substance we got hammered 3-0.

 

[kaz7]

Hope he's not watching Barca now as the ground is empty!

He won't say anything about his beloved barca fans

 

[eastmanc]

He is not above criticism, absolutely.

He is however above being compared to klopp as an inferior manager, above being called a fraud, and above being wanted rid of. 100% above all three.

You are bang on right, there is a lot of rubbish spoken about Pep, especially in the press.

 

[Coatigan]

Depends what value you put on them. Please see my response to blueparrot below.

Aye, if you value klopp's one league title as two, like most liverpool fans and media do and if you value his zero cup tophies as 6, then yes, it is possible, just like its possible to pay for 400m's worth of players with 110m coutinho money. The old liverpool value measure converter..

 

[blueinsa]

Klopp surpasses Pep when he wins the league this season?

Nearly chocked on my dinner pmsl.

 

[Coatigan]

He won't say anything about his beloved barca fans

Why would he? he's the manager of City, not barca.

if he did say anything, the headlines and comments would condemn him for caring for them and not us, flirting or lining up a return.

 

[kaz7]

Why would he? he's the manager of City, not barca.

if he did say anything, the headlines and comments would condemn him for caring for them and not us, flirting or lining up a return.

Did he used to complain when the Nou camp was half full for anything other than the glamour games is what i mean

 

[Coatigan]

Did he used to complain when the Nou camp was half full for anything other than the glamour games is what i mean

i see. fair enough.

i genuinely don't know. didn't follow his pressers then, apart from the odd chamions league ones. was more interested in what Mancini had to say at the time.