jay_mcfc said:
What a sad thread. We have 3 of the worlds top strikers who are banging them in for fun and breaking records galore yet City fans continue to have to slate one of them at a time. Dzeko is awesome around the box. I don't think I've seen any footballer be able to use both feet the way he does. He's tricky, good in the air, can shoot with power and accuracy with both feet and he is also capable of creating goals. He can work the channels, he can be a target man and he is also works hard and is a good defender for us at set-pieces. On top of this he's a top guy who loves it here.
The trouble is that there seem to be an especially vocal (in the posting sense) contingent of Dzeko-worshippers on this forum, who are constantly bigging him up - often at the expense of other City players. This is bound to annoy those who think that Dzeko is not the greatest footballing genius in the City team -let alone the EPL, Europe, or the world.
On the other hand, there is the usual contingent of those who for some reason take against certain player(s) and take slightest excuse to criticise the player(s) they particularly dislike. But Edin is certainly not alone in suffering from this. I suspect that every City player has a number of dislikers/haters! There are certainly those on this forum who are just waiting for Silva to have a really poor game - which he's bound to have from time to time, even Messi isn't always effective - to denigrate him as "lightweight", "doesn't turn up in big games" etc.etc.etc.
These denigrators/haters often reveal more about themselves than about the players they take against. The best response is to reply in as polite and rational way as possible if it seems necessary to do so. The worst way is to make exaggerated and unreasonable claims about the players criticised.
[Incidentally, showing Youtube clips about a player doing one or two apparently remarkable things is not a reasonable response - unless the clip is really representative of the standard of play the player manages in many games. I used to play football, rugby, and cricket at a very low level. I scored goals, including one quite spectacular one, tries, and took wickets. They were flukes, not that I didn't intend them, but that it wouldn't have much difference whether or not I did, so low was my level of ability :-)]
Of course support for clubs, teams, and players, is not just a matter of "reason". If it is true that the Dzeko-worshippers on this forum are mostly Bosnians, then their attitude is understandable, and almost excusable, given the tragic recent history of Bosnia. But I suspect that some of the Dzekolators are not Bosnians, but are those who for some reason find Edin a more appealing figure than Mario, Kun etc.
Whatever the reason, there are some on this forum whose primary loyalty as fans seems to be for Dzeko, rather than for City. This doesn't seem to apply to the same extent for other City players.