Goodbye Mario? (merged)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Goodbye Mario?

nijinsky's fetlocks said:
andyhinch said:
Just driven pasted his house, the black bin was out and some lights were on inside

The lights may be on,but there's nobody home mate.
I have some flowers and a thank you card if you could drop them off when you pass next.
I'm missing him already.
I haven't felt this distraught since Stan Ogden passed away.
That is a very good description of Mario lol.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

Churchill123 said:
what's the latest on this- is he actually going, or what.. keeping reading he's going but not sure if it's based on any facts at all?


No facts mate



Papers claim he had goodbye party last night but he was in training today and Platt claims he will be in team tomorrow
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

Disappointed to have got through 17 pages and he's still here.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

sergiokun said:
Churchill123 said:
what's the latest on this- is he actually going, or what.. keeping reading he's going but not sure if it's based on any facts at all?


No facts mate



Papers claim he had goodbye party last night but he was in training today and Platt claims he will be in team tomorrow

So we either believe some tabloid hack,or our first team coach.
Ooh - it's a tough one...
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

Prestwich_Blue said:
bluenova said:
Prestwich_Blue said:
For a family as financially illiterate as yours it would be a (very lucrative) pleasure. ;-)

We paid £18m (€22m) on a 5 year contract for him 2.5 years ago. We amortise (write off to the P&L account) 18/5 (£3.6m) every year meaning we've written off £9m to date. This makes his net book value £9m. We calculate the profit on the sale price less net book value so if we get €24m (£20.5m) the profit we show, regardless of how Milan finance it, is £11.5m.

Don't like to be cheeky to a fellow Prestwich blue, but does it really make it a better deal because of the "accounting profits"? We still spent that money, even if it's been written off.

Given the up/down career he has had so far, getting more money than we paid for him is probably a good deal - but if you're paying £18m for a teenager then you're hoping he's going to be worth a lot more than that when you sell him. We could sell him for £10m and still make an 'accounting profit' - but it would be a travesty for a player who was one of the stars of the Euros last summer.
It's a fair question but the cash in or out is largely irrelevant and to get back what we paid for someone who really hasn't delivered on his promise is not bad. Plus there's a business decision to be made on a number of counts.

1) From a paying point of view we know what he CAN do but are we ever going to see him do it consistently?

2) Will he appreciate in value significantly? You could take a chance pre-Bosman but can't anymore. It's a bit like Deal Or No Deal but now the odds are in the player's favour.

3) We'd be looking at offering him a new contract or getting rid this summer as his value will start going down unless he delivers on the field (See 1)

4) FFP. We might need that profit to meet it.

5) We almost certainly need to sell before we buy. If we've got someone more reliable lined up it makes sense

I understand all that - and agree with each of your points which is why getting back our money is probably a good deal (although I suspect we'll replace him someone who costs more FFPwise).

I'm just suggesting that the £11m accounting profit isn't real. If we sold all our players half way through their contracts for what we paid for them we'd have a huge accounting profit, but in reality we'd have the same amount of money we started with :)
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

My personal opinion is I would be glad to see him go... We play better as a team without him (team performances this season back that up). He's made 2 appearances for the 1st team this season (According to Sky Sports).

It's clear he is a talent with huge potential... The problem is he doesn't want to play for MCFC. So it will be of Milan's benefit if he does go there as that is where he wants to be (In my opinion of course).

With him likely to depart, I wonder whether that means we are bringing a striker in. As that leaves us with 3 and if one gets injured/suspended/loss of form, then we could be in trouble.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

More news ladies



Is this a sign Mario is leaving City? Kidd asks Balotelli for an autograph as Italian side renew efforts to buy striker


<a class="postlink" href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2269531/Mario-Balotelli-close-AC-Milan-Italian-club-step-efforts-prise-Manchester-City-striker.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... riker.html</a>
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

nijinsky's fetlocks said:
andyhinch said:
Just driven pasted his house, the black bin was out and some lights were on inside

The lights may be on,but there's nobody home mate.
I have some flowers and a thank you card if you could drop them off when you pass next.
I'm missing him already.
I haven't felt this distraught since Stan Ogden passed away.
My thoughts to tbh, should I leave a reath ?
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

The term 'shirt sales' should be viewed in a metaphorical, not literal sense.

The battle to elevate this club has had to have been fought on a number of fronts. Some people seem to forget how much this club has struggled for column inches down the years, even after the takeover to some extent. In spite of being the 'richest club in the world' we were never taken seriously.

That has all changed in the last two years. Manchester City Football Club is now one of the most talked about sporting entities on the planet. Is this down to one FA Cup and one Premier League title? To suggest so displays a complete failure to understand how the modern, digital world operates.

We have become a big story, not in spite of the egos but because of them and Mario has been the biggest ego and the biggest story of them all. He has helped accelerate our global presence and consequently our status within the game.

The struggle to make this club stand shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, itself a notion that would have been met with derision only a short time ago, has to be fought beyond the playing arena, for better or worse.

Mario's contribution on the pitch has been fitful at best but in his own way he has helped as much as any other player in making Sheikh Mansour's vision for Manchester City a reality.

He has helped make City truly 'Massive'.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

BlueHalli said:
Brendan110_0 said:
Can't see him leaving, Platt says he staying, Mancini says he's staying. Do we have another 22 year old who's happy to play 4th choice lined up? Nope, doesn't make sense to let a player go so late with no replacement, Aguero has had problems this season, Tevez could get 'taken out' Whelan style then we'd be donald ducked.
I don't know another 22 year old with the potential he has, for me we'd be letting him go at the wrong time, wait another season.


The reason he doesn't mind being fourth choice is because he doesn't give a fook .


source or it didnt happen?
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

gordondaviesmoustache said:
The term 'shirt sales' should be viewed in a metaphorical, not literal sense.

The battle to elevate this club has had to have been fought on a number of fronts. Some people seem to forget how much this club has struggled for column inches down the years, even after the takeover to some extent. In spite of being the 'richest club in the world' we were never taken seriously.

That has all changed in the last two years. Manchester City Football Club is now one of the most talked about sporting entities on the planet. Is this down to one FA Cup and one Premier League title? To suggest so displays a complete failure to understand how the modern, digital world operates.

We have become a big story, not in spite of the egos but because of them and Mario has been the biggest ego and the biggest story of them all. He has helped accelerate our global presence and consequently our status within the game.

The struggle to make this club stand shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, itself a notion that would have been met with derision only a short time ago, has to be fought beyond the playing arena, for better or worse.

Mario's contribution on the pitch has been fitful at best but in his own way he has helped as much as any other player in making Sheikh Mansour's vision for Manchester City a reality.

He has helped make City truly 'Massive'.

Agreed
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

bluenova said:
I understand all that - and agree with each of your points which is why getting back our money is probably a good deal (although I suspect we'll replace him someone who costs more FFPwise).

I'm just suggesting that the £11m accounting profit isn't real. If we sold all our players half way through their contracts for what we paid for them we'd have a huge accounting profit, but in reality we'd have the same amount of money we started with :)
If your player sees out the contract, and leaves on a Bosman, they're worth nothing, so it is real. Because of that there is a reason to assume zero value at the end of the contract and therefore the idea that a player depreciates in value is correct. Most assets you buy depreciate. It's not some whimsical notion that only exists in football.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

dave_blue12 said:
gordondaviesmoustache said:
The term 'shirt sales' should be viewed in a metaphorical, not literal sense.

The battle to elevate this club has had to have been fought on a number of fronts. Some people seem to forget how much this club has struggled for column inches down the years, even after the takeover to some extent. In spite of being the 'richest club in the world' we were never taken seriously.

That has all changed in the last two years. Manchester City Football Club is now one of the most talked about sporting entities on the planet. Is this down to one FA Cup and one Premier League title? To suggest so displays a complete failure to understand how the modern, digital world operates.

We have become a big story, not in spite of the egos but because of them and Mario has been the biggest ego and the biggest story of them all. He has helped accelerate our global presence and consequently our status within the game.

The struggle to make this club stand shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, itself a notion that would have been met with derision only a short time ago, has to be fought beyond the playing arena, for better or worse.

Mario's contribution on the pitch has been fitful at best but in his own way he has helped as much as any other player in making Sheikh Mansour's vision for Manchester City a reality.
He has helped make City truly 'Massive'.

Agreed

Check out the training session on citytv and what does the canadian kid tell mario? "Your the best player in canada"
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

edtheblue said:
Latest odds 1/12 to be a Milan player by end of transfer window,
And why do bookies all drive limos?

He's a 4/6 shot to go at best.

Is there an odds against to stay option?
If so,'ave it !
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

I've not been through all 18 pages so apologies if it's been mentioned but it occurred to me this morning before the new reports coming out that it's gone very quite on the John Guidetti front. I'm thinking he's going nowhere as he's now our 4th striker replacing Mario.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

gordondaviesmoustache said:
The term 'shirt sales' should be viewed in a metaphorical, not literal sense.

The battle to elevate this club has had to have been fought on a number of fronts. Some people seem to forget how much this club has struggled for column inches down the years, even after the takeover to some extent. In spite of being the 'richest club in the world' we were never taken seriously.

That has all changed in the last two years. Manchester City Football Club is now one of the most talked about sporting entities on the planet. Is this down to one FA Cup and one Premier League title? To suggest so displays a complete failure to understand how the modern, digital world operates.

We have become a big story, not in spite of the egos but because of them and Mario has been the biggest ego and the biggest story of them all. He has helped accelerate our global presence and consequently our status within the game.

The struggle to make this club stand shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, itself a notion that would have been met with derision only a short time ago, has to be fought beyond the playing arena, for better or worse.

Mario's contribution on the pitch has been fitful at best but in his own way he has helped as much as any other player in making Sheikh Mansour's vision for Manchester City a reality.

He has helped make City truly 'Massive'.
For me we're a fair way off being truly massive and we're not quite standing shoulder to shoulder with Madrid and Barça. At the moment we're just getting ahead of the levels Wolfsberg and Deportivo did when they were winning titles in their respective leagues. We're catching up all the time but stadium, stadium size, attendances, sustained challenging for honours, sustained success, youth development, revenue generated and to a lesser extent media interest(because we have become quite big in this area)... aren't massive club status yet.

As for Mario, City have said he's going nowhere this month but sometimes clubs say one thing and the opposite happens. But overall with Mario I'm fucking pissed off with him. I've never subscribed to the hugely overinflated hype that has followed him in his career so far; he has some talent but he's not world class and may never will be, but I do think he's a fairly good player with some great attributes and to be honest his application of putting those attributes to use on a regular basis have been unacceptable. He's never played well in two consecutive games for us, in fact his Good to Average to Shit ratio is probably something like GSSAAAASSGAGAAAAAASSGAAAAGSSAASG (you get my point :)!). Forget his childhood, forget the racist chants in Italy, how other players treat him (they've never been particularly bad with him anyway) or how refs treat him (another exaggeration) - forget all that - his actual application of himself to his own game and the team's game has not been good enough consistently. That's why he will leave (if he does).

As I say he's not a top class player and may never will be but he could have been a good player and I'm unhappy with him that he's not going to be that with us. I like him, I like what he's good at, I can ignore some of the bullshit that comes with him, but he's just not put himself into his job and hasn't taken his job professionally or seriously enough in his time here. If he has and that was actually him at his most professional serious, then the lad will struggle to even be a good player in his career.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

ColinLee said:
I've not been through all 18 pages so apologies if it's been mentioned but it occurred to me this morning before the new reports coming out that it's gone very quite on the John Guidetti front. I'm thinking he's going nowhere as he's now our 4th striker replacing Mario.

Or, as stated by Mancini a few days ago he's not ready for senior football just yet.
 
Re: Goodbye Mario?

dave_blue12 said:
gordondaviesmoustache said:
The term 'shirt sales' should be viewed in a metaphorical, not literal sense.

The battle to elevate this club has had to have been fought on a number of fronts. Some people seem to forget how much this club has struggled for column inches down the years, even after the takeover to some extent. In spite of being the 'richest club in the world' we were never taken seriously.

That has all changed in the last two years. Manchester City Football Club is now one of the most talked about sporting entities on the planet. Is this down to one FA Cup and one Premier League title? To suggest so displays a complete failure to understand how the modern, digital world operates.

We have become a big story, not in spite of the egos but because of them and Mario has been the biggest ego and the biggest story of them all. He has helped accelerate our global presence and consequently our status within the game.

The struggle to make this club stand shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, itself a notion that would have been met with derision only a short time ago, has to be fought beyond the playing arena, for better or worse.

Mario's contribution on the pitch has been fitful at best but in his own way he has helped as much as any other player in making Sheikh Mansour's vision for Manchester City a reality.

He has helped make City truly 'Massive'.

Agreed

top post GGV.<br /><br />-- Mon Jan 28, 2013 6:23 pm --<br /><br />
TGR said:
The sooner he is gone the better for all concerned.

Bollox.

Has he gone yet OP? will you be really dissapointed if he stays with us and helps us win the league, again
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top