Not always, but that is not at all what the discussion was about.
People are arguing he was dogshit last year, and that McAtee is better. Both of those are obviously absurd.
Does McAtee start in the first 11 when everyone is fit? Heck does he start ahead of Alvarez if he were still here? No chance. That doesn't mean he has no role.
I'm happy with the move and the fee we got, and happy with whatever way Pep goes forward. People are going way too far with their exaggeration though, and that is all I am pointing out.