You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
James Milner
- Thread starter Jumanji
- Start date
Train said:
It's a shame so few compliations of Milners skills actually exist, he really does go unnoticed.
As an aside, I reckon he's my favorite city player.
bornblueegg
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 3 Sep 2008
- Messages
- 8,167
Hard working, great player
Decent role player. Hardworking and Professional. But when it comes to City's best or favorite. I'd have to rank him below Joe Hart, Vincent Kompany, Pablo Zab, Yaya Toure, David SIlva, and Kun Aguero.
He ranks for me in the middle with the likes of Gael Clichy, Nasty and Barry. Above the old Dzeko (hopefully not the new one), an Injury prone Micah (hopefully injury free this year), a timid Rodwell, a soft Garcia, an inconsistent Nasri, a footskill-less Lescott, and a poor Kolarov.
I
He ranks for me in the middle with the likes of Gael Clichy, Nasty and Barry. Above the old Dzeko (hopefully not the new one), an Injury prone Micah (hopefully injury free this year), a timid Rodwell, a soft Garcia, an inconsistent Nasri, a footskill-less Lescott, and a poor Kolarov.
I
hallstreetblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 707
Train said:andrewmswift said:mate could you start a thread of all your compilations? would love to have them in one place
Sure. It sounds good. It would save people time from having to sift back through threads etc. I will re-post the Milner compilation in the new thread soon along with others.
Train, remember not long ago, we had a little discussion re my mate Jimmy? Well, you didn't exactly back me up when I was singing his praises. Now you post this like you're a born again. Not slaggin you, just as you never slagged Jimmy, but you also never praised him when you had the chance. Bayern Midfielders page 2
hallstreetblue said:Train said:andrewmswift said:mate could you start a thread of all your compilations? would love to have them in one place
Sure. It sounds good. It would save people time from having to sift back through threads etc. I will re-post the Milner compilation in the new thread soon along with others.
Train, remember not long ago, we had a little discussion re my mate Jimmy? Well, you didn't exactly back me up when I was singing his praises. Now you post this like you're a born again. Not slaggin you, just as you never slagged Jimmy, but you also never praised him when you had the chance. Bayern Midfielders page 2
I remember our conversation. I didn't have your back then because you were comparing him to Thomas Muller whom i think you were vastly underrating at the time. But just because i was backing Muller against Milner doesn't mean i don't rate Milner. On the contrary, I respect Milner as a player and also as a person for a lot of the the same reasons as others do too. I simply don't feel the need to voice my opinion about him, because most of its well documented by others who sing his praise.
D
D
Deleted member 52846
Guest
My second behind Kun!samharris said:Jimmy is my favourite City player..
pinkwheeltrim
Well-Known Member
daxman said:Decent role player.
I
He was the finest Dungeons and Dragons player the West Riding has ever seen!
hallstreetblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 707
Train said:hallstreetblue said:Train said:Sure. It sounds good. It would save people time from having to sift back through threads etc. I will re-post the Milner compilation in the new thread soon along with others.
Train, remember not long ago, we had a little discussion re my mate Jimmy? Well, you didn't exactly back me up when I was singing his praises. Now you post this like you're a born again. Not slaggin you, just as you never slagged Jimmy, but you also never praised him when you had the chance. Bayern Midfielders page 2
I remember our conversation. I didn't have your back then because you were comparing him to Thomas Muller whom i think you were vastly underrating at the time. But just because i was backing Muller against Milner doesn't mean i don't rate Milner. On the contrary, I respect Milner as a player and also as a person for a lot of the the same reasons as others do too. I simply don't feel the need to voice my opinion about him, because most of its well documented by others who sing his praise.
Fair one. But I wasn't underating Thomas Müller, I was comparing him to James Milner, a player I rate very highly. That's where people misunderstood me; me calling Müller a grafter, doesn't mean he's a bad player, it means he runs his arse off for the badge, as does Milner.
Rammyblues
Well-Known Member
If he and Barry play against the rags we win.