andrewmswift
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 6,957
caballero. not even a question. hart is midtable for the last two years
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Joe Hart or Willy Caballero
- Thread starter Zizi4City
- Start date
Bluewonder
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 24 Jun 2013
- Messages
- 3,333
You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
D
D
Deleted member 58678
Guest
A very slight compliant about the Wilshire goal was that he didn't stay tall for long enough. He dropped to the floor and opened up the top to the bet for Wilshire to score in.
But that's being very critical.
He was fine today.
But that's being very critical.
He was fine today.
johnmc
Well-Known Member
Bluewonder said:You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
I agree. Today he did nothing wrong apart really. One mistake on a cross but nothing came of it.
Braggster
Well-Known Member
Not really. Would've been a big ask for him to make the save from Sanchez but sitting down in front of Wilshere was poor, he made Wilshere's decision for him which is a big no no, especially when faced with a player who has the technique to execute the chip (which Wilshere does).Bluewonder said:You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
Fact is that we spent £6m on Caballero for a reason, and that is that the management don't trust Hart.
Braggster said:Not really. Would've been a big ask for him to make the save from Sanchez but sitting down in front of Wilshere was poor, he made Wilshere's decision for him which is a big no no, especially when faced with a player who has the technique to execute the chip (which Wilshere does).Bluewonder said:You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
Fact is that we spent £6m on Caballero for a reason, and that is that the management don't trust Hart.
Yet trusted him to play every game so far this season? You do talk some bollocks.
City Glory While Others Fade
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 May 2014
- Messages
- 515
Bluewonder said:You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
Point well argued.
Gaylord du Bois
Well-Known Member
Joe did as much as could be expected today and kept us in the game first half.
Braggster
Well-Known Member
Alright mate, no need for the abuse. If you disagree why not just explain why?RandomJ said:Braggster said:Not really. Would've been a big ask for him to make the save from Sanchez but sitting down in front of Wilshere was poor, he made Wilshere's decision for him which is a big no no, especially when faced with a player who has the technique to execute the chip (which Wilshere does).Bluewonder said:You'd have to be an idiot to blame Hart for those goals. A serious idiot.
Fact is that we spent £6m on Caballero for a reason, and that is that the management don't trust Hart.
Yet trusted him to play every game so far this season? You do talk some bollocks.
I think it is fairly clear that he isn't trusted, because Caballero is in the wings and will get his chance shortly - Pellers has said as much. In fact far from being trusted, Hart is on probation.
Don't you think it was telling that Pellegrini refused to confirm that Hart was his number one when asked after the game? If it were true then this would be an easy give for him, he could just say "yes of course". Instead he refused to talk about it. It seems clear therefore that Hart is not trusted.
To those who say it is harsh to blame him for the first goal, yes it is, but he didn't do what a top keeper should do. At our level we cannot afford that.