No, your point was he has not shown any signs of improvement under Pep, I did say this in an earlier post.
I also said that was why I replied as it was utter crap, he did improve as in the 100point season he was fucking imperious at the back and I also said he is out of form.
A whole 8 years support, ah well, I best put myself back in my box and bow down to your superiority and knowledge.
As for the criticising players bit, did you not read what I put in the previous post, I take it you didn't as you replied yet again lol
Folk's come on and say fuck me he was shit and leave the thread, then there are others that will argue black is white with any other City fan that disagrees with their assessment of the player, I always wonder what you/others get out of it, some of the player threads are full of this shit, VK's some folk had him finished and he was a liability and was just embarrassing himself, Zabba's the very same, like I said a guy argued for weeks that David Silva was overrated and was actually shit, at this point I feel like screaming "you have said your piece now shut your fucking mouth and move on" but I am always far too polite to be that rude.