Keir Starmer

Just finished reading a book about a post war murder. Two things are perhaps relevant to this thread. You are quite correct Attlees government did not abolish capital punishment because most Labour voters were in favour of it. This accords with what you said earlier that there is a strong streak of social conservatism running through working class Labour support.
Secondly the author of the book a child of the late 40s was grateful to the socialist policies of Attlee's government. Free school fees, fares, textbooks, public library card, spectacles, braces on her teeth, concentrated orange juice and cod liver oil.
My comment to you was tongue in cheek, and I didn't intend to patronise.

Attlee and Bevan both voted to uphold it after they were voted out too. Tony Benn had many small c conservative views and the Blue Labour movement is still considerable.

Okay fair enough, it’s hard sometimes to understand context when communicating with the written word.
 
Attlee and Bevan both voted to uphold it after they were voted out too. Tony Benn had many small c conservative views and the Blue Labour movement is still considerable.

Okay fair enough, it’s hard sometimes to understand context when communicating with the written word.
The guys you mention were brought up in a different era. I suspect though that there were probably wealthy Tories who had more liberal social mores shall we say.
 
Last edited:
The guys you mention were brought up in a different era. I suspect though that were probably wealthy Tories who had more liberal social mores shall we say.

They were but conservatism is built upon on tradition. Not that some things need to move on but the majority, specifically the good aspects to society, are expected to stay the same under this ideology.
 
It would appear that Rebecca Long Bailey, the Continuity Marxist candidate, has shot herself in the foot by saying she's not keen on having different limits for regular or disability linked abortions. Quite right of course but why even mention it?
They need to bring the limit down to 16 weeks unless rape and serious disability applies,the pussy footing around the limit helps no-one,babies are now living at 22/23 weeks,it's a scandal you can have an abortion up to 24 weeks
 
They were but conservatism is built upon on tradition. Not that some things need to move on but the majority, specifically the good aspects to society, are expected to stay the same under this ideology.
I edited my post it read a bit like I said Attlee, Benn were wealthy Tories, which obviously was not the case.
I was highlighting perhaps that while there are social conservatives within the Labour movement there are also social progressives on the Conservative side.
As to your last point it is the debate between Edmund Burke and Thomas Paine.
 
It would appear that Rebecca Long Bailey, the Continuity Marxist candidate, has shot herself in the foot by saying she's not keen on having different limits for regular or disability linked abortions. Quite right of course but why even mention it?
She didn't just mention it

But in response to a questionnaire compiled during the election by her local Catholic Church diocese, which was unearthed on Thursday, Ms Long-Bailey said that she did “not agree with this position”.

In her response to local Catholic priests late last year, she said: "It is currently legal to terminate a pregnancy up to full-term on the grounds of disability while the upper limit is 24 weeks if there is no disability.

"I personally do not agree with this position and agree with the words of the Disability Rights Commission that 'the context in which parents choose whether to have a child should be one in which disability and non-disability are valued equally'."

Hitting back on Thursday, Ms Long-Bailey’s spokesman suggested a rival leadership team had unearthed the comments, published on the pro-Labour website The Red Roar, in order to wreck her bid.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politic...ys-labour-leadership-bid-risk-derailing-amid/
 
I edited my post it read a bit like I said Attlee, Benn were wealthy Tories, which obviously was not the case.
I was highlighting perhaps that while there are social conservatives within the Labour movement there are also social progressives on the Conservative side.
As to your last point it is the debate between Edmund Burke and Thomas Paine.

Well it’s pretty safe to say you know what you’re talking about, I don’t disagree with a word of that.
 
I'm totally underwhelmed by all the candidates. With perhaps a particular mention to that Nandy woman, who for me represents the very small-town, narrow-minded attitudes that a proper Labour Party should avoid like the plague.

Starmer is probably the best of a bad bunch, but that isn't saying much. There is a very good chance that I will be defecting to the Lib Dems in future elections as I don't like the look of the stall Labour seems to be setting out.
 
I'm totally underwhelmed by all the candidates. With perhaps a particular mention to that Nandy woman, who for me represents the very small-town, narrow-minded attitudes that a proper Labour Party should avoid like the plague.

Starmer is probably the best of a bad bunch, but that isn't saying much. There is a very good chance that I will be defecting to the Lib Dems in future elections as I don't like the look of the stall Labour seems to be setting out.
Who's the LibDem leader? (No googling.)
 
If Labour choose another Marxist there will be a new party formed with center right Labour MP's and Center left Tories ..... people similar to Blair, Brown, Heseltine, Major, Ken Clarke ....MP's with similar ideas to those

It’s called the Liberal Democrats and they were roundly rejected at the GE.
 
Daniel Susskind (me neither) made a good point on PoliticsLive. Leadership contest seems quite policy focused, and no one is framing it as who can beat Boris, which is worrying if you actually want to see a change of government next time around.
 
Looks like Jess Phillips will be withdrawing later today.

Yep. Shame, I liked her. Think the left of the party hate her tho, so her dropping out is a worrying sign. Steeling myself to accept its going to be Long Bailey. At which point I'm gonna have to become a Green voter.
 
Yep. Shame, I liked her. Think the left of the party hate her tho, so her dropping out is a worrying sign. Steeling myself to accept its going to be Long Bailey. At which point I'm gonna have to become a Green voter.

I would not read anything into this. It's a two horse race, the others dropping is a formality.
 
Yep. Shame, I liked her. Think the left of the party hate her tho, so her dropping out is a worrying sign. Steeling myself to accept its going to be Long Bailey. At which point I'm gonna have to become a Green voter.

She’s even further away from being Prime Ministerial than Corbyn, Jess Phillips.

Her rants in parliament showed that whilst passionate, she couldn’t keep her emotions in check and she was that close to tears, what she was saying stopped making sense.

You cannot have someone like that running the country. Nandy is the best option because at least she said she’d listen to the communities they have left and has seemingly done so already. She’s also very good at answering questions by tough interviewers like A. Neil.

Still, she said her Labour Party would continue to support FOM, which is mental considering she has supposedly listened to the communities that dropped Labour.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top