Mancini

Status
Not open for further replies.
Solihull Samba Boys said:
I like Mancini but my faith in him is beginning to wane. The majority of fans can see that we don't have the personnel to play 3-5-2 or any variation of it, that we are one-dimensional and don't move the ball quick enough.

Why should your faith be on the wane ?? catching the scum was a monumental task and most of this forum have already written off any chance of winning it this year.


Through all of our shortcomings we are still second(and will remain so) in the table with a chance of an FA cup.

And this was the expectation from most before the game today, nowt has really changed except we lost away at Everton and Mancinis tactics were wrong..

what manager gets them right week in week out without fail ?? Not one.
 
Sabster said:
sniff said:
Sabster said:
What plan B do Barca or Madrid have???

We should not be aspiring to play caveman football with wingers as soo many want.

The same caveman football like MADRID... with those two handy and fast fellas on the wing.. erm DiMaria and Ronaldo.. that caveman football seems to be doing the trick for them... seems to be doing the likes of Bayen and Dortmund quite well too...

To be honest I would prefer to spire to be like Barca than like those teams......

The fact is counter attacking teams cannot beat teams that sit back and are organised most of the time..

thats rubbish mate... the teams ive just name checked will all tear you open with sheer pace and accurate passing.. we dont really play counter attacking football anymore.

Players like silva are brilliant, but never fast.. thats why we look so lifeless up front without Aguero.
 
BillyShears said:
It's not either or though Sabster. Top teams need to have the capacity to play both ways which the likes of Madrid Barca do.

Do you watch Spanish football???

Neither Madrid or Barca have a plab B...

Madrid get complete shut out by teams who don't come at them and Barca play one way...

This idea that they have plan Bs is a complete rubbish
 
Marvin said:
Dortmund were 20 points behind last time I looked - seems there's a whole host of people ready to take cheap pot shots at our manager
Real Madrid 19 points behind!

AND both of these teams have PACE....WIDTH....QUICK PASSING....MOVEMENT....CROSSING....COUNTER ATTACKING.....

Why people think either Klopp or Mourinho would be able to do better than Mancini is bizarre. Both would want a shed load of money because they have different styles of play and would want different players!

That would be severely limited because of FFP.

What would be interesting is to see either of these two join City and spend say 50m which is the Balo, Dzeko + few others money.

Let's see how good they are then.
 
TFC said:
Things are never as cut and dried as they look. Trying to take nothing away from the accomplishment cos it was one of the greatest days of my life, but 'won us the title' or had it handed to him by the biggest choke job in Prem history only to very nearly balls it up at home to relegation candidates?

Oh, now you've gone and told it like it is. Can't do that. Or to mention the fact that we beat Stoke to win the cup.

<Sarcasm> Not at all on par with Mancini's having to face the weakest Serie A in history when he won those titles, and thus the credentials to come manage City. </Sarcasm>

He's a good Manager. But he's not world class, nor is he the man to take us into the future. Keeping him for another year and undergo complete squad shakeup in the summer, only to finally realize that he'll never do well in the CL and struggle to win the Premier League again? I think that would be the most disastrous thing to happen to us since Alan Ball.
 
samharris said:
we lost away at Everton and Mancinis tactics were wrong..

what manager gets them right week in week out without fail ?? Not one.

While Mancini has been in charge,how many times have we played Everton now? and how many times have they embarrassed us with the same approach?
 
Winning the Premier League was an enormous achievement for City and Mancini and it's shocking to see how quickly it's all forgotten and dismissed
 
Sabster said:
BillyShears said:
It's not either or though Sabster. Top teams need to have the capacity to play both ways which the likes of Madrid Barca do.

Do you watch Spanish football???

Neither Madrid or Barca have a plab B...

Madrid get complete shut out by teams who don't come at them and Barca play one way...

This idea that they have plan Bs is a complete rubbish

Yes I do watch Spanish football mate. I was talking about counter attacking and possession football. Top teams can play both ways but seemingly can't. When we get penned in we panic which to me suggests we're not comfortable playing on the counter. For penned in read pressed high up the field.
 
BillyShears said:
Sabster said:
BillyShears said:
It's not either or though Sabster. Top teams need to have the capacity to play both ways which the likes of Madrid Barca do.

Do you watch Spanish football???

Neither Madrid or Barca have a plab B...

Madrid get complete shut out by teams who don't come at them and Barca play one way...

This idea that they have plan Bs is a complete rubbish

Yes I do watch Spanish football mate. I was talking about counter attacking and possession football. Top teams can play both ways but seemingly can't. When we get penned in we panic which to me suggests we're not comfortable playing on the counter. For penned in read pressed high up the field.

Real Madrid solely play counter attacking football.... (They bring the other team on)

Barcelona the complete opposite (they can counter attack quite well because of Messi but they rarely need to... )<br /><br />-- Sat Mar 16, 2013 5:14 pm --<br /><br />
BillyShears said:
Sabster said:
BillyShears said:
It's not either or though Sabster. Top teams need to have the capacity to play both ways which the likes of Madrid Barca do.

Do you watch Spanish football???

Neither Madrid or Barca have a plab B...

Madrid get complete shut out by teams who don't come at them and Barca play one way...

This idea that they have plan Bs is a complete rubbish

Yes I do watch Spanish football mate. I was talking about counter attacking and possession football. Top teams can play both ways but seemingly can't. When we get penned in we panic which to me suggests we're not comfortable playing on the counter. For penned in read pressed high up the field.

Real Madrid solely play counter attacking football.... (They bring the other team on)

Barcelona the complete opposite (they can counter attack quite well because of Messi but they rarely need to... )
 
Marvin said:
Winning the Premier League was an enormous achievement for City and Mancini and it's shocking to see how quickly it's all forgotten and dismissed


Do you mean by us , as fans ..... or the players ?????

Because the players don't appear to have been prepared to defend that title right from the very start of this campaign !
 
Real's style is a 2-in-1. They have width and pace (Ronaldo, Di Maria) and technical playmakers (Ozil, Modric... Alonso from deeper). I'd love it if we could line up like that, it'd work very well in England I think. Yes it won't always work against parked buses but there is a higher probability it will. Silva would be less oppressed in such a system too.
 
BillyShears said:
Sabster said:
BillyShears said:
It's not either or though Sabster. Top teams need to have the capacity to play both ways which the likes of Madrid Barca do.

Do you watch Spanish football???

Neither Madrid or Barca have a plab B...

Madrid get complete shut out by teams who don't come at them and Barca play one way...

This idea that they have plan Bs is a complete rubbish

Yes I do watch Spanish football mate. I was talking about counter attacking and possession football. Top teams can play both ways but seemingly can't. When we get penned in we panic which to me suggests we're not comfortable playing on the counter. For penned in read pressed high up the field.
Mancini in car on way to airport while players in shower v southhampton was more bollocks from you wasnt it?
 
samharris said:
Solihull Samba Boys said:
I like Mancini but my faith in him is beginning to wane. The majority of fans can see that we don't have the personnel to play 3-5-2 or any variation of it, that we are one-dimensional and don't move the ball quick enough.

Why should your faith be on the wane ?? catching the scum was a monumental task and most of this forum have already written off any chance of winning it this year.


Through all of our shortcomings we are still second(and will remain so) in the table with a chance of an FA cup.

And this was the expectation from most before the game today, nowt has really changed except we lost away at Everton and Mancinis tactics were wrong..

what manager gets them right week in week out without fail ?? Not one.

It has nothing to dow ith catching the rags. It's about the performance of the team and his continual forcing of this 3 back system that clearly doesn't work for us. I just don't get why he tries to use the 3-5-2 against the top clubs, and at their ground to boot. That doesn't make sense to me. We had a number of clean sheets in a row and then we go to this stupid 3 back system and give up 3(I'm counting the offside goal cause he wasn't offside). If he used it against QPR and the like that would make sense. Teams that we are going to dominate posesion against are gonna park the bus and aren't likely to take advantage of the system going forward. Yet those teams we stay with a back 4. But clubs we have had trouble with year in year out, we go to a back 3. We had a great chance to lock up 2nd place. Now it's back to a fight with Spurs and we have to go to WHL. If we don't get a result there the pressure will really be on.
 
sniff said:
Sabster said:
Blue Heaven said:
This applies to the entire midfield, inside and out. No width, no pace. No wonder then, that there is never an effective Plan B, when needed.

What plan B do Barca or Madrid have???

We should not be aspiring to play caveman football with wingers as soo many want.

The same caveman football like MADRID... with those two handy and fast fellas on the wing.. erm DiMaria and Ronaldo.. that caveman football seems to be doing the trick for them... seems to be doing the likes of Bayen and Dortmund quite well too...

Not to mention that the Purple Conch has been winning Prem titles for decades with it.
 
Marvin said:
Dortmund were 20 points behind last time I looked - seems there's a whole host of people ready to take cheap pot shots at our manager

Yeah, and we're almost 15 points behind Utd and were out of the CL by mid November....I'm sure your research also uncovered the fact that Dortmund are still in the CL QF's.....and I wouldn't fancy our chances if we were playing them next week.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top